Keep Texans Talk Google Ad Free!
Venmo Tip Jar | Paypal Tip Jar
Thanks for your support! 🍺😎👍

Josh Conerly Jr. vs Kelvin Banks Jr.

I actually think the fact that he's young is encouraging, as the one hole in his game is strength. Give him a full offseason and in the 2nd year expect he'll be ready to go.
I think it can’t be understated, Nick Caserio set up replacing Lamery Tunsil with a young, affordable, similar toolsy talent with veteran Cam Robinson to showcase his skill set and pass it on down to a higher ceiling LT.

:logo:
 
Give me a top 5-10 LT.
Define top 5-10 LT?

Hell, I’d take serviceable, hardworking, relatively lesser penalized, team player on contract reflecting actual production.

Let’s say Caserio trades up with Cowboys (#12) to go get Banks. I don’t even think his best position is LT but could be heck of a OG. Anyway he would have to trade #25 & #89 (Washington from Tunsil trade) this year plus next year’s 2nd (Washington from Tunsil trade).

Substituting 3 starters for one and eventually, if Banks does convert into NFL LT, his second contract will be right back up in Tunsil neighborhood (30+mil). Giving up less than what Tunsil trade cost but still valuable draft capital when & where we need it.

Let Conerly fall into your laps or maybe give up one Tunsil pick (3rd this year) & only have to move up to #21 Steelers (who might still draft Sanders plus gain a third). Conerly is a LT, just needs to add strength and polish technique, heck he is probably starting after the bye week.

Intentions of this thread a bit more crystallized as we’re less than 24 hours until Texans are on the clock.

:logo:
 
Last edited:
Define top 5-10 LT?

Hell, I’d take serviceable, hardworking, relatively lesser penalized, team player on contract reflecting actual production.

Let’s say Caserio trades up with Cowboys (#12) to go get Banks. I don’t even think his best position is LT but could be heck of a OG. Anyway he would have to trade #25 & #89 (Washington from Tunsil trade) this year plus next year’s 2nd (Washington from Tunsil trade).

Substituting 3 starters for one and eventually, if Banks does convert into NFL LT, his second contract will be right back up in Tunsil neighborhood (30+mil). Giving up less than what Tunsil trade cost but still valuable draft capital when & where we need it.

Let Conerly fall into your laps or maybe give up one Tunsil pick (3rd this year) & only have to move up to #21 Steelers (who might still draft Sanders plus gain a third). Conerly is a LT, just needs to add strength and polish technique, heck he is probably starting after the bye week.

Intentions of this thread a bit more crystallized as we’re less than 24 hours until Texans are on the clock.

:logo:
One of the best 5-10 top LT's in the NFL. NFL guys disagree with this MB when it comes to Tunsil. The only reason Tunsil got let go was money. They needed to pay Stingley/Hunter/Petrie etc... That's why I wasn't against the Tunsil trade and he's about to get paid again by the Redskins. They obviously think more highly of Tunsil than this MB does.

The Texans need more guys that are top 5-10 in the NFL on their team, not less. BTW, I like Conerly because he's got the feet and can get to his landmarks on the 2nd level.
 
This is how I think it goes Thu/Fri. I go off of gut feeling and this is a lot of gut feeling with a sprinkling of rumor mill. Same sprinkling of rumor and gut feeling had me picking Duane Brown back in the day.

Banks goes in the teens. Texans stay at 25 after failing to find a trade down deal and take Tyler Booker. I love me some Booker. Some of you do not. But if Banks is gone…as I suspect, they go Booker. I don’t think they go Zabel based on history. Conerly could also be the guy but only if Booker is gone. Slight chance D Jackson if Booker is gone. I do not think they go WR…but could be wrong if both Banks and Booker are gone. Like I said…gut feeling.

