There are legitimate questions to ask about certain picks or moves the texans, but think that this was an irresponsible draft probably goes too far.
Keep Texans Talk Google Ad Free!
Venmo Tip Jar | Paypal Tip Jar
Thanks for your support! 🍺😎👍
I think you got it backwards. Pollard was a difference maker on the team last year and Wilson has the question of staying on the field.
I think what we do ... me included ... is watch some games , youtube videos , and read from some guys who may not know much , and get names . When these names start falling and we pick a guy that Joe Blow ranked lower ... we panic . Then we pick a position that we feel is not a need and all hell breaks lose .
Right now you can't get to up or to down about the draft because nobody knows what's going to happen with these players . So I'll just wait and see and hopefully we get 4-5 guys who contribute alot this year .
This draft was day 1 starter material through rd 3. IMHO
I would have traded the rest of my draft to get into the top 5 of the 3rd rd.
Then you could have gotten 4 day 1 starters.
Asamoah fell to the 3rd. So did Burnett and Wright. Immediate impact guys.
I think everyone should do draft grades using emoticons. Draft grades are silly so as long as you are being silly, you should use emoticons.
My TC blog take:
Houston Texans draft link dump + commentary + emoticon draft grades
Mostly stuff that diehards know, but a few fun facts mixed in. Hardest part of the post was figuring out the emoticons that best reflected fan feelings.
Driving home yesterday, I was flipping between the four local sports channels as I usually do and 790 the ESPN station and 610 sports channel each had "experts" voicing their evaluation of the draft. Each had Wilson rated higher than Jackson and one gave the Texans a C- grade for the draft.Hey, I wasn't stupefyingly thrilled with all the Texans selections, but where do you get the idea that only the Texans had Jackson rated highest at the time? Good lord, even Kiper had him rated as the highest CB available at the time and his choices aren't exactly secret.
If we got a legitimate #1 CB in the first round, we've improved (Dunta was nobody's #1 but us)
Driving home yesterday, I was flipping between the four local sports channels as I usually do and 790 the ESPN station and 610 sports channel each had "experts" voicing their evaluation of the draft. Each had Wilson rated higher than Jackson and one gave the Texans a C- grade for the draft.
Driving home yesterday, I was flipping between the four local sports channels as I usually do and 790 the ESPN station and 610 sports channel each had "experts" voicing their evaluation of the draft. Each had Wilson rated higher than Jackson and one gave the Texans a C- grade for the draft.
Driving home yesterday, I was flipping between the four local sports channels as I usually do and 790 the ESPN station and 610 sports channel each had "experts" voicing their evaluation of the draft. Each had Wilson rated higher than Jackson and one gave the Texans a C- grade for the draft.
Scouts, Inc. had Jackson as the