bah007
Hall of Fame
That happens all the time in this defense. All kinds of players make check with me's and it's difficult to follow. That's part of the problem, that type of mistake is not uncommon. The coaching is just bad on defense, I'm really tired of it. The previous two defensive coordinators had these players and similar players playing excellent defense. This guy just flat out sucks.
I'm actually a big time proponent of that style of defense. It allows for reactive audibles that you just wouldn't have time to get called in if they came from the sideline due to the tempo of today's offenses. TCU has been doing this for years with great success up until this year, but that had more to do with an unusually high number of injuries forcing young guys who weren't ready into action.
Having said that, communication is of utmost importance and there has to be a clear structure to the decision making. A CB or LB doesn't get to overrule a S, even if the S is making the wrong call. That's how you end up with two guys in the same place.
Based on what you're saying, I would have to agree that it falls on the coaches to either prepare the players properly for that kind of situation or just scrap it entirely.