Keep Texans Talk Google Ad Free!
Venmo Tip Jar | Paypal Tip Jar
Thanks for your support! 🍺😎👍

CJ Stroud year 2

Lol, Are we allowed to pull together as fans and give a gift to our beloved players? Let’s get Stroud a nice big Pit Bull. How much you pitching in Steel?


Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk Pro

I'll throw in $500.00

300.00 for the fighting dog and 100.00 for the throw down dog and 100.00 for Vick to teach Stroud how to get Strouds dog to fight, if this means this ignorant bleep is suspended for a couple of years.
 
He's a rookie QB who is going to struggle in his rookie season because that's what a vast majority of rookie QBs do. You don't learn all the tricks of the trade and become an All Pro playing parts of 3 preseason games. This will be an ongoing season long thing. What you're looking for is growth over the course of the season because the mistakes and bad games are going to happen.

And it would be nice if this OL they've invested heavily in can stay heathly and give the young man some help so that he doesn't get Carr'd.

This team is likely to win 5-7 games this year and that's with not really knowing what to expect from the division. Hell, they might end up going 4-2 there, so not saying they can't win more, or that they can't win less, but that's where I've got them, and Vegas does too for that matter. And sorry, but having Mills start isn't going to make things any better. That's only going to waste time and prolong Stroud's development.
 
He's a rookie QB who is going to struggle in his rookie season because that's what a vast majority of rookie QBs do. You don't learn all the tricks of the trade and become an All Pro playing parts of 3 preseason games. This will be an ongoing season long thing. What you're looking for is growth over the course of the season because the mistakes and bad games are going to happen.

And it would be nice if this OL they've invested heavily in can stay heathly and give the young man some help so that he doesn't get Carr'd.

This team is likely to win 5-7 games this year and that's with not really knowing what to expect from the division. Hell, they might end up going 4-2 there, so not saying they can't win more, or that they can't win less, but that's where I've got them, and Vegas does too for that matter. And sorry, but having Mills start isn't going to make things any better. That's only going to waste time and prolong Stroud's development.
This depends on if you think you can make the playoffs or not. If you think you can then you play the QB that you think can win the most games instead of worrying about developing Stroud. If not then you lose more games and hopefully Stoud learns from his mistakes. This really comes down to which philosophy the McNair's want the team to have. I'm betting they want Stroud out there as soon as possible for marketing reasons, winning be damned.
 
Deculus didn't look as bad as I thought when I watched the game. I still think his run blocking is strong, his pass pro, after watching this, is almost good. He had one bad, really bad, play. but the rest he looked... almost good. I'd say he's an upgrade over caveman most fans loved a while back. Luckily, he's not expected to start. But he can very well develop into a starter in this league.

Scruggs looks good.

Dieter looks like a smart capable guard.

26... has absolutely no conception of pass pro. None.
 
Deculus didn't look as bad as I thought when I watched the game. I still think his run blocking is strong, his pass pro, after watching this, is almost good. He had one bad, really bad, play. but the rest he looked... almost good. I'd say he's an upgrade over caveman most fans loved a while back. Luckily, he's not expected to start. But he can very well develop into a starter in this league.

Scruggs looks good.

Dieter looks like a smart capable guard.

26... has absolutely no conception of pass pro. None.
hmmm....we will just have to agree to disagree..."RE-deculus" got smoked on almost every snap that Stroud took...he did play better after Stroud went out and the pats changed out some of their dline.

Juice held his own and not sure on the one bad play he had if there was a miscommunication and he was handing off the defender to someone else or the other person was supposed to pick him up due to protection called...

and yes 26 looked a little lost and def way too soft when chipping to help out.
 
This depends on if you think you can make the playoffs or not. If you think you can then you play the QB that you think can win the most games instead of worrying about developing Stroud.
Is 5 games in 2 seasons the "most games" you think the Texans can win? You think the development is over for the guy with the 5-19-1 record and 83.3 QB rating?
 
hmmm....we will just have to agree to disagree..."RE-deculus" got smoked on almost every snap that Stroud took...he did play better after Stroud went out and the pats changed out some of their dline.

Juice held his own and not sure on the one bad play he had if there was a miscommunication and he was handing off the defender to someone else or the other person was supposed to pick him up due to protection called...

and yes 26 looked a little lost and def way too soft when chipping to help out.
I'm only talking about the plays posted in the QB school video I quoted. If you can point to the poor Deculus plays in that video I'd love to rewatch them & discuss.
 
Is 5 games in 2 seasons the "most games" you think the Texans can win? You think the development is over for the guy with the 5-19-1 record and 83.3 QB rating?
I actually think they could win 10 games with Keenum and possibly win 10 games with Mills. I don't think they win 10 games with Stroud. With this defense they really only need solid mistake free QB play and I think they win 10 games. This is unlikely to happen with a rookie QB.
 
I think the Texans could win 10 games with Mills. It would probably take 3 seasons, but it could be done.

