Keep Texans Talk Google Ad Free!
Venmo Tip Jar | Paypal Tip Jar
Thanks for your support! 🍺😎👍

You are GM of the Texans for the next 4 months

Musgrave is a top end talent, He can threaten the middle of the field and is a really good blocker. A playmaker, if you put an Musgrave/Quitoriano at TE and Schmitz at center those 3rd and shorts get converted. With Smith in the middle and I hope Givens comes with Ryans from the 49ers and the run defense will look much better. Benton is really showing out at the Sr. Bowl too, so there are options at the DT position. Build the trenches.

If you want to run the ball better and stop the run, these are the guys that can help accomplish this. Each one of these guys are dominate guys.
Right, build in the trenches. Musgrave doesn't help there. I'm not taking a TE before the 3rd round, if at all. I think we have much bigger needs than TE, and I'm sure we can get a FA TE if needed. I'd also be interested to know what they think of the TE's we have on the practice squad.
 
Right, build in the trenches. Musgrave doesn't help there. I'm not taking a TE before the 3rd round, if at all. I think we have much bigger needs than TE, and I'm sure we can get a FA TE if needed. I'd also be interested to know what they think of the TE's we have on the practice squad.
TEs in the lower rounds typically take time to adjust - we need as many impact players as we can get.
 
I agree. However, Metchie is supposed to be that guy. If he's not, I'd love to have Hyatt. My issue with taking Hyatt is that he would probably stop you from getting a big #1. If I could get both Johnston and Hyatt, or Hyatt and Rice, sign me up. I just want to make sure we get that next AJ or D-Hop.
You act like D-Hop and AJ type of guys grow on trees. You're talking HOF caliber players. Metchie is a slot at best vs a guy like Boyd who is big and plays the slot. Hyatt is a homerun hitter which creates a tyreke hill type of coverage. I like Johnston, but I do want to see how fast he runs.
 
Right, build in the trenches. Musgrave doesn't help there. I'm not taking a TE before the 3rd round, if at all. I think we have much bigger needs than TE, and I'm sure we can get a FA TE if needed. I'd also be interested to know what they think of the TE's we have on the practice squad.
A great blocking TE certainly does help in the trenches.
 
A great blocking TE certainly does help in the trenches.
The Eagles have high end trench guys, tell me about their te. Tell me about the 1 from KC also. Thing is, te's who can only block or run a seam route is like a NT who is just a run stopper. The middle of the field is wide open in the nfl and if you don't have a guy who can consistently exploit that, you're limiting your offense. Me personally, I think Akins can jump a bunch of notches in a west coast offense with his ability to run. I never understood why they didn't use him more.
 
The Eagles have high end trench guys, tell me about their te. Tell me about the 1 from KC also. Thing is, te's who can only block or run a seam route is like a NT who is just a run stopper. The middle of the field is wide open in the nfl and if you don't have a guy who can consistently exploit that, you're limiting your offense. Me personally, I think Akins can jump a bunch of notches in a west coast offense with his ability to run. I never understood why they didn't use him more.
I think Musgrave can be that guy.

Akins has improved but he will never be more than an avg blocker at best. I'm all about drafting to the strength of the draft and TE is a strength this yr.

Give me my #1 wr at 1-12 and my #1 TE at 2-32 and I'm happy. I realize that my evals are different than the draftniks.
 
I would be very happy if Ryan's 1st four picks looked like this

1-12 Schmitz
2-33 Musgrave
3-64 Smith I would trade up if needed.

This would solve getting their butts kicked in the trenches every week.

Schmitz is not a 1-12 talent.

Musgrave is not worth that pick. He’s like the 5th best TE, at best. Why did you get off Washington?

Like Smith, prefer Benton.
 
From what I have seen, Musgrave isn't a great blocker. Right now we have Brevin Jordan, Teagan Quitoriano, and Mason Schreck. I expect the Texans to bring back Akins. Schreck got to play in a couple games, and didn't look too bad. With another offseason, I think he will be as good if not better than Musgrave.
 
