I'm a first amendment guy in general. Let people state their case as they see fit. Others can ignore, engage, discuss, or make whatever comment they wish...or none at all.
Personal opinion - Buckeye Homer has in pretty short order become a valuable member of this board. I enjoy reading his commentary, and it's the type of posts I enjoy. I may not agree with every word, but they are well-reasoned, detailed, and backed up by his personal insight or available facts.
I'd personally like to see more Buckeye Homers on this board. It elevates the discussion and keeps me interested.
That said, I'm just a fan and I want more fans to discuss things with, so I don't want to run anyone off. We're all made differently. Some are dour by nature. Some are just bursting with optimism. Let's allow for all thoughts and styles. If you don't like it - place them on ignore. Just my two cents.