In the second they trade up, with Conerly the target if he is there. If he is gone…I’m less certain. They may stay put but for this exercise, Conerly is available. Why not Conerly first, then Booker in the 2nd? Because they want their first round pick to be a day one starter. Conerly is unlikely to start. I have heard DeMeco on the record state this. The first rounder should be a plug and play starter.

Add a day two guard or center in the 2026 draft, and you’ve rebuilt this line with young, cheaper talent. It’s up to the coaches to put it all together and make it work.
If you want a center in this draft, you might have to trade back into the second round, not much depth in this class
 
One of the best 5-10 top LT's in the NFL. NFL guys disagree with this MB when it comes to Tunsil. The only reason Tunsil got let go was money. They needed to pay Stingley/Hunter/Petrie etc... That's why I wasn't against the Tunsil trade and he's about to get paid again by the Redskins. They obviously think more highly of Tunsil than this MB does.

The Texans need more guys that are top 5-10 in the NFL on their team, not less. BTW, I like Conerly because he's got the feet and can get to his landmarks on the 2nd level.
Sorry SB, it’s not all about the money. It’s more about culture, loving football and being there for your line mates. Some could set aside being most penalized OL, but they were freaking drive killers. Completely unacceptable :brickwall:
 
Sorry SB, it’s not all about the money. It’s more about culture, loving football and being there for your line mates. Some could set aside being most penalized OL, but they were freaking drive killers. Completely unacceptable :brickwall:
If 10-12 false starts kills your teams offense then you didn't have much of an offense to begin with. Besides the Vikings game the false starts weren't that big of a deal.

I expect Tunsil to be much better next yr because he will have better players around him than Green/Scruggs. Of course if he plays at a pro bowl or better level some (Not you) will jump through hoops explaining why he's playing better or say he's not playing better using some convoluted spreadsheet, when in truth he will be playing better because he's got better talent around him.
 
If 10-12 false starts kills your teams offense then you didn't have much of an offense to begin with. Besides the Vikings game the false starts weren't that big of a deal.

I expect Tunsil to be much better next yr because he will have better players around him than Green/Scruggs. Of course if he plays at a pro bowl or better level some (Not you) will jump through hoops explaining why he's playing better or say he's not playing better using some convoluted spreadsheet, when in truth he will be playing better because he's got better talent around him.

Lots of excuses for Tunsil.
 
Lots of excuses for Tunsil.
What excuses, he's a top 5/7 LT that had one bad game and I dont think aaveraging a false start a game (Which he didn't with Patterson at C) is a big deal, particularly when he was playing on a bad ankle. Obviously Peters/Quin agree with me. We will have to agree to disagree on this one.
 
One of the best 5-10 top LT's in the NFL. NFL guys disagree with this MB when it comes to Tunsil. The only reason Tunsil got let go was money. They needed to pay Stingley/Hunter/Petrie etc... That's why I wasn't against the Tunsil trade and he's about to get paid again by the Redskins. They obviously think more highly of Tunsil than this MB does.

The Texans need more guys that are top 5-10 in the NFL on their team, not less. BTW, I like Conerly because he's got the feet and can get to his landmarks on the 2nd level.

BS. I think money was part of it, but I’m not buying the narrative Nick is selling whatsoever. Of course, they aren’t going to run the bus over him in public, but if they wanted him and he was SWARM, you can be your sweet bippy they would find a way to fit his salary in. He became expandable because he’s not a culture fit.
 
BS. I think money was part of it, but I’m not buying the narrative Nick is selling whatsoever. Of course, they aren’t going to run the bus over him in public, but if they wanted him and he was SWARM, you can be your sweet bippy they would find a way to fit his salary in. He became expandable because he’s not a culture fit.
Peters and Quin disagree with this post.
 
If 10-12 false starts kills your teams offense then you didn't have much of an offense to begin with. Besides the Vikings game the false starts weren't that big of a deal.

