Texecutioner
Hall of Fame
Short answer, I struggle with Starr, Elway, and Manning depending on when I'm having the conversation. I could easily have those three in a different order on different days.
Starr and Unitas always get hurt because of the time frame where they played their prime. They didn't win a ton of Super Bowls but each won numerous titles before the Super Bowl era. Unitas, in particular, was extraordinarily better than his peers.
I'd have Young at #8. Favre is probably #9. I'm not too high on Bradshaw, though he is always a part of this conversation due to his SB numbers.
Double post
Last edited: