Keep Texans Talk Google Ad Free!
Venmo Tip Jar | Paypal Tip Jar
Thanks for your support! 🍺😎👍

Texans MLK Mock

beerlover

Hall of Fame
This edition is in memory of a great leader in fight for Human Rights by non violent means. In Football & in society in general there is far too much, loss of control in emotions & respect for each other. NOTE: used one of the 5th round picks to move up in second to secure O'Brian's QB.

First Round: Jaylon Smith, LB, Notre Dame, 6-3 240

Smith tore the ACL and LCL in his left knee against Ohio State Jan. 1, but the procedure to repair the ligaments "went about as well as it possibly could have," a source with knowledge of the situation reported. Full recover is expected however instead of being a top 10 lock he slides down towards end of first round in Texan territory. Same Vision different path will overcome adversity https://twitter.com/JaeeSmiff9ENT/status/686599061173055488 Texan fans of all walks in life will love him both as a player & person.
jaylon-smith-ncaa-football-wake-forest-notre-dame-850x560.jpg


Second Round: Christian Hackenberg, QB, Penn State, 6-4 236

After being anointed coming to Penn State with new coach Bill O'Brian as the "future No. 1 overall pick" post Bill, he has struggled & dealt with his own demons of a different kind.
Penn State quarterback Christian Hackenberg is leaving school early for the NFL. Hackenberg declared his intentions following a 24-17 loss to Georgia in the TaxSlayer Bowl on Saturday. "This place means a lot to me," Hackenberg said. "It's been an awesome ride, tough way to end it today. It means the world to me. My family and I talked about it and we felt this was the best decision for me. I felt my role here and my job here has been accomplished." Hackenberg left the game in the second quarter with a right shoulder injury. Linebacker Roquan Smith landed on his shoulder after a scramble. Hackenberg stayed in the game and threw four more passes, but grabbed the shoulder between plays.

He headed to the locker room after an incompletion and returned for the second half in street clothes. He said he wanted to play, but team officials told him no. "It is what it is," said Hackenberg, who hadn't missed a snap in three years before Saturday. "I'm disappointed I wasn't able to finish the game." Hackenberg said he made his decision to turn pro before the team left State College for Jacksonville. Hackenberg, a junior, is the school's all-time leader in yards passing (8,457) and touchdowns (48) as well as completions, attempts and total offense. He completed 8 of 14 passes for 139 yards against Georgia. - AP Sports
penn-state-quarterback-christian-hackenberg.jpg



Third Round: Sebastian Tretola, OG, Arkansas, 6-5 334

Brooks will be a free agent if his agent & Texans don't agree to terms opening up a position of need on interior of OL. Tretola has been Arkansas' starting left guard over the last 23 games and has graded over 80 percent in 10 of 12 contests this season. The senior earned SEC Offensive Lineman of the Week honors earlier this season and in over 25 career games at Arkansas, he has only allowed a half-sack to help the Razorbacks lead the SEC in fewest sacks allowed the last two seasons.
1231765_web_HOGS-Allen_Tretola_141015.jpg


Fourth Round: Jordon Howard, RB, Indiana, 6-1 225

Has NFL size O'Brian covets had to overcome transferring Senior season because team he was on UAB, dropped football program so came to Indiana filling some big shoes left by Tevin Coleman (drafted 3rd rd. Atlanta). In his only season with the Hoosiers, the junior rushed for 1,213 yards and nine touchdowns despite missing the equivalent of five plus games due to injury. Despite the shortened season Howard still managed to finish third in the Big Ten in rushing and has set himself up to be one of the top backs in the 2016 draft.

04e7411fb54abf2bd469a7cd1e6e1265.jpg


Fifth Round: Willie Henry, DT, Michigan, 6-3 311

Better suited inside than Crick, who will be a free agent, Willie can work himself in the rotation to fill nose tackle in Crennel's 3-4.
https://twitter.com/WE_69
http://touch-the-banner.com/defensive-tackle-willie-henry-declares-for-nfl-draft/
willie-henry-ncaa-football-utah-michigan-850x560.jpg


Fifth Round: Texan GM Rick Smith trades up in 2nd round using 5th round pick to the Giants jumping ahead of Chicago, New Orleans & Philly.

Sixth Round: Sean Price, TE, South Florida, 6-3 249

Fluid with soft hands that can run after the catch. Fits in a New England style where a QB can spread defenses out by distributing the ball, good open field blocker & adds another offensive weapon @ position of need. 6-3, 249-pound Price brings 42 career receptions into his third season at USF, after posting 21 catches in each of his first two seasons. Price is the only American Athletic Conference player selected to the 2014 watch list of 38 players nationwide. Price was a preseason first-team all-conference selection by Phil Steele. Raised by his grandparents he was voted homecoming king ... spent numerous hours volunteering to clean his school and in the community ... participated in car wash fundraisers ... earned academic honors all four years.
c7s_PriceTD121915_16461064_8col.jpg
 
This edition is in memory of a great leader in fight for Human Rights by non violent means. In Football & in society in general there is far too much, loss of control in emotions & respect for each other. NOTE: used one of the 5th round picks to move up in second to secure O'Brian's QB.

First Round: Jaylon Smith, LB, Notre Dame, 6-3 240

Smith tore the ACL and LCL in his left knee against Ohio State Jan. 1, but the procedure to repair the ligaments "went about as well as it possibly could have," a source with knowledge of the situation reported. Full recover is expected however instead of being a top 10 lock he slides down towards end of first round in Texan territory. Same Vision different path will overcome adversity https://twitter.com/JaeeSmiff9ENT/status/686599061173055488 Texan fans of all walks in life will love him both as a player & person.
jaylon-smith-ncaa-football-wake-forest-notre-dame-850x560.jpg


Second Round: Christian Hackenberg, QB, Penn State, 6-4 236

After being anointed coming to Penn State with new coach Bill O'Brian as the "future No. 1 overall pick" post Bill, he has struggled & dealt with his own demons of a different kind.
Penn State quarterback Christian Hackenberg is leaving school early for the NFL. Hackenberg declared his intentions following a 24-17 loss to Georgia in the TaxSlayer Bowl on Saturday. "This place means a lot to me," Hackenberg said. "It's been an awesome ride, tough way to end it today. It means the world to me. My family and I talked about it and we felt this was the best decision for me. I felt my role here and my job here has been accomplished." Hackenberg left the game in the second quarter with a right shoulder injury. Linebacker Roquan Smith landed on his shoulder after a scramble. Hackenberg stayed in the game and threw four more passes, but grabbed the shoulder between plays.

He headed to the locker room after an incompletion and returned for the second half in street clothes. He said he wanted to play, but team officials told him no. "It is what it is," said Hackenberg, who hadn't missed a snap in three years before Saturday. "I'm disappointed I wasn't able to finish the game." Hackenberg said he made his decision to turn pro before the team left State College for Jacksonville. Hackenberg, a junior, is the school's all-time leader in yards passing (8,457) and touchdowns (48) as well as completions, attempts and total offense. He completed 8 of 14 passes for 139 yards against Georgia. - AP Sports
penn-state-quarterback-christian-hackenberg.jpg



Third Round: Sebastian Tretola, OG, Arkansas, 6-5 334

Brooks will be a free agent if his agent & Texans don't agree to terms opening up a position of need on interior of OL. Tretola has been Arkansas' starting left guard over the last 23 games and has graded over 80 percent in 10 of 12 contests this season. The senior earned SEC Offensive Lineman of the Week honors earlier this season and in over 25 career games at Arkansas, he has only allowed a half-sack to help the Razorbacks lead the SEC in fewest sacks allowed the last two seasons.
1231765_web_HOGS-Allen_Tretola_141015.jpg


Fourth Round: Jordon Howard, RB, Indiana, 6-1 225

Has NFL size O'Brian covets had to overcome transferring Senior season because team he was on UAB, dropped football program so came to Indiana filling some big shoes left by Tevin Coleman (drafted 3rd rd. Atlanta). In his only season with the Hoosiers, the junior rushed for 1,213 yards and nine touchdowns despite missing the equivalent of five plus games due to injury. Despite the shortened season Howard still managed to finish third in the Big Ten in rushing and has set himself up to be one of the top backs in the 2016 draft.

