Its all about precedent, and this sets a bad one.
If we give him a new deal it signifies the following:
1) If you hold out and we need you badly enough, we'll cave
2) If you outplay your contract, regardless of how recently we resigned you, we'll give you more money
Neither of those are conducive to winning a championship. AJ deserves to be paid more. But the NFL is a business, he signed a deal for 8 years 3 years ago. I want him to get paid more because he's my favorite player. But I also realize that this would be a huge slap in the face to OD. And it would prevent us from signing more talent in the future. And it would put us in an awkward situation in the future when lesser talented players make the same demands. Saying no to AJ makes it easier for us in the future. "Dont even try a hold out. We didn't cave for AJ, the best WR in the NFL. We're not caving for you."
'eh, I don't know about precedent. And besides, what precedent did AJ establish by being the best WR in football and restructuring a deal on the crappiest team in football to make room under the cap for more talent?
Dude signed his contract after we went 2-14 and 6-10. Think about that. He could have played it out and asked whatever he wanted from whoever he wanted. Can you even begin to imagine how many rings he'd be sporting if he was with the Colts or Patriots?
Sure, AJ has no leverage with regards to forcing the franchise to re-do his contract....but there is the little fact he's the best WR in football, much less the best and most loyal player on this team. Leverage is subjective. He can bring bad publicity just by this story existing. He knows that, and he's not one to showboat or talk crap in the media.
The Houston Texans, Inc. is a billion dollar industry. All this "team loyalty" by customers...errrr....fans is so sad it's funny. BTW, where is the defining line between being a customer and being a fan? I'm always confused about that...
Anyway, it's just business.
Sure but don't get too harped on the "voluntary" aspect of it. Nothing is truly voluntary in the NFL. They won't get docked pay but you'd be kidding yourself if you didn't think one would be ruffling feathers by missing camp. Any camp!
Don't get confused about the VOLUNTARY aspect of it. The word has meaning, and OTA's are truly voluntary, as per the NFLs Collective Bargaining Agreement.
With regards to "ruffling feathers"; According to all the retired players interviewed about subjects like this, they all side with the player. It is a brotherhood, and they understand there is a business side to it. N.D. Kalu was guest hosting a radio show earlier today and talked about this very subject. He said the only time players even talk about these situations is over a beer after practice, and even then only when it's over-the-top like a T.O. situation.
If he's ruffling the front office's feathers, so freakin' what. They get paid to deal with this crap, so deal with it. I could honestly care less about the front office. They exist to make money off of the careers of players like AJ.
AJ is the 800 pound gorilla on this team that can sit whever the hell he wants.
He won't miss any training camp or mandatory practices. Bank on it.