TexansSeminole
Hall of Fame
Yeah, that Jeff Allen had actual experience against the big boys. Glad we signed him. He was a guarantee.
Keep Texans Talk Google Ad Free!
Venmo Tip Jar | Paypal Tip Jar
Thanks for your support! 🍺😎👍
If you're responding to my post, I think the word I used was "mitigate", which is considerably different than guarantee. But then again, I'm pretty sure you knew that when you called me out on something I didn't say.Yeah, that Jeff Allen had actual experience against the big boys. Glad we signed him. He was a guarantee.
If you're responding to my post, I think the word I used was "mitigate", which is considerably different than guarantee. But then again, I'm pretty sure you knew that when you called me out on something I didn't say.
Yeah, that Jeff Allen had actual experience against the big boys. Glad we signed him. He was a guarantee.
I'm sick of this stupid argument about a second round pick.
Is a future, hopefully late round 2 draft pick, worth the cap space that was freed up and a potential locker room cancer being removed? That's what the question ultimately boils down to. That's a hard one to answer when you consider Smith's draft history. I can see both sides of this argument and, ultimately, I don't care. I'm glad that Os is in the rearview mirror.Then people need to stop with the, "We needed to get Brock out of the locker room" argument.
If you want to argue the merit of the cap space freed up, that's fine. But if the goal was simply to get him out of Houston we didn't need to dump a 2nd round pick to do it.
Is a future, hopefully late round 2 draft pick, worth the cap space that was freed up and a potential locker room cancer being removed? That's what the question ultimately boils down to. That's a hard one to answer when you consider Smith's draft history. I can see both sides of this argument and, ultimately, I don't care. I'm glad that Os is in the rearview mirror.
Brother, I have wholly adopted your version of fandom. I will watch every single thing that I can that is Texan, but I'm not emotionally involved. What happens will happen and I will hope for the best but not even bother to expect the worst.Yep. At the end of the day, this is what it comes down to.
I'm too cynical to get emotional about any of it, much less insult other fans or care about being insulted.
This organization is inept. They are pretty good at .500+1 in a crappy division, but nothing I've seen since 2002 really leads me to believe that they can be anything other than what we've seen for 15 years.
So I'm just eatin' my popcorn.
On a random throwing darts moment, wouldn't it be funny if they sent Brock to the Browns out of spite?Nah, "of course not!". . .
On a random throwing darts moment, wouldn't it be funny if they sent Brock to the Browns out of spite?Nah, "of course not!". . .
I see your Jeff Allen and raise you a Antonio Smiff.Yeah, that Jeff Allen had actual experience against the big boys. Glad we signed him. He was a guarantee.
I see your Jeff Allen and raise you a Antonio Smiff.
![]()
Are you insinuating sending a QB to the Browns could constitute cruel and unusual punishment? Lol. Watching Osweiler attempt to throw on the shores of Lake Erie in cold weather and getting slammed to the frozen ground might not be a pretty sight. I'm really curious as to what the Browns plan to do with Osweiler, especially with Cleveland cutting RG3 loose.
Is a future, hopefully late round 2 draft pick, worth the cap space that was freed up and a potential locker room cancer being removed? That's what the question ultimately boils down to.
Just to clarify a little bit:
The Texans received the 3rd to last pick in the 4th round and gave up the 4th pick in the 6th round. We moved up 46 picks there. It probably sounds like it should be more like 70, but it's not.
I thought they got Browns' higher pick in Rd 4. Clearly remember seeing multiple messages about that last Thursday.
2nd round picks are NOT easy to come by. They are an assumed starting football player. A potentially great player locked into a minuscule contract, a part of the foundation of building the team
There's not a Texans fan in the world who's not happy Brock's gone. The only difference is that some (you for example) think that a 2nd round pick was too high a price to pay to make that happen. Others (me for example) think that $16 million in cap space (10 immediately, 6 more next season) was reasonable compensation for a 2nd round pick, and you get rid of Brock to boot. I believe league-wide statistics indicate the odds of finding a consistent starter in round two are about 50/50 (although it's somewhat dependent on the position drafted), so I'm good with using that money for finding an established NFL player and mitigating the risk of adding a bust.