04e7411fb54abf2bd469a7cd1e6e1265.jpg


Fifth Round: Willie Henry, DT, Michigan, 6-3 311

Better suited inside than Crick, who will be a free agent, Willie can work himself in the rotation to fill nose tackle in Crennel's 3-4.
https://twitter.com/WE_69
http://touch-the-banner.com/defensive-tackle-willie-henry-declares-for-nfl-draft/
willie-henry-ncaa-football-utah-michigan-850x560.jpg


Fifth Round: Texan GM Rick Smith trades up in 2nd round using 5th round pick to the Giants jumping ahead of Chicago, New Orleans & Philly.

Sixth Round: Sean Price, TE, South Florida, 6-3 249

Fluid with soft hands that can run after the catch. Fits in a New England style where a QB can spread defenses out by distributing the ball, good open field blocker & adds another offensive weapon @ position of need. 6-3, 249-pound Price brings 42 career receptions into his third season at USF, after posting 21 catches in each of his first two seasons. Price is the only American Athletic Conference player selected to the 2014 watch list of 38 players nationwide. Price was a preseason first-team all-conference selection by Phil Steele. Raised by his grandparents he was voted homecoming king ... spent numerous hours volunteering to clean his school and in the community ... participated in car wash fundraisers ... earned academic honors all four years.
c7s_PriceTD121915_16461064_8col.jpg
Where would you have Smith lining up?
 
Taking inside linebackers in first scare me the same as running backs in first. Yes they are normally instant upgrades and can improve the heck out of team fast. But for how long before they suffer an injury, those two position just seem like the two most violent in football.
 
As much as I love Smith's game I'm terrified of his injury. Keep hearing about possible nerve damage. Last thing we need is another player on a medical timetable who we're always waiting to hear about the next "pop". I could just see Cushing, Clowney, and Smith hanging out in the trainers room after every game comparing the swelling in one another's knees.
 
As much as I love Smith's game I'm terrified of his injury. Keep hearing about possible nerve damage. Last thing we need is another player on a medical timetable who we're always waiting to hear about the next "pop". I could just see Cushing, Clowney, and Smith hanging out in the trainers room after every game comparing the swelling in one another's knees.

Agreed. I can't imagine getting behind a player that just recently had such a significant injury, no matter how good the player.
 
From reports I've read there was no nerve damage involved.

repair of the ACL and LCL "couldn't have gone better," per the source. Though clearly significant, the ligament damage was the lesser of the concerns for the All-America performer thought to be a lock for a first-round NFL draft selection.

There were reports of possible nerve damage within the knee, which would have loomed much larger for Smith's immediate future. But the source offered a positive report about that after the surgery.
 
The point of this mock was to select BPA regardless of situation, including injury, because of moral fiber to overcome odds & people's prejudice. Intrigued by outpouring of biased opinion, only Cloak is qualified to accurately project medical recovery moving forward & even he would admit not actually being there to physically examine subject leaves some doubt. Go ahead now, carry on!
 
I'm not sure any NFL team would a first rd pick on a Jan ACL LCL injury. Just MHO. What that means is another and he's done.
 
The point of this mock was to select BPA regardless of situation, including injury, because of moral fiber to overcome odds & people's prejudice. Intrigued by outpouring of biased opinion, only Cloak is qualified to accurately project medical recovery moving forward & even he would admit not actually being there to physically examine subject leaves some doubt. Go ahead now, carry on!
How is he the BPA if you don't know how fast he can run or how high he can jump? Will he have the worst Cone and Shuttle times.
 
Willis McGahee
In the last 12 years that's 1 player in 384 picks. What else you got? McGahee had a ACL and MCL. If Jaylon did have an LCL tear, as you posted (This is where CnD needs to jump in) this is a slower longer recovery as I have heard it to be.
 
