Smith did okay getting the defensive guys to make it top ten.
if your head offensive "chef" can't cook up a good offense (like the defensive chef did) do you blame the delivery boy or the cook?
2006 core defensive players before Smith took the reign:
Mario (1), Weaver (a former 2nd rounder), Demeco (2) Greenwood (3rd), Dunta (1), Babin (1).
That was a good core to build around.
Ụnder Smith:
Okoye (1) Failed.
Bennett (4), Harrison (5), both Fs.
Molden (3) F,
Adibi (4) average.
Barber (6) nobody.
Cushing (1), not up to draft status.
Barwin (2) not bad, but gone
Quin (4) good, but was replaced by Ed Reed. Bad move.
McCain (6) OK for his draft position.
Jackson (1) unspectacular, a B.
Mitchell (3), average at best
Sharpton (4), average.
McManis (5), nobody.
Watt (1) , great, but more like a Wade's pick.
Reeds (2), not bad, but gone.
Harris (2) F
Carmichael (4), F
Kéo (5) OK, but gone
Merciless (1) Good, but now somewhat expensive.
Crick (4), not bad for his draft slot, but now gone. ( could sign for cheap)
DJS (2), headcase, Failed.
Montgomery (3), gone
T Williams (4) nobody
C Jones (6) PS player
Clowney (1), McNair's boy, and an obvious pick.
Nix (3) Gone
Pagan (6) jury still out
Kevin J (1) average at best for his spot.
McKinney (2) good downhill, suspect in coverage
Client (6) jury still out
Covington (6) not bad for his spot, jury still out for long term.
Dillon (5) Reader (5) jury still out
I don't see much result overall pertaining to Smith, do you?