HoustonFrog
Dallas Frog
Maybe because the stats you picked don't provide an accurate picture.
If you want to compare D-Rob to Quin then you have to do it on a snap by snap basis, not just looking at total numbers. A guy who played 5 snaps and didn't give up any receptions is not the greatest corner to ever take the field. He's a bum who couldn't get on the field.
above average
average
bellow average
Yards allowed per play in coverage
Dunta Robinson 0.88 <--- here's your winner
Glover Quin 1.18
Percentage of plays in coverage they allowed a reception.
Dunta Robinson 8.6% <--- here's your winner
Glover Guin 10.3%
Percentage of plays in coverage they were thrown at.
Dunta Robinson 13.1% <--- here's your winner
Glover Quin 16.1
Yards per reception
Dunta Robinson 10.3 <--- here's your winner
Glover Quin 11.5
Yards per attempt
Dunta Robinson 6.7 <--- here's your winner
Glover Quin 7.3
Completion percentage against
Dunta Robinson 65.4%
Glover Quin 63.8% <--- here's your winner
Despite D-Rob covering the other team's #1 and Quin covering the #2 or slot, Robinson still comes out ahead in almost every category.
It isn't even close.
98th out of 107 corners based completely on an opinion based ratings system.
"I thought Petey looked good getting torched on that 98 yard TD. I'll give him +2"
That's what their ratings amount to. They are opinions. Opinions are not stats.
You are pencil whipping the numbers and the stats are based on pure yardage, etc, not opinions. It is one of the most repsected sites out there. You are basically making up an argument. Let me switch places with you and be smarmy for a minute. An opinion is something like "I think Dunta sucks." Giving a value system to a stat isn't an opinion when all those value stats are used the same across the board for each player. It's not like they decided to make a statistical analysis site to stick it to Dunta. What is funny is that there are fractions involved in the alleged #1 corner you so covet and a rookie last year. Even in your cherry picking you make my point. And Quin wasn't even as good as Reeves. So how is Dunta #1?