Last edited:
I love Jaylon Smith but I'm not sure how I feel about him in the 1st round for the Texans. Someone is going to take the chance on him and, when healthy, he is an absolute stud. However, the Texans history when it comes to drafting injured players isn't just lackluster, it's brutal. I don't trust the Texans FO to do the required groundwork to make an informed decision. I say this because history has proven that they shouldn't be trusted in doing so.
 
Building a team with indomitable spirit, boom or bust. I thought the controversy would be with the QB? Who I'm not a big fan of but does possess the real essential look of a NFL QB he's just had his share of controversy as well. Are Texans resigning both Brooks & Crick? Don't we need a stud RB? How about a stud DT in 5th or athletic, pass catching TE in 6th? No mention of using one of the 5th rd picks to move up in 2nd, so as not to be leapfrogged by another team in search of a QB? A lot here for so much focus on a late #1, heck it took De Andre & Mercilus a couple years to develop, don't think Texans medical team hasn't learned a thing or two past decade?

Wow, that's all I got to say.
 
Building a team with indomitable spirit, boom or bust. I thought the controversy would be with the QB? Who I'm not a big fan of but does possess the real essential look of a NFL QB he's just had his share of controversy as well. Are Texans resigning both Brooks & Crick? Don't we need a stud RB? How about a stud DT in 5th or athletic, pass catching TE in 6th? No mention of using one of the 5th rd picks to move up in 2nd, so as not to be leapfrogged by another team in search of a QB? A lot here for so much focus on a late #1, heck it took De Andre & Mercilus a couple years to develop, don't think Texans medical team hasn't learned a thing or two past decade?

Wow, that's all I got to say.

I don't fault your position selection the first round. He is exactly the type of player that we need, or rather he was the type of player we need. It's just that injury.

Regarding Hackenberg, I don't like trading up to get him in the second. That's a lot of risk at such a key position for a guy with a lot of question marks.
 
I'm going to have the same question in every mock that passes on QB in the 1st - which QBs are you passing on to make your projection?
 
I think Smith, with his skill set, has an incredibly high ceiling in the NFL. But I'm just not comfortable with the Texans using a high pick on someone coming off of that type of injury.

If he fell to us then I'm assuming it's because the teams in front of us view him as damaged. And I trust those teams' medical evaluations more than I trust the Texans.
 
I'm going to have the same question in every mock that passes on QB in the 1st - which QBs are you passing on to make your projection?

None.

Goff, Cook, lynch & Wentz all projected off the board now. Wentz is still my priority QB but Texans would need to trade up top 10. Maybe same team I've targeted in 2nd (GIANTS)? Won't know until draft day how players fall.
Hackenberg would be next best option to O'Brian I just hate to use the first on him but would understand it. He could rise during the process with the other four guys, making it 5 taken in the first round.
 
Browns- Goff
Cowboys or Niners- Wentz
Eagles- Lynch
Rams or Jets- Cook

not saying it will happen but there is a possibility

If that were to happen, then a top 10 talent falls to us... we go another route for QB and I'd be happy with that. Would prefer we trade up to #6 and likely have our choice of all but Goff, but it is what it is
 
Browns- Goff
Cowboys or Niners- Wentz
Eagles- Lynch
Rams or Jets- Cook

not saying it will happen but there is a possibility

Don't think either the Cowboys or Niners take a QB in the 1st. IMO (as a Cowboys 2nd fan) Jerry is looking for Romo insurance not Romo's replacement. My suspicion is Kelly is in a Kubiak/Carr situation.
 
2.Cleveland Browns
2015 record:3-13 (.531)
Top need: Quarterback - GOFF
Other needs:
Wide receiver, defensive end, inside linebacker

4.Dallas Cowboys
2015 record:4-12 (.531)
Top need: Quarterback - WENTZ
Other needs:
Running back, defensive tackle, linebacker

7.San Francisco 49ers
2015 record:5-11 (.539)
Top need: Quarterback - COOK
Other needs:
Right tackle, wide receiver, defensive line

11.Chicago Bears
2015 record:6-10 (.547)
Top need: Pass rusher - Would consider one of the above QB's if available, Cutler is hot & cold with 10 years of wear & tear
Other needs: Quarterback
, cornerback, left tackle, wide receiver

12.New Orleans Saints
2015 record:7-9 (.504)
Top need: Weak-side linebacker
Other needs: Guard, quarterback, cornerback - Same situation as Chicago with aging QB, great time to develop next franchise signal caller

13.Philadelphia Eagles
2015 record:7-9 (.508)
Top need: Quarterback - LYNCH, not going to admit Kelly was right for giving Bradford a comeback shot
Other needs:
Offensive tackle, pass rusher, guard

22.Houston Texans
2015 record:9-7 (.496)
Top need: Quarterback - So Texans are just going to do what they do best, wait until the 2nd round then trade up for Christian Hackenberg, jumping ahead of the Bears, Saints & Eagles.
Other needs:
Running back, inside linebacker, defensive tackle - Jaylon Smith, a top 10 talent despite injury
 
Kelly was gushing over their QB situation today. There was a report they went with Kelly because Shanahan wanted to dump Kaep. Jerry is convinced Romo has a few more years. Not seeing Niners or Cowboys taking a QB in the 1st. Saints have too many holes to spend a 1st to ride the bench until Brees retires. Might as well trade Brees which they have shown no inclination to do.

So we are blowing off Lynch for Hack?
 
Kelly was gushing over their QB situation today. There was a report they went with Kelly because Shanahan wanted to dump Kaep. Jerry is convinced Romo has a few more years. Not seeing Niners or Cowboys taking a QB in the 1st. Saints have too many holes to spend a 1st to ride the bench until Brees retires. Might as well trade Brees which they have shown no inclination to do.

So we are blowing off Lynch for Hack?

Looks to me that we could possibly have our choice of all but whoever Cleveland takes... or possibly missing out on all of them including Hack
 
I can still see Chip drafting a QB, you never know with Chip. But as we have found in recent articles/rumors, Chip may have less control and even if he has a large say, Kaep actually fits what he does. It's not only the dual threat of run and pass, it's the quick pass, the one step back throw on timing. Kaep actually can do that much more effectively than the typical pass scheme. Chip may actually feel that he can work with Kaep. The Niners have so many needs. As time passes, I agree more and more that the Niners are going to use that pick on another position. There's alot of possibilities for them. Offensive tackle, Treadwell at wide receiver, Jalen Ramsey at corner or safety, or Shaq Lawson. All those guys would portentially (in the way that all prospects are only potential) help that team immediately. They fill holes.

You look at Dallas and the consistent claim around here that they are going to look past a QB in order to bolster their chances to win one with Romo and it makes alot of sense. Romo has had some poor luck and he's actually played better recently. His big issue is staying on the field. I can't imagine Jerry Jones takes a QB in the top 10 and forgoes the opportunity to give Romo and himself every chance to make it work. They're in the same situation as the Niners as well in that there are going to be players available that can really help them at that spot.

Browns are going QB, I have no doubt. Manziel has no shot in Cleveland and they have only Austin Davis to inspire the fans and management. One QB will go at 2.

I hadn't looked too hard into the Bears, but they may actually look at a QB. The situation with Cutler there has been pretty unstable for a few years now and they lost their "QB whisperer" to the Dolphins, although that hire for the Dolphins is still confusing for me.

Now, the Saints. I agree with icak in regards to that situation and its much like the Cowboys. It's actually more similar the more you look at it. Brees had an injury that slowed him down in 2014 and kept him from preparing fully for 2015. In addition, the team was poor overall, much like the Cowboys. Their team just isn't that great and they could really benefit from a trade sceario in which they get more picks this year. It would probably be hard to sell them on future picks. This probably means our 1st, 2nd and 3rd, maybe even a pick next year. Then again, they'd benefit from a guy on defense that slips to 12 as well.

The Eagles will take a QB if only one has gone off the board by 13, in my opinion. So, as we have said, #12 is the sweet spot for us to trade into and would give us the most options at QB.
 
