Keep Texans Talk Google Ad Free!
Venmo Tip Jar | Paypal Tip Jar
Thanks for your support! 🍺😎👍

Texans trade for WR Christian Kirk

Mr teX said:
I think he’s gonna be great as a slot b/c he’s very shifty. I think his injuries over the years have been largely due to him being put or tried in a bigger role as a #1 than he can probably handle. He’s a good solid #3 that can step into a #2 role in a pinch when needed.

I’d still like to see them draft a young guy to play as a #3 next year & learn then take over as #2 and drop Kirk where he belongs and is best utilized.
Click to expand...
I hope we get back to Cj's favorite receiver is the open receiver.
 
TheRealJoker V2 said:
Kirk is fully capable of playing to the level Diggs did for us last season in that role. I don’t think he’ll ever reach the all pro heights Diggs reached in Buffalo. But he is a much better value for the 7th in 2026 than Diggs was last season.
Click to expand...
Until Nick does something about it Kirk still cost $13M. Which is more than Diggs should have got last season.

Not my money, but it's got to work with our Roster, under the cap & I'm sure Nick is aiming at a Super Bowl.
 

thunderkyss said:
Until Nick does something about it Kirk still cost $13M. Which is more than Diggs should have got last season.

Not my money, but it's got to work with our Roster, under the cap & I'm sure Nick is aiming at a Super Bowl.
Click to expand...
Call getting to the conference championship just incremental improvement if you want but in my book that would make the 2025 season
a solid success.
 
thunderkyss said:
True.

But I'd be sorely disappointed if Caserio is aiming for the conference championship.
Click to expand...
Was chatting to a Ravens fan the other day who made a really good point about what is success in the NFL? Because they played great all season long, very few games they’d have liked back, before coming up short in a win or go home playoff game.

His point was looking at free agency where would they improve that team? Of course players get older and injuries change situations, there will always be roster churn, but really they could be as good as last season and win the Super Bowl.

The Diggs signing, they got unlucky because the OC they entrusted ran out of ideas and he got a bad injury. Couple that with the fact that despite coming off an ACL he’s still likely the top WR target in FA and the Texans are right to be taking on a player that most opinions I’ve read see as a better version of the same type of player right now, rather than overpaying to chase the loss.

Of course the aim is superbowl every season, but the league is setup a bit wonky in that regard with 31 unsuccessful teams every season and it being so hard to repeat the feat.
 
Ecstatic for this deal honestly.

Kirk fills a big need and is one of (if not) the best options for WR out there. I know he's been injured that past couple seasons, but at least on paper he's a dream fit. He's a great shifty slot with tremendous vertical ability. Feels tailor made for CJ and even for Nico. I can just see a safety jumping to cover Kirk vertically with Nico darting in on a dig route underneath him - tough for a defense to cover.

Kirk also always struck me as the most talented player on offense that the Jags had whenever I watched them or we played against them.
 
Sweech said:
Ecstatic for this deal honestly.

Kirk fills a big need and is one of (if not) the best options for WR out there. I know he's been injured that past couple seasons, but at least on paper he's a dream fit. He's a great shifty slot with tremendous vertical ability. Feels tailor made for CJ and even for Nico. I can just see a safety jumping to cover Kirk vertically with Nico darting in on a dig route underneath him - tough for a defense to cover.

Kirk also always struck me as the most talented player on offense that the Jags had whenever I watched them or we played against them.
Click to expand...

The "injury prone" description (in general) seems a little farcical when you look at what the injuries actually were. He had a 'core muscle' injury in 2023 (that held up in 2024,) and he broke his collarbone in 2024. To me, that simply looks like bad luck. Heck Nico has a worse injury history than Kirk does.

Now I don't expect him to put up another 1000 yard season like 2022, but I think he'll fit in very well with the 'quick game' that I expect Caley to install.
 
cland said:
The "injury prone" description (in general) seems a little farcical when you look at what the injuries actually were. He had a 'core muscle' injury in 2023 (that held up in 2024,) and he broke his collarbone in 2024. To me, that simply looks like bad luck. Heck Nico has a worse injury history than Kirk does.

