the wonger need food said:
Here's what San Diego fans are saying about Fonoti...
SD Message Board on Fonoti
The general concensus is that he is a very good player and that they need to trade him for a defensive back. DB is a position that we were told we were deep at, however, that theory has been exposed. Looks like it would take draft picks to get him in a trade.
I'm a Chargers fan.
Fonoti is an unrestricted free agent after this season, and rumors say he won't resign with San Diego. GM AJ Smith has tried to get negotiations going but Fonoti's agent has said no.
SD has problems with Fonoti's actions on multiple occassions. He doesn't participate in the off season conditioning program, but rather spends his off season in Houston.
He reported way overweight in 2003, then developed a foot injury, probably due to his weight. He was IR'd that year. He also reported late to Training Camp by one day in 2004, and had another unexcused one day absence at Mini Camp 2005.
He left practice one day a week or two ago, then notified the team the next day he had a second surgery on his injured hand. That meant he would miss an additional three games (two more from now, then SD has a bye.)
Compensation: The Chargers are looking for a 3rd or 4th round pick. They know Fonoti is going to get a good FA contract, and SD can expect a 3rd round Compensatory Selection in 2007 as compensation from the NFL for losing a quality FA. However, I believe they would take a 2006 4th round pick, as that provides equal present value to a 2007 #3.
Talent: Fonoti is a road grader in the running game. He has All Pro talent in drive blocking. He is not very agile, nor very athletic, and has some problems in pulling. He does well in SD's short pull and trap system, but doesn't get to the second level well on extended sweeps or screens. If he lines up a guy while in space, he can level him, but he can also be side stepped easily.
In pass blocking, he's average to above average, but definitely not elite. He's now worked with two of the best OL coaches around (Hudson Houck and Carl Mauck) but his pass blocking has not improved as much as I thought it would. My contention is it never will, and it's simply a matter of his limited athleticism. He would probably help a troubled OL such as the Texans.
Weight: He's "in shape". For him that means about 350-370 lbs. He's a big dude.
Bottom line: The Texans are my #2 team, and I would love to see the team do something to upgrade the OL to keep Carr on his feet and allow him some time to find downfield WR's. Carr is never going to develop if he doesn't have the time in the pocket to make reads.
I contend that Fonoti will sign with Houston after this season anyway. Is a #4 in 2006 worth helping to keep Carr on his feet for the next 10 games? That's the question y'all need to ask.