Last edited:
I don't think the Bears look at QB in round one no matter who is available. Cutler has been Cutler but they have kinda committed to him.

Jay Cutler signed a 7 year contract with the Chicago Bears worth $126.7 million on January 2, 2013. $38 million becomes fully guaranteed on the 3rd day of the 2014 League Year. Cutler’s 2016 salary is guaranteed for injury upon signing with $10 million becoming fully guaranteed on the 3rd day of the 2015 League Year and the remaining $6 million becoming fully guaramteed on the 3rd day of the 2016 League Year. http://overthecap.com/player/jay-cutler/130

They are stuck with him another couple years in my opinion. Now they may look at round 2 or 3 but they have so many needs...
 
I don't think the Bears look at QB in round one no matter who is available. Cutler has been Cutler but they have kinda committed to him.



They are stuck with him another couple years in my opinion. Now they may look at round 2 or 3 but they have so many needs...

Good info, I didn't know his contract situation.
 
  • Like
Reactions: JB
The Browns are pretty much guaranteed to take a QB at some point. And with the #2 pick, it seems likely to happen there.

The Cowboys likely have Romo for four more years so I don't think they look at QB just yet. Instead, I think they look to bolster one of their weak spots to gear up for another run.

Who knows what SF will do. With they way they run things over there, I wouldn't be surprised to see them give Gabbert a full year with Kelly before they decide what to do.

I think Chicago could surprise some people and take a QB. Cutler has five years left on his contract, but the way it looks structured they could easily get out from under it after this season with very little damage done. They'd owe $13M to cut him this year but only $2M to do it next year, and even less to do it in the years after that. They could definitely draft a guy and let him sit behind Cutler until they think he's ready.

The Saints just drafted a QB in the 3rd round last year. The third round doesn't guarantee that they think anything of him. Maybe they just didn't feel good with what they had behind Brees. But Grayson was the first QB off the board after Winston and Mariota went #1 and #2. I would expect they'd like to find out what they have in him before taking a QB in the first the very next year.

I think we need to watch out for the Eagles but I think they'll only go QB for the right guy. They have Sanchez for next year. I don't think they feel desperate to get a QB right now, but would definitely move for the right one.
 
I don't think the Bears look at QB in round one no matter who is available. Cutler has been Cutler but they have kinda committed to him.



They are stuck with him another couple years in my opinion. Now they may look at round 2 or 3 but they have so many needs...

Does anyone remember David Fales?



Not that I think he's the answer or anything, but I don't think the Bears are going to be looking to draft a player to replace Cutler this year & they won't be looking to draft & develop someone either. They've got the QB situation they want.
 
  • Like
Reactions: JB
I would look @ it this way. If this QB class of 2016 was the 2014 QB class the Texans would have selected a QB with the first overall pick. Would say the same thing if it was the 2015 QB class. QB is such a commodity driven position & this draft has four possibly five, very good pro prospects, anyone who passes risk peril @ own expense!
 
Per Daniel Jeremiah - 9th overall rated prospect
Jaylon Smith - LB, Notre Dame



Smith was a three-year starter at linebacker for the Fighting Irish. This is an ultra-twitched-up athlete that creates "wow" plays on a routine basis. He primarily lines up inside, but he has experience on the outside as well. Against the run, he attacks the line of scrimmage and stuns lead blockers with a jolting punch. There are times where he struggles to sort through the trash inside but once he sees it, he gets there in a hurry. He has incredible range and makes a lot of plays near the sideline. Against the pass, he is a dynamic blitzer with timing and burst. He has the speed and agility to mirror running backs and tight ends in coverage. Unfortunately, he suffered a knee injury in the Fiesta Bowl against Ohio State and his status for next season is up in the air. Overall, if healthy, this player would be in the mix for the first overall pick. He has rare talent.
 
ACL right?

ACL injuries aren't what they used to be. Where in the past I could see an ACL injury dropping a first round prospect to a 4th or 5th round gamble, I can see a 1st overall prospect dropping to 22 overall.

He might not be that impact player day one, but he'll eventually recover to form & contribute for a long time.
 