I'm not as certain as some that the Texans did the deal because (and only because) Romo is expected to become available, but that's neither here nor there, as no matter what happens or doesn't happen between the Texans and Romo, we'll never definitively find out that answer. Regardless, I don't view it as $10 million for Romo - I view it as $16 Million they wouldn't have if they'd kept or cut Osweiler, and they can use it for whoever they want, whenever they want (this year, next year, whenever).
You view it your way, I view it my way, you're not gonna convince me I'm wrong, and the chances of me convincing you you're wrong are probably identical.
And this is the main point. When you hit on these players, it provides great flexibility, because of the return vs the contract. It allows you to add more to your team in FA, where you rarely are able to get more than what you pay for and instead usually get less. When you trade those picks away, you are essentially banking on your ability to sign contracts with vets at a rate that is equal or less than their value.
It's hard enough to build a great team. You need to hit on these players in order to be at the top, nobody can pay full price for every player and be a championship contender. We just lost one of our limited chances to achieve that.
Easy now TK. You run the risk of being labeled a whiner if you dont like the trade. It's our duty as Texans fans to walk the company line and stomach the shoveled turds. Just pretend it's all unicorns and rainbows...
Ricky McNair wouldn't have a clue about what this post is about.
Roster building to Ricky is like a big foot sighting.
Easy now TK. You run the risk of being labeled a whiner if you dont like the trade. It's our duty as Texans fans to walk the company line and stomach the shoveled turds. Just pretend it's all unicorns and rainbows...
It's getting to be very hard to take what you say with any credibility when you incessantly use that stupid nickname for Rick Smith. Is this 7th grade?
Or alternatively, people just have different opinions than yours on the subject.
McNair is in a bubble.
Rick has been his "GM" forever and he only interviewed O'Brien and Lovie Smith (Rooney rule) for the last coaching job.
Maybe if he interviewed multiple candidates for coach AND GM he'd get some idea on how to build a team (for example by not throwing away draft picks for no reason)
We shall see who has the better career, BO or O'b. I say Bo does.This is a guy who straight sucks.
Pick. Singular.
We shall see who has the better career, BO or O'b. I say Bo does.
Easy.Huh ?? What ?!
I'm confused , clarify this BO OB sh!t.
Easy.
BO = Brock
OB = O'Brien
How many for nix and strong?
In general they've been way too careless with picks since Obrien got here.
Not careful with compensatory picks either (foregoing them with Daniels and Manning)
Geez man. Look up his history (rickys) on picks and free agents. There's usually some merit to need in every pick (usually) , but dont come knockin on the door like some two bit car salesman trying to sell us Tupperware.
![]()
Or not use the cap space at all, which appears to be what's happening.
Also the odds of Ricky getting more than a XSF type starter appears to be less than 50-50.
You said "throw away for no reason". Both Nix and Strong graded well and were a position of need. Being busts is not the same as throwing away picks.![]()
like when NE traded 2 places ahead of us to land Garoppolo?Fair enough. But in general, the smart teams don't trade up, they tend to trade down and add more picks. Not always, just generally speaking.
like when NE traded 2 places ahead of us to land Garoppolo?![]()
you're rightI don't think that happened. Are you thinking of Minnesota and Bridgewater?
you're right
I thought they traded to get that pick but actually it was always a NE pick. I guess my memory registered as a surprise pick because I wasn't expecting NE to draft a QB in the second, and in time the memory morphed into "NE traded up to get garoppolo"
Yes, I just wasn't expecting them to draft one in the second round.That's interesting they have continually drafted QBs even when they had Brady. Heck they drafted Brissett even though they had Brady AND Jimmy G. It's all about value for them. They know they can trade these QBs for more later.
Yes, I just wasn't expecting them to draft one in the second round.