The HC just left a team that had TE as a major part of the offense. And the Texans have one of, if not the, weakest TE groups in the league.
That’s because the Texans didn’t utilize the TE’s position right. So of course we’re going to look at like it was weak. Put Jordan, Howard and Akins on the the 49ers team and they’re thriving easily.
 
I don’t see them drafting a TE this year.
Why? All our TEs suck. What we’ve done in the past is irrelevant now. If you’re going to spend major assets to bring in a young QB why wouldn’t you want him to have a safety blanket TE? This is a deep TE draft.
 
This is a highlight reel of Musgrave from last season. Not a random game, where maybe he doesn't play his best. These are his highlights.

Count how many tackles he breaks during this video. His highlight video.

Give me some of that.
 
The HC just left a team that had TE as a major part of the offense. And the Texans have one of, if not the, weakest TE groups in the league.
My question is for the season we expect in 2023, is TE a high priority this draft?
 
Why? All our TEs suck. What we’ve done in the past is irrelevant now. If you’re going to spend major assets to bring in a young QB why wouldn’t you want him to have a safety blanket TE? This is a deep TE draft.
Bijan better blanket, huge stats and good blocking; blew up PFF records on tackles broken. Great RB with great hands as WR. He knows how to get to end zone. Can remain on field either position.
 
FA: I) Top priority is address LB.

I would sign Tremaine Edmunds and Azeez Al-Shaair. I would focus here in FA for two reasons:

1) The draft is shallow in starting LB talent and I don’t want to be forced into burning a high pick on a position that I identify as a major weakness.

2) I want veterans who understand how to do their job play in play out. This is particularly important to fix the horrible tackling the defense put on display last season.

The LB position has been neglected ever since DeMeco and Cushing left. DeMeco puts an end to that and gets dependable veterans who know how to wrap up and tackle as well as perform their coverage responsibilities. Tremaine Edmunds fills the Fred Warner role in this defense and the hope is that DeMeco and the extra $$ he’ll be getting will raise his game to the level of Fred Warner or close. Certainly better than Kirksey.

Al-Shaair competes with Christian Harris to see who gets to stay on the field with Edmunds when the team is in nickel. We will finally see LBs leading the team in tackles again.

II) Sign Jimmie Ward.

This would be a 2-3 year contract because Ward is getting older. But in that time span he will fulfill the value of the contract. Expectation is for him to be the deep safety so Pitre can be unleashed in the Hufanga role. Ward and Shaair will bring their experience in DeMeco’s scheme with them to dispense that knowledge on their new teammates. Ward in particular is valuable for this because he played every position in SF’s secondary and understands all the coverage responsibilities. Ward is a sizeable upgrade over Johnathan Owens and will not break the bank in FA. Tackling, coverage and veteran leadership all upgraded.

III) Sign Garrett Bradbury and Mike Mcglinchey. Maybe both is a bit unrealistic. But if DeMeco changes scheme both fit the needs of the outside zone rushing attack. If Mcglinchey is signed then Tytus Howard is traded for picks. I’ve seen Howard at guard and don’t want to pay him for that.

IV) Sign Charles Omenihu or Samson Ebukam. I feel good about the DEs on this team and in the draft so this would be lower priority. But it wouldn’t hurt to bring productive players from DeMeco’s last team to help acclimate everyone to the system and secure one position. Add re-signing Ogbo Okoronkwo to this list. Jerry Hughes was a massive value steal and i’d like to keep that trend going. Can’t have too many pass rushers. Let Rasheem Green walk and replace his reps with Omenihu or Ebukam.

V) Sign DJ Chark if he can be had around 8-10 million. He is a tall WR that can stretch the field. It would be nice to have a veteran deep threat. But if he doesn’t come cheap I don’t mind finding someone who fits that mold in the draft. Just would be nice to add prior to the draft so as not to reach.

VI) Re-sign Tavierre Thomas. I love the depth at nickel CB with Thomas and King.

