Slightly different take - by your criteria there would have been some pretty good QB’s cut after their third year who went on to have nice careers. (HOF nice)
Do you want Watson to be your Drew Bree’s? San Diego didn’t think you could win a SB with Bree’s so moved on to Rivers. How did that work out for them?
Said ‘trash’ him partially tongue-in-cheek, and admitted as much in my post with my hyperbole comment. But since you mention it, I believe you have called him stupid, unable to run the EP system, not developing at the super sonic pace you would like etc. etc. ad nauseam. What would you call that, constructive criticism?
I would like to see at least his fourth year preferably with a different coach, at a minimum with an actual OC. I agree with you on one thing BOB and Watson are not a good match. Both are inconsistent, so together they are inconsistent x2 which looks horrible at times. However, one is in year three of his career and at times shows absolute greatness, the other, decades as a coach, 6 years as our head coach and we cheer like wild men when he manages to not waste a timeout because it’s “progress”.
I don’t hate Bob, think he’s a good man that’s awesome with his son... and actually think he could be a great HC. his downfall in my opinion is his ego, hire a damn OC, stop trying to micro manage everything, find a GM you can work with, hold people accountable (I’m looking at you Mike Dellin) and focus on leading the team which he seems to excel at.