I don't care who the QB is, the Texans aren't winning 10 games this year. The roster just isn't good enough. Maybe next year.

The Texans are still a crummy team, but hopefully will be an improved crummy team this year. These pie in the sky predictions are only setting up some folks for disappointment. Of course, disappointment is what we're used to anyway.

I think DeMeco will change all this. But not in his first year.
 
I don't care who the QB is, the Texans aren't winning 10 games this year. The roster just isn't good enough. Maybe next year.

The Texans are still a crummy team, but hopefully will be an improved crummy team this year. These pie in the sky predictions are only setting up some folks for disappointment. Of course, disappointment is what we're used to anyway.

I think DeMeco will change all this. But not in his first year.
We had several chances to pull out a couple of more wins last year with a less talented team and a very bad defense....given our improvement on both sides of the ball as well as the improvement on the sidelines...I would say we have a reasonable chance given all this AND a weak schedule.

But then again thats just me looking at it thru my cool polarized Texans Homer Glasses! LOL
 
We had several chances to pull out a couple of more wins last year with a less talented team and a very bad defense....given our improvement on both sides of the ball as well as the improvement on the sidelines...I would say we have a reasonable chance given all this AND a weak schedule.

But then again thats just me looking at it thru my cool polarized Texans Homer Glasses! LOL

Cool polarized Texans Homer Glasses are just fine. Keep wearing them is my advice. :)

If you take the three wins from last year, add in a few more just cause DeMeco is in charge, and another or two because of an improved defense, and you might, MIGHT get to 8 wins this season. I'm still predicting 6 or 7 wins for this season, which in my opinion will show considerable improvement.
 
Was Goff really a miss? He lead a team to a SB and played very well last yr. I thought he could lead a franchise like he has. I never thought he was on the Elway/Manning type generational type guys. The McNair's will be lucky if Stroud turns out to be as good as Goff.
 
Was Goff really a miss? He lead a team to a SB and played very well last yr. I thought he could lead a franchise like he has. I never thought he was on the Elway/Manning type generational type guys. The McNair's will be lucky if Stroud turns out to be as good as Goff.
You were saying Goff was a bust when he got traded
 
I've hit on Jimmy G and Mahomes.

Who have I missed on?

Lets talk about your QB evals.
You like Peterman, Kelly, Kaaya, Tannehill,

You thought Lawrence and Fields were trash.

.......

Me, I've been quite consistent since I joined the board since 2006.
I always said that I would put my QB evaluation record against any professional.
 
You like Peterman, Kelly, Kaaya, Tannehill,

You thought Lawrence and Fields were trash.

.......

Me, I've been quite consistent since I joined the board since 2006.
I always said that I would put my QB evaluation record against any professional.
Tell us more about your evals, starting in the last 10 yrs.

The guys you listed I didn't have as 1st rd picks. Kinda like this yrs class. I would've picked a QB but not in the 1st rd. Actually I would've signed Minshew to a 2 yr deal.

I still dont think Lawrence or fields are all that. Lawrence is Clemson trash though. He's very lucky Perderson got hooked up with him.
 
I've hit on Jimmy G and Mahomes.

Who have I missed on?

Lets talk about your QB evals.
I'll give you credit. You got Mahomes right. Jimmy G is overrated. However, you wanted to spend a 2nd round pick on Peterman. You missed on Jameis Winston and Trubisky. There might be others, but those jump out. Especially Nate Peterman. :shades:

In the real NFL draft you draft if you want Howard/Peterman then draft Howard and trade to the top of the 2nd and pick Peterman.

We Texans fans dont want to admit this, but Peterman has looked better than Watson this preseason.
 
Last edited:
  • Like
Reactions: JB
Tell us more about your evals, starting in the last 10 yrs.

The guys you listed I didn't have as 1st rd picks. Kinda like this yrs class. I would've picked a QB but not in the 1st rd. Actually I would've signed Minshew to a 2 yr deal.

I still dont think Lawrence or fields are all that. Lawrence is Clemson trash though. He's very lucky Perderson got hooked up with him.
First off, I was a Julius Peppers guy.
Avoiding Carr would have been big for the franchise.
Palmer in 2003 was a no brainer though I don't recall people calling him the generational type.
The next year, I was quite busy so I didn't know Eli from Rivers or Big Ben.
I didn't watch Schaub either.
The Texans were stuck with Carr anyway.
Same goes for 2005, I didn't watch much college football, and I didn't know either Smith or Rodgers.
I got back to the scene for the 2006 draft, joining the TT board.
Said no to both VY and Bush.
I'd take Mario. Another disaster avoided.

In 2007, I said no to Russell, Quinn and Kolb (an UH guy; I'm not a homer).
For that reason, I looked for FA, and I thought Schaub can fit the offense, like how an old Elway.
For me and TexansMike to be wanting Schaub should tell you that I was not a fan of that QB class.