Now onto the draft. Assuming I get my wish list in FA here is what i’d do first 4 rounds:

1-2) Jalen Carter. This defense is now a problem for teams! Carter elevates the play of everyone around him on defense and provides one on one matchups for the other DL to exploit as well as helps keep the LBs clean. Of course if a trade down is available I take it.

1-12) Best WR available. Would love to trade out of this pick and secure more picks in the 2nd-3rd. Depth of draft is not great and want to get as much in the top 100 as possible or add picks next year. But if I have to pick… I’m adding Anthony Richardson if he’s here to audition as franchise QB and one of my top three QBs are not. Johnson, Addison, Smith-Njigba in that order. Also may go Bijan Robinson here if BPA and I get to run 40+ times/game with the best RB duo this side of Chubb/Hunt.

2-33) Best TE available. Mayer or Washington should be here hopefully and would give this offense the George Kittle it needs. Tired of tip toeing around the TE issue throwing late picks at JAGs hoping they blossom. Give me a premier talent.

3-65) Best RB available. If I take Bijan at 12 then its best WR available. I am partial to Devon Achane here. I think him and Pierce could be on the field at the same time in certain packages.

3-73 and 4-108) Best CB and interior OL available. Priority based on how board falls. I want to groom Steven Nelson’s replacement and provide insurance for if Stingley gets hurt again. Also want to solidify the OL.

Example selections:

3-73) Joe Tippman C Wisconsin

4-108) Riley Moss CB Iowa

*Elephant in the room… QB. I would not mind signing a FA QB to a 2-3 year deal and take pressure off picking QB high in the first round. Derek Carr, Daniel Jones and Jimmy G don’t come cheap but needs to be addressed to field a team that can compete for the AFC South.

Of course with this draft I don’t take a QB. If that’s the case then I need to add a veteran to compete with Mills in camp (one of those three or maybe Minshew if i’m pinching pennies) and may add a rookie like Haener or O’connell with one of those 3rds (hopefully added from Cooks trade, and/or trade down, trading the excess sixths in a package and/or trading Howard).

This team is now competing for the AFC South and is in line with DeMeco’s vision for the team.
 
Last edited:
You're going to have to use 1.12 for Bijan
I wouldn't hate the Bijan pick, even though there are better needs. Love Pierce, but I'm unconvinced he'll be a 'horse' kind of back. I see him as more of a 150-200 rush/season guy - a good combo package back to share the load with another strong back. Runs with too much reckless abandon and not big enough to shoulder a massive load. Pierce and Bijan would be an awesome duo.

But no question getting an alpha WR1 with a big catch radius is more important. That element was very much missing from the offense, and definitely hurt Mills production. It will stunt the new QB if/when he comes in here also if not addressed.
 
FA: I) Top priority is address LB.

I would sign Tremaine Edmunds and Azeez Al-Shaair.
I like these 2 players and support such a decision. But after Roquan Smith set the market, that'll cost you $30M+ annually between the two. That's a lot to pay for 2 LBs. Probably more realistic to shoot for 1 or the other, which should be fine if Harris continues to progress.
 
I like these 2 players and support such a decision. But after Roquan Smith set the market, that'll cost you $30M+ annually between the two. That's a lot to pay for 2 LBs. Probably more realistic to shoot for 1 or the other, which should be fine if Harris continues to progress.

True. But I suspect DeMeco values the LBs higher than most. Without Fred Warner in particular that 49er defense loses a lot of its flexibility. Coverage in the deep middle taking pressure off the DBs and reliably filling gaps in the run game are gone. That’s why its my top priority. To get a defense like DeMeco wants you need to have the best LBs in the league. And I am willing to pay for that in FA versus say paying close to that same amount for premier trench players I can get in the draft (Jalen Carter).
 
FA: I) Top priority is address LB.

I would sign Tremaine Edmunds and Azeez Al-Shaair. I would focus here in FA for two reasons:

1) The draft is shallow in starting LB talent and I don’t want to be forced into burning a high pick on a position that I identify as a major weakness.