ACL right?

ACL injuries aren't what they used to be. Where in the past I could see an ACL injury dropping a first round prospect to a 4th or 5th round gamble, I can see a 1st overall prospect dropping to 22 overall.

He might not be that impact player day one, but he'll eventually recover to form & contribute for a long time.
ACL and LCL
 
Agreed. I can't imagine getting behind a player that just recently had such a significant injury, no matter how good the player.

I find it interesting that Jaylon would bring exactly the type of speed @ MLB the Texans need, even you point that out.

I don't agree with that, the personnel in Denver suits Wade's attacking man scheme. You've pointed out one of the main reasons as to why in your previous posts, speed, particularly at linebacker. We didn't/don't have speed at LB and that hurt us in his scheme. That's why TEs and backs destroyed us in the flats, on option and crossing routes. We still have that issue now.

I'm of the opinion that if we can get some speed at middle linebacker and some range at safety, our defense will improve dramatically against the type of offenses that typically burn us. I'm talking about spread oriented teams that create mismatches as a primary way of attacking the defense.

The only reason that Jaylon may still be on the board when Texans select is because of his injury, an injury he will fully recover from. So try a little harder to imagine, lol
 
I find it interesting that Jaylon would bring exactly the type of speed @ MLB the Texans need, even you point that out.



The only reason that Jaylon may still be on the board when Texans select is because of his injury, an injury he will fully recover from. So try a little harder to imagine, lol

Didn't I already say that he was the type of player we need earlier in this thread?

I don't fault your position selection the first round. He is exactly the type of player that we need, or rather he was the type of player we need. It's just that injury.

We don't know that he will fully recover from the injury. That's the point.
 
We don't know that he will fully recover from the injury. That's the point.

I'm well aware of the Texans track record in this area but I have to attribute that more to bad luck than lack of Medical team ineptitude. If you can't utilize modern medical advancements then you probably don't belong in sports business period.

Might not make it to Texans anyway, if Jets address LB need.
 
Didn't I already say that he was the type of player we need earlier in this thread?



We don't know that he will fully recover from the injury. That's the point.
BINGO!
Recovery to pre injury level? Dicey.
Recovery to play poorly. More likely
Unable to play. Possibly.
How far should he drop if we take the unrealistic recovery presumption off the table?
 
First Round: Jaylon Smith, LB, Notre Dame, 6-3 240
jaylon-smith-ncaa-football-wake-forest-notre-dame-850x560.jpg


McShay's pretty bullish on Smith's comeback as well.

i

19. Buffalo Bills (8-8)

Jaylon Smith, LB, Notre Dame Fighting Irish

This selection comes with some risk because of Smith's knee injury, but if the Bills' doctors clear him, Smith would be a great pick. He took his game to the next level this past season and is an elite athlete. Smith has experience playing inside and outside and would fit well as the weakside off-ball linebacker in Rex Ryan's defense. Other options here: Alabama DT Jarran Reed and Ohio State OLB Darron Lee.
 
Well, considering several people taking Smith out of the 1st round all together.

I guess if you got bullish from that, ok. I read it as "if doctors clear him ...". Which is to say what everyone else is saying, he was phenomenal pre-injury, and should he recover well then he could still very well be a damn good player. And in the event that he begins to show a strong recovery someone will likely take a chance on his considerable pre-injury talents early.

Again, I don't get that McShay was particularly worked up about his actual prognosis from all of "if doctors clear him ...". And as it goes for the Texans I would love to have this kid, would absolutely love it, even since the injury. I just don't know how solid a move it is to take him in the first with all the issues we have and not knowing just how long until he sees the field again and how long until he's fully himself again, if he's ever really fully himself again at all. Being bullish to me would be to speak in the affirmative about all of those things. But fair enough if this is just semantics.
 
Jaylon is a makeup call for not selecting Mack & only reason he could be available is this injury. Clowney should be kicked inside replacing Crick DE opposite JJ.

Not high on Hack but could see Texans trading up in 2nd. per O'Brian history & Texan needs.
 
Back
Top