I expect Tunsil to be much better next yr because he will have better players around him than Green/Scruggs. Of course if he plays at a pro bowl or better level some (Not you) will jump through hoops explaining why he's playing better or say he's not playing better using some convoluted spreadsheet, when in truth he will be playing better because he's got better talent around him.
Remember several of those false starts cost them momentum in key drives that stalled and cost them a chance to win, maybe not exclusively but definitely in part. Heck I even remember Clowney having similar false starts that cost Texans games here and there.

DeMeco says we need to play clean football, hard enough to beat another NFL team, made harder if you gotta beat the refs too, but beating yourselves is a nail in the coffin ⚰️
 
Remember several of those false starts cost them momentum in key drives that stalled and cost them a chance to win, maybe not exclusively but definitely in part. Heck I even remember Clowney having similar false starts that cost Texans games here and there.

DeMeco says we need to play clean football, hard enough to beat another NFL team, made harder if you gotta beat the refs too, but beating yourselves is a nail in the coffin ⚰️
If a false start a game costs you games, you probably didn't deserve to win that game to begin with.
 
Tunsil false starting had become chronic issue, no ownership or remorse, that’s issue with me.

Conerly also started College career with false start issue, but he took accountability and fixed his issue.

Conerly himself wasn't willing to take the out his coach created for him. Speaking with media for the first time on Tuesday following the game, the sophomore cited nerves as the primary cause for his three false start flags.

"That was all me and just my anxiety being too high. I just really have to take a deep breath and calm down," he explained. "That's something I just have to clean up by myself. That's not on anybody else but me. I just really have to calm down and play my game and not think too much."

"Once I really noticed how much it was costing us, like every time I had a false start we had to punt on that drive, so how negatively I was affecting those drives I had to really get myself together," he said. "I did take ownership for it and apologized to all the guys. Being the left tackle and being a starter like that, I have to hold myself to a higher standard and I can't have such costly penalties like that."
Conerly seized the starting left tackle job in 2023 and never looked back. His sophomore campaign saw him allow just one sack across 540 pass-blocking snaps, earning All-Pac-12 honorable mention honors while helping quarterback Bo Nix to a conference Player of the Year season.
The 2024 season marked Conerly's arrival as an elite pass protector, as he anchored Oregon's offensive line during their undefeated regular season run to the College Football Playoff. The 6'4", 315-pound tackle emerged as one of college football's premier blindside protectors while showing steady improvement in the run game. His First-Team All-American campaign, highlighted by surrendering just nine total pressures all season, convinced him to forego his remaining eligibility and declare for the 2025 NFL Draft.
 
Remember several of those false starts cost them momentum in key drives that stalled and cost them a chance to win, maybe not exclusively but definitely in part. Heck I even remember Clowney having similar false starts that cost Texans games here and there.

DeMeco says we need to play clean football, hard enough to beat another NFL team, made harder if you gotta beat the refs too, but beating yourselves is a nail in the coffin ⚰️
Every coach says that and they're right. If a team can't overcome a 5 yd penalty a game then that's not a championship quality team. IMHO
 
Scoreboard Banks #9 overall Conerly #29. Yet give it three years and see what transpires. I did post wrong information, stated Conerly was only 20 when actually his birthdate is Nov 5th 2003. Do the math he’s actually 21. Still maturation is far from complete. Tell me who is in better situation? New Orleans, Kellen Moore HC/OC vs Kliff Zingsbury, Washington Commanders?
 
Matters more for QBs than O-linemen. Banks will start at LT day 1. Conerly will be the LT when Quinn gets tired of Tunsil.
I bet you 2 THINGS,

1. Quinn wont get tired of Tunsil protecting Daniels blindside for the next 5 yrs, provided Tunsil stays healthy.

2. Conerly is the Redskins starting RT next yr.
 
Is Conerly moving to RT or Coleman? I haven't paid attention to Washington or anyone else other than the Texans.
I've read Coleman LG/Conerly LT.

In two offseasons the Redskins have done what the Texans have spent a decade trying to do.