2) I want veterans who understand how to do their job play in play out. This is particularly important to fix the horrible tackling the defense put on display last season.

The LB position has been neglected ever since DeMeco and Cushing left. DeMeco puts an end to that and gets dependable veterans who know how to wrap up and tackle as well as perform their coverage responsibilities. Tremaine Edmunds fills the Fred Warner role in this defense and the hope is that DeMeco and the extra $$ he’ll be getting will raise his game to the level of Fred Warner or close. Certainly better than Kirksey.

Al-Shaair competes with Christian Harris to see who gets to stay on the field with Edmunds when the team is in nickel. We will finally see LBs leading the team in tackles again.

II) Sign Jimmie Ward.

This would be a 2-3 year contract because Ward is getting older. But in that time span he will fulfill the value of the contract. Expectation is for him to be the deep safety so Pitre can be unleashed in the Hufanga role. Ward and Shaair will bring their experience in DeMeco’s scheme with them to dispense that knowledge on their new teammates. Ward in particular is valuable for this because he played every position in SF’s secondary and understands all the coverage responsibilities. Ward is a sizeable upgrade over Johnathan Owens and will not break the bank in FA. Tackling, coverage and veteran leadership all upgraded.

III) Sign Garrett Bradbury and Mike Mcglinchey. Maybe both is a bit unrealistic. But if DeMeco changes scheme both fit the needs of the outside zone rushing attack. If Mcglinchey is signed then Tytus Howard is traded for picks. I’ve seen Howard at guard and don’t want to pay him for that.

IV) Sign Charles Omenihu or Samson Ebukam. I feel good about the DEs on this team and in the draft so this would be lower priority. But it wouldn’t hurt to bring productive players from DeMeco’s last team to help acclimate everyone to the system and secure one position. Add re-signing Ogbo Okoronkwo to this list. Jerry Hughes was a massive value steal and i’d like to keep that trend going. Can’t have too many pass rushers. Let Rasheem Green walk and replace his reps with Omenihu or Ebukam.

V) Sign DJ Chark if he can be had around 8-10 million. He is a tall WR that can stretch the field. It would be nice to have a veteran deep threat. But if he doesn’t come cheap I don’t mind finding someone who fits that mold in the draft. Just would be nice to add prior to the draft so as not to reach.

VI) Re-sign Tavierre Thomas. I love the depth at nickel CB with Thomas and King.

Now onto the draft. Assuming I get my wish list in FA here is what i’d do first 4 rounds:

1-2) Jalen Carter. This defense is now a problem for teams! Carter elevates the play of everyone around him on defense and provides one on one matchups for the other DL to exploit as well as helps keep the LBs clean. Of course if a trade down is available I take it.

1-12) Best WR available. Would love to trade out of this pick and secure more picks in the 2nd-3rd. Depth of draft is not great and want to get as much in the top 100 as possible or add picks next year. But if I have to pick… I’m adding Anthony Richardson if he’s here to audition as franchise QB and one of my top three QBs are not. Johnson, Addison, Smith-Njigba in that order. Also may go Bijan Robinson here if BPA and I get to run 40+ times/game with the best RB duo this side of Chubb/Hunt.

2-33) Best TE available. Mayer or Washington should be here hopefully and would give this offense the George Kittle it needs. Tired of tip toeing around the TE issue throwing late picks at JAGs hoping they blossom. Give me a premier talent.

3-65) Best RB available. If I take Bijan at 12 then its best WR available. I am partial to Devon Achane here. I think him and Pierce could be on the field at the same time in certain packages.

3-73 and 4-108) Best CB and interior OL available. Priority based on how board falls. I want to groom Steven Nelson’s replacement and provide insurance for if Stingley gets hurt again. Also want to solidify the OL.

