maverick512000
Hall of Fame
I don't know about others, but my no. 1 was Mahomes, so it wasn't me who said that Watson would be a superstar if he was drafted by the Chiefs.
I do think strongly that he'd been quite better than being with the Texans.
.....
I never cared about separate evaluation on QBs by anybody because I've seen some of the best in the business (like Greg Cossell) miss on them badly.
...
PFF is constantly bad though.
Not only you'd have to mortgage the team to trade up to draft Trubisky, but you would also miss on Mahomes at 29 (where they slotted him).
PFF admits they were too low on Patrick Mahomes during 2017 NFL draft
PFF went over some of their NFL draft misses during recent years.www.google.com
I get it and again keep in mind that when I posted the article I didn't even look at where they slotted him I looked entirely at what they said his strengths and weaknesses are and tried to remember how closely that matched what I read on the NFL.com one. I wish I could find that because its strictly a scouting report and doesn't project anything but what round they will be drafted in. Now I do think scouts and draft predictors get a bad rap because their job is to predict the future and if they get it wrong then they are considered bad at their job even though there are so many factors that its insane. Would Trubisky have been better if KC had drafted him? Would Mahomes have been as good if Chicago drafted him? These are questions we will never know the answers to but they are factors that have to be considered if you are a draft predictor evaluating a QB.
Thats why I pretty much just read the strengths and weaknesses and then compare it to what others people/sites say. It's by no means perfect but if multiple people are saying the same thing then its worth considering what they are saying and taking a look at.