Now I don't expect him to put up another 1000 yard season like 2022, but I think he'll fit in very well with the 'quick game' that I expect Caley to install.
Click to expand...
The '23 injury was an "inguinal groin tear" on his right side, causing him to miss the last five games of the season. Previously, in September 2020, he "strained" the same groin, missing only one game.
 
Number19 said:
The '23 injury was an "inguinal groin tear" on his right side, causing him to miss the last five games of the season. Previously, in September 2020, he "strained" the same groin, missing only one game.
Click to expand...
He was healthy last season.
 
JB said:
But still unknown if his core would have held up to a 17 game season... those damn core injuries seem to recur a lot
Click to expand...

Whelp, according to Number19 the first core issue held out for 3 years (with a thousand yard season in the middle) before reoccurring. I'm feeling pretty good about him making it through his 1 nonguaranteed season. :tiphat:
 
cland said:
Whelp, according to Number19 the first core issue held out for 3 years (with a thousand yard season in the middle) before reoccurring. I'm feeling pretty good about him making it through his 1 nonguaranteed season. :tiphat:
Click to expand...
Nvrmnd
 
I still think Houston should go after a Elite receiver whether thats bringing back Diggs for a one year deal or sign Kupp that is getting released tomorrow. Collins and Kirk I dont think is it
 
I think they will most likely draft a wide receiver in the first 2-3 rounds who fits their needs. I can't rule out another vet signing, but IMHO, the Kirk trade was the splash guy in terms of a vet. There's not much to work with in terms of the cap and considering the o-line needs...I think Kirk and the other low-level guys are it for vets. I could be wrong, though. Let's give it a week or two, and then we'll have a good idea where the WR position stands.
 
Texas Punishers said:
I still think Houston should go after a Elite receiver whether thats bringing back Diggs for a one year deal or sign Kupp that is getting released tomorrow. Collins and Kirk I dont think is it
Click to expand...

I think Diggs has been replaced with Kirk, but I would hope to see another #2 brought in. There's a chance that Hutchinson might emerge in his 3rd year (like Nico), but I wouldn't want to rely on that.
 
Kubiak used to say he wants a rabbit and a fox at wide receiver.
We have several foxes, who's the rabbit?
 
cland said:
JB said:
But still unknown if his core would have held up to a 17 game season... those damn core injuries seem to recur a lot
Click to expand...

The "injury prone" description (in general) seems a little farcical when you look at what the injuries actually were. He had a 'core muscle' injury in 2023 (that held up in 2024,) and he broke his collarbone in 2024. To me, that simply looks like bad luck. Heck Nico has a worse injury history than Kirk does.

Now I don't expect him to put up another 1000 yard season like 2022, but I think he'll fit in very well with the 'quick game' that I expect Caley to install.
Click to expand...
His clavicle fracture was no doubt "bad luck." But adductor tears and core tears are overuse injuries. He had been dealing with his adductor for a while before it tore off the bone. He also was dealing with his abdominal core tear for a couple of months before it extended, making him significantly compromised. Both injuries required surgeries.

What bothers me about the latter injuries is that the adductor off the bone injury occurred on the left..........and the core abdominal tear occurred on the right. This tells me that Kirk likely has structural soft tissue weaknesses, making future similar type of issues distinctly more possible.
 
www.nbcsports.com

DeMeco Ryans: Christian Kirk is going to be a "friendly target" for C.J. Stroud

The Texans wanted Stefon Diggs back for 2025.
www.nbcsports.com www.nbcsports.com

Some items from the article:
The Texans wanted Stefon Diggs back for 2025.

He had 47 receptions for 496 yards and three touchdowns, putting him on pace for 100 catches and 1,000 yards before he tore the anterior cruciate ligament in his right knee in an Oct. 27 game against the Colts. Diggs ended up signing with the Patriots for more money than the Texans were willing to offer.

The Texans replaced Diggs by trading with the Jaguars for Christian Kirk, who is coming off an abdominal injury that ended his 2024 season. Kirk played only eight games and had career lows in catches (27), yards (379) and touchdowns (one). “I love Christian,” Ryans said. “His speed is the one thing that jumps out about him. He’s a fast player. He’s made a lot of nice plays in the slot, running the deep routes in the slot or it’s the option routes of winning on third down.
Click to expand...
 
You must log in or register to reply here.
Back
Top