Example selections:

3-73) Joe Tippman C Wisconsin

4-108) Riley Moss CB Iowa

*Elephant in the room… QB. I would not mind signing a FA QB to a 2-3 year deal and take pressure off picking QB high in the first round. Derek Carr, Daniel Jones and Jimmy G don’t come cheap but needs to be addressed to field a team that can compete for the AFC South.

Of course with this draft I don’t take a QB. If that’s the case then I need to add a veteran to compete with Mills in camp (one of those three or maybe Minshew if i’m pinching pennies) and may add a rookie like Haener or O’connell with one of those 3rds (hopefully added from Cooks trade, and/or trade down, trading the excess sixths in a package and/or trading Howard).

This team is now competing for the AFC South and is in line with DeMeco’s vision for the team.
Not counting on this happening obviously, but Jalen Carter would be so helpful towards anchoring the middle DL and tightening up the absolutely wretched run defense. Even if Carter performs similar to Tavon Walker, he can change things being a load and taking on double teams in the middle. Christian Harris emergence helped the run defense a little, but need that middle DL anchor to really make it respectable. If they can get a guy like Javon Hargreaves, that also would work.
 
True. But I suspect DeMeco values the LBs higher than most. Without Fred Warner in particular that 49er defense loses a lot of its flexibility. Coverage in the deep middle taking pressure off the DBs and reliably filling gaps in the run game are gone. That’s why its my top priority. To get a defense like DeMeco wants you need to have the best LBs in the league. And I am willing to pay for that in FA versus say paying close to that same amount for premier trench players I can get in the draft (Jalen Carter).
Fair enough. Not against the idea at all, but you will pay almost franchise QB price tag for it. If that's what Ryans wants, all for it. He's got a ton of political capital in which to sculp the roster in Year 1 (a$ much a$ management will allow)
 
FA: I) Top priority is address LB.

I would sign Tremaine Edmunds and Azeez Al-Shaair. I would focus here in FA for two reasons:

1) The draft is shallow in starting LB talent and I don’t want to be forced into burning a high pick on a position that I identify as a major weakness.

2) I want veterans who understand how to do their job play in play out. This is particularly important to fix the horrible tackling the defense put on display last season.

The LB position has been neglected ever since DeMeco and Cushing left. DeMeco puts an end to that and gets dependable veterans who know how to wrap up and tackle as well as perform their coverage responsibilities. Tremaine Edmunds fills the Fred Warner role in this defense and the hope is that DeMeco and the extra $$ he’ll be getting will raise his game to the level of Fred Warner or close. Certainly better than Kirksey.

Al-Shaair competes with Christian Harris to see who gets to stay on the field with Edmunds when the team is in nickel. We will finally see LBs leading the team in tackles again.

II) Sign Jimmie Ward.

This would be a 2-3 year contract because Ward is getting older. But in that time span he will fulfill the value of the contract. Expectation is for him to be the deep safety so Pitre can be unleashed in the Hufanga role. Ward and Shaair will bring their experience in DeMeco’s scheme with them to dispense that knowledge on their new teammates. Ward in particular is valuable for this because he played every position in SF’s secondary and understands all the coverage responsibilities. Ward is a sizeable upgrade over Johnathan Owens and will not break the bank in FA. Tackling, coverage and veteran leadership all upgraded.

III) Sign Garrett Bradbury and Mike Mcglinchey. Maybe both is a bit unrealistic. But if DeMeco changes scheme both fit the needs of the outside zone rushing attack. If Mcglinchey is signed then Tytus Howard is traded for picks. I’ve seen Howard at guard and don’t want to pay him for that.

IV) Sign Charles Omenihu or Samson Ebukam. I feel good about the DEs on this team and in the draft so this would be lower priority. But it wouldn’t hurt to bring productive players from DeMeco’s last team to help acclimate everyone to the system and secure one position. Add re-signing Ogbo Okoronkwo to this list. Jerry Hughes was a massive value steal and i’d like to keep that trend going. Can’t have too many pass rushers. Let Rasheem Green walk and replace his reps with Omenihu or Ebukam.