In 2008, I said yes to Matt Ryan. Talked about him on the draft forum.
Also, ThreeToePete and I were the only two who said Flacco can be a late first rounder.
How many people dared to make that call?
We certainly didn't get any buyer.

In 2009, I said yes to Stafford (he improved every year in college) and said no to Sanchez and Freeman.
I said Sanchez is a product of a good USC offense (same as Barkley).

In 2010, I said Iike Bradford, but I'm concerned with his injury.
Said no to both Tebow and Clausen.
Tebow was a tremendous college QB, but I just didn't think his game will translate at the next level.

In 2011, I said yes to Newton.
That he's more than just a big powerful QB.
It's just a matter if he can take the next step as a true QB.
But he was a pretty good prospect.
He did throw for 400 yards plus in his first two games as a rookie, right?
Too bad he remained a bit too inconsistent in the passing game.

In that same year, I said no to Locker, Gabbert, and Ponder. All went in the first round.
I said I'd take Dalton instead; he's a smart QB.
That was another great call; I need to pat myself on the back yet again. :)
I can't remember the SN of the poster who was as against Gabbert as I was, but yes, we did think he will be a bust.
I watched Karpernick some, and I mentioned that he's worth to take a flier on. I even talked about his unorthodox release and more.
Said no to Ryan Mallett in any round.
Yates, a good prospect in the fifth round, ran an almost-exact copy cat system as Kubiak's.
(Yates said so).
No illusion here, but he was worth a 5th rd pick for the Texans.

I'll pick it up later.
Will be more of the same???
 
First off, I was a Julius Peppers guy.
Avoiding Carr would have been big for the franchise.
Palmer in 2003 was a no brainer though I don't recall people calling him the generational type.
The next year, I was quite busy so I didn't know Eli from Rivers or Big Ben.
I didn't watch Schaub either.
The Texans were stuck with Carr anyway.
Same goes for 2005, I didn't watch much college football, and I didn't know either Smith or Rodgers.
I got back to the scene for the 2006 draft, joining the TT board.
Said no to both VY and Bush.
I'd take Mario. Another disaster avoided.

In 2007, I said no to Russell, Quinn and Kolb (an UH guy; I'm not a homer).
For that reason, I looked for FA, and I thought Schaub can fit the offense, like how an old Elway.
For me and TexansMike to be wanting Schaub should tell you that I was not a fan of that QB class.

In 2008, I said yes to Matt Ryan. Talked about him on the draft forum.
Also, ThreeToePete and I were the only two who said Flacco can be a late first rounder.
How many people dared to make that call?
We certainly didn't get any buyer.

In 2009, I said yes to Stafford (he improved every year in college) and said no to Sanchez and Freeman.
I said Sanchez is a product of a good USC offense (same as Barkley).

In 2010, I said Iike Bradford, but I'm concerned with his injury.
Said no to both Tebow and Clausen.
Tebow was a tremendous college QB, but I just didn't think his game will translate at the next level.

In 2011, I said yes to Newton.
That he's more than just a big powerful QB.
It's just a matter if he can take the next step as a true QB.
But he was a pretty good prospect.
He did throw for 400 yards plus in his first two games as a rookie, right?
Too bad he remained a bit too inconsistent in the passing game.

In that same year, I said no to Locker, Gabbert, and Ponder. All went in the first round.
I said I'd take Dalton instead; he's a smart QB.
That was another great call; I need to pat myself on the back yet again. :)
I can't remember the SN of the poster who was as against Gabbert as I was, but yes, we did think he will be a bust.
I watched Karpernick some, and I mentioned that he's worth to take a flier on. I even talked about his unorthodox release and more.
Said no to Ryan Mallett in any round.
Yates, a good prospect in the fifth round, ran an almost-exact copy cat system as Kubiak's.
(Yates said so).
No illusion here, but he was worth a 5th rd pick for the Texans.

I'll pick it up later.
Will be more of the same???
Links?
 
No one’s been more wrong about QBs than me……in saying that I think Bryce young will be the best qb from the draft…. :smiliepalm:
 
I'll give you credit. You got Mahomes right. Jimmy G is overrated. However, you wanted to spend a 2nd round pick on Peterman. You missed on Jameis Winston and Trubisky. There might be others, but those jump out. Especially Nate Peterman. :shades:

I put Peterman in the 2nd rd. That's not the generational type guy I'm talking about. I had Mahomes in the same draft in the 1st rd. I knew Mahomes had talent to be a generational guy, but I didn't think he would reach the level he has today. I had Peterman on a different level.

Yep, I missed on Winston, he's got all of the talent in the world, kind like Mahomes. He just cant put it all together. I did miss on Trubiski, i should've listened to Jim Miller and gone with Allen. I'm still not sure why Trubiski busted, he's got talent. Winston has more talent than Stroud and Trubiski has as much talent as Stroud does IMHO.
 
Back
Top