b0ng
Bad Hombre
The Jags were as good as they were in 2007 because David Garrard had a career year... The Jags were BETTER last year on defense than they were in 2007...infact a LOT better. They also only had 6 more sacks in 2007, so they weren't exactly killing the QB that year either.
You basically just proved my point. Mario Williams is not going to be the catalyst that launches the Jags into the playoffs even if he does sign there... which isn't going to happen, so it's not even worth discussing to start with.
and Tyson Alualu has been average at best. He's a solid player.. not a difference maker, not a sieve like Amobi was.. hence "J.A.G."
Your point is something along the lines of Mario would have no impact on the Jaguars winning correct? When he would be an obvious significant upgrade at a position on their defense which is already really good. I think your point is very flawed in the ways that I believe adding a stud pass rusher to an already really good defense who is missing a stud pass rusher would improve them from being right outside the top 5 to being a viable candidate for best overall defense in the NFL.
In a game like football where small changes can have significant impacts in individual games I think doing something that big by itself could get the entire team to mediocre. Since they retained their defensive staff you have Mularkey is probably free to worry about the offense mostly so it's basically on him to get them the final win or two they might need to challenge for a wildcard.
Similarly I think the Titans would also be a team where the defense would go from decent to really good, so it's not like I'm just trying to lovefest the Jaguars here.