V) Sign DJ Chark if he can be had around 8-10 million. He is a tall WR that can stretch the field. It would be nice to have a veteran deep threat. But if he doesn’t come cheap I don’t mind finding someone who fits that mold in the draft. Just would be nice to add prior to the draft so as not to reach.

VI) Re-sign Tavierre Thomas. I love the depth at nickel CB with Thomas and King.

Now onto the draft. Assuming I get my wish list in FA here is what i’d do first 4 rounds:

1-2) Jalen Carter. This defense is now a problem for teams! Carter elevates the play of everyone around him on defense and provides one on one matchups for the other DL to exploit as well as helps keep the LBs clean. Of course if a trade down is available I take it.

1-12) Best WR available. Would love to trade out of this pick and secure more picks in the 2nd-3rd. Depth of draft is not great and want to get as much in the top 100 as possible or add picks next year. But if I have to pick… I’m adding Anthony Richardson if he’s here to audition as franchise QB and one of my top three QBs are not. Johnson, Addison, Smith-Njigba in that order. Also may go Bijan Robinson here if BPA and I get to run 40+ times/game with the best RB duo this side of Chubb/Hunt.

2-33) Best TE available. Mayer or Washington should be here hopefully and would give this offense the George Kittle it needs. Tired of tip toeing around the TE issue throwing late picks at JAGs hoping they blossom. Give me a premier talent.

3-65) Best RB available. If I take Bijan at 12 then its best WR available. I am partial to Devon Achane here. I think him and Pierce could be on the field at the same time in certain packages.

3-73 and 4-108) Best CB and interior OL available. Priority based on how board falls. I want to groom Steven Nelson’s replacement and provide insurance for if Stingley gets hurt again. Also want to solidify the OL.

Example selections:

3-73) Joe Tippman C Wisconsin

4-108) Riley Moss CB Iowa

*Elephant in the room… QB. I would not mind signing a FA QB to a 2-3 year deal and take pressure off picking QB high in the first round. Derek Carr, Daniel Jones and Jimmy G don’t come cheap but needs to be addressed to field a team that can compete for the AFC South.

Of course with this draft I don’t take a QB. If that’s the case then I need to add a veteran to compete with Mills in camp (one of those three or maybe Minshew if i’m pinching pennies) and may add a rookie like Haener or O’connell with one of those 3rds (hopefully added from Cooks trade, and/or trade down, trading the excess sixths in a package and/or trading Howard).

This team is now competing for the AFC South and is in line with DeMeco’s vision for the team.
The Texans drafted the Miss St kid and The Vandy kid while Cush was playing. How did they neglect the position? I like some of your suggestion, allow me to retort. Harris has the ability to do what Werner did. He has the speed and athleticism to do it. There are some very talented lbs in this draft to fill out that spot. No need to overspend on that position as much as I like Edmonds. No to Ward, he's 31. If you want vets in the secondary, between Nelson and King, they can do it with them. They need help up front and better coverage in the lb corps. I think the kid from Pitt, BJ Johnson,and the kid from Georgia Tech are going to outperform their draft positions by a long shot.

In terms of rbs, there are a gang of quality runners as usual to pair with Pierce. The shrine bowl as well as the senior bowl will show this. At wr, I've been on Hyatt for a minute because he can take the top off the defense. All sounds great, they still need a qb.
 
Not counting on this happening obviously, but Jalen Carter would be so helpful towards anchoring the middle DL and tightening up the absolutely wretched run defense. Even if Carter performs similar to Tavon Walker, he can change things being a load and taking on double teams in the middle. Christian Harris emergence helped the run defense a little, but need that middle DL anchor to really make it respectable. If they can get a guy like Javon Hargreaves, that also would work.
Walker was terrible this year even with Allen on the other side
 
The Texans drafted the Miss St kid and The Vandy kid while Cush was playing. How did they neglect the position? I like some of your suggestion, allow me to retort. Harris has the ability to do what Werner did. He has the speed and athleticism to do it. There are some very talented lbs in this draft to fill out that spot. No need to overspend on that position as much as I like Edmonds. No to Ward, he's 31. If you want vets in the secondary, between Nelson and King, they can do it with them. They need help up front and better coverage in the lb corps. I think the kid from Pitt, BJ Johnson,and the kid from Georgia Tech are going to outperform their draft positions by a long shot.