Tunsil/Coleman/Biadaz/Cosmi/Conerly, with Wylie/Allegretti/Herbig/Deiter in reserve.
 
Yeah, it burns. Let it sink in a little. It’s almost as if the Texans (what should have been to protect CJ Stroud, somehow flew off together to the East Coast to protect Jayden Daniels). Give us all a moment to pray 🙏
 
Yeah, it burns. Let it sink in a little. It’s almost as if the Texans (what should have been to protect CJ Stroud, somehow flew off together to the East Coast to protect Jayden Daniels). Give us all a moment to pray 🙏
Why? Just because Conerly is going to compete for the RT doesn't make him a future All-Pro, it doesn't even guarantee he won't still be a bust. Talk to me in two years and this can be a conversation based in something other than feelings
 
So offensive line is one position I won’t say I am nearly the expert on comparative to some other spots. But this discussion of Conerly and Ersery reminds me of how upset we (TT) were when Dillard was taken over Howard. Now I will say both Dillard and Howard have failed to live up to the hope of their draft position, but I don’t have the same outlook on Conerly as some here. However, I also don’t know how Ersery will project out. But I am not upset about not taking Conerly, especially if he doesn’t seem to fit the mold of what the Texans are filling the line with right now, big / broad / mauling / mountain of men.

Look at Dillard vs Conerly from pre draft scores. Dillard is photos 1 and 2 Conerly is 3 and 4.
IMG_8801.png
IMG_8802.png
IMG_8803.png
IMG_8804.png
 
Apparently not. Conerly will compete for starting RT day one!
Not sure where you're getting this from, but here is an interview with Dan Quinn post day 1. Quinn gushes over Conerly but is noncommittal regarding where Conerly might play on the line. He does say that Conerly can play inside or outside. I take Quinn at his word that he doesn't know at this point.

 
Apparently not. Conerly will compete for starting RT day one!
Had we drafted Conerly do you think we'd kick Fisher in to RG & start him at RT?

Do you think he would compete with Robinson for LT, possibly winning the spot?

Do you think he would be working to replace Robinson in case of injury or next season?
 
Had we drafted Conerly do you think we'd kick Fisher in to RG & start him at RT?

Do you think he would compete with Robinson for LT, possibly winning the spot?

Do you think he would be working to replace Robinson in case of injury or next season?
All the above are possible. Pushback is Robinson good enough? Or Fisher? Do you feel good about CJ’s protecton, after moving on from three starters? It’s ironic the team who traded-for Tunsil also drafted Conerly... To protect their franchise.
 
Not sure where you're getting this from, but here is an interview with Dan Quinn post day 1. Quinn gushes over Conerly but is noncommittal regarding where Conerly might play on the line. He does say that Conerly can play inside or outside. I take Quinn at his word that he doesn't know at this point.
Posted another clip that said as much.
 
So offensive line is one position I won’t say I am nearly the expert on comparative to some other spots. But this discussion of Conerly and Ersery reminds me of how upset we (TT) were when Dillard was taken over Howard. Now I will say both Dillard and Howard have failed to live up to the hope of their draft position, but I don’t have the same outlook on Conerly as some here. However, I also don’t know how Ersery will project out. But I am not upset about not taking Conerly, especially if he doesn’t seem to fit the mold of what the Texans are filling the line with right now, big / broad / mauling / mountain of men.

Look at Dillard vs Conerly from pre draft scores. Dillard is photos 1 and 2 Conerly is 3 and 4.
View attachment 15506
View attachment 15507
View attachment 15508
View attachment 15509
Thanks for the comparison. I believe Ersery has some Orlando Brown Jr in his game. As far as next yr goes I believe Ersery can play OG. Some like LeeBigEZ dont think he can play OG, but he wanted Caserio to sign Becton who played very well at RG for Philly despite never play OG or on the right side of the OL in his career.
 
Back
Top