In terms of rbs, there are a gang of quality runners as usual to pair with Pierce. The shrine bowl as well as the senior bowl will show this. At wr, I've been on Hyatt for a minute because he can take the top off the defense. All sounds great, they still need a qb.


Forgot about Mckinney and Cunningham. But I still agree on my priorities for LB. I am signing Ward to a short term deal. He is still a quality player at 31. If i’m going on a spending spree i’d pay for Jessie Bates but think that $ will be needed elsewhere next few seasons and Ward shouldn’t break the bank.

Agree on RB options. Hyatt is a quality player and team needs to address WR early in draft as i’m not sold on the FA options, especially for the $.

Agree on the elephant in the room (QB). Therein lies the rub.
 
Walker was terrible this year even with Allen on the other side
100% disagree with terrible. His stats didn't pop out. But the run defense did go to 4.1 yards per rush from 4.3 (22th in yards to 12th, probably due to being in the lead more often), PFF overall grade is a pretty respectable 60.3.

If you softened the language by saying he didn't live up to #1 pick status, I'm with you. Terrible - not at all. Walker is a load in the middle, but he risks being overdrafted if he doesn't improve from here. Too early to tell.

Can you point me to the dataset which suggests Tavon Walker was "terrible"?
 
Last edited:
Forgot about Mckinney and Cunningham. But I still agree on my priorities for LB. I am signing Ward to a short term deal. He is still a quality player at 31. If i’m going on a spending spree i’d pay for Jessie Bates but think that $ will be needed elsewhere next few seasons and Ward shouldn’t break the bank.

Agree on RB options. Hyatt is a quality player and team needs to address WR early in draft as i’m not sold on the FA options, especially for the $.

Agree on the elephant in the room (QB). Therein lies the rub.
This team, imo needs to continue to get younger. Jimmy Ward is cool in SF, but we know Houston doesn't have the heat up front or the cover lbs who can close lanes down. I think if Greenard can stay healthy, he can be a 12-14 sack guy. I think that Thompson and the Pitt kid are going to wreck havoc. I think people forget that the 49ers didn't get alot of sacks last year.In fact, the Texans had more sacks than the 49ers. They stopped the run and kept people out of the end zone, but they played that cover 2 and had timely pressure.
 
100% disagree with terrible. His stats didn't pop out. But the run defense did go to 4.1 yards per rush from 4.3 (22th in yards to 12th, probably due to being in the lead more often), PFF overall grade is a pretty respectable 60.3.

If you softened the language by saying he didn't live up to #1 pick status, I'm with you. Terrible - not at all. Walker is a load in the middle, but he risks being overdrafted if he doesn't improve from here. Too early to tell.

Can you point me to the dataset which suggests Tavon Walker was "terrible"?
I watched pretty much all of Jacksonville games and you never noticed him even playing. Jacksonville screwed up on that one, They should've taken Hutchinson and the team would've been even better defensively. He wasn't good at all. I don't care how you slice and you're playing with an above avg offense and you get 3 sacks in 17 games.
 
I watched pretty much all of Jacksonville games and you never noticed him even playing. Jacksonville screwed up on that one, They should've taken Hutchinson and the team would've been even better defensively. He wasn't good at all. I don't care how you slice and you're playing with an above avg offense and you get 3 sacks in 17 games.
Fair enough. It was widely known Walker needed work as a pass rusher, and I guess he still does. Pretty sure he's helpful against the run. Should of went with Hutchinson agree.
 
Fair enough. It was widely known Walker needed work as a pass rusher, and I guess he still does. Pretty sure he's helpful against the run. Should of went with Hutchinson agree.
I didn't think that highly of Walker from the jump. People tried to make ways of talking about how he couldn't just rush the passer. Well, when he just rushed the passer in nfl, it was just a bull or straight rush. No dip,speed to power, or power to speed. You expect more from the #1 pick rushing the passer. I mean Mario Williams had like 5 sacks and he was injured.
 
My biggest desire from a solid DT is to absorb and command double teams, stuff the run, and push the pocket back on passing plays. If my DT’s (4-3) are doing this…..it’s my DE’s, LB’ers, and S’s who should be reaping the rewards from their unsung rolls.
 
I believe steelb mentioned this idea first, but I’m also coming around to the idea of trading down and eventually out of RD1 if the opportunities were presented. If those moves fill the coffers for RD2, RD3, RD4, and possibly the 2024 draft, then it may not be a bad move. I’m also feeling that this draft will be deep in RD2, RD3, RD4 with players who are going to be equally or better than those selected in RD1. Texans could be in a position to trade back and trade up from RD6 and RD7, to a point, to just about have their entire draft fall between 32 and 170….wouldn’t be a bad way to fill the new roster.
 
100% disagree with terrible.
Walker cost the Jags a win vs the Texans with the 3rd down late hit on Mills. Then, he did the same thing in the playoff game to Herbert. Somehow, the Chargers screwed that up. He was a project that should have gone in the middle of the round.

Same thing with Carter. How does a transformational player like Carter end up with the grand total of 6 sacks in his career? Carter was tied for 4th on his college team in sacks. And the guy he was tied with only played 8 games. He is the least productive d-lineman among those considered in the 1st round.

Like a QB or don't like a QB. Fine. But there's no way I'm taking a guy at 1.2 that cannot produce in college at a very high level. That's the mistake Jacksonville made last year, and it should be a lesson for every team.
 
Walker cost the Jags a win vs the Texans with the 3rd down late hit on Mills. Then, he did the same thing in the playoff game to Herbert. Somehow, the Chargers screwed that up. He was a project that should have gone in the middle of the round.

Same thing with Carter. How does a transformational player like Carter end up with the grand total of 6 sacks in his career? Carter was tied for 4th on his college team in sacks. And the guy he was tied with only played 8 games. He is the least productive d-lineman among those considered in the 1st round.

Like a QB or don't like a QB. Fine. But there's no way I'm taking a guy at 1.2 that cannot produce in college at a very high level. That's the mistake Jacksonville made last year, and it should be a lesson for every team.

Good points on Carter. Now if he was double teamed his entire college career then I guess that could play a role in low numbers. I have no clue if that was the case or not.


Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk Pro
 
Musgrave is being single handedly brought down by DBs smaller than Bryce Young. Geez.
Many of those plays he gets brought down right after catching the ball. No chance to break tackles. You're looking for reasons to not like him. What I saw was a guy making plays.
 
There's no way the Texans are doing that. @steelbtexan was silly to even mention it.

They're silly if they dont entertain the idea of trading down and getting more picks in the 2024. You know, the class with better talent and definitely better QB's. At least they should entertain the idea of trading down from 12 if it includes a 2024 1st.

I guess this really comes down to what you think of this draft class. I think this is a weak class.
 
Last edited:
I believe steelb mentioned this idea first, but I’m also coming around to the idea of trading down and eventually out of RD1 if the opportunities were presented. If those moves fill the coffers for RD2, RD3, RD4, and possibly the 2024 draft, then it may not be a bad move. I’m also feeling that this draft will be deep in RD2, RD3, RD4 with players who are going to be equally or better than those selected in RD1. Texans could be in a position to trade back and trade up from RD6 and RD7, to a point, to just about have their entire draft fall between 32 and 170….wouldn’t be a bad way to fill the new roster.
I think that the texans are locked in on Bryce young. Having said that I have offered a similar plan of trading down from 1.2 for him and other 1st round pics. Those pics can be traded down for 2nd rounders if everything falls just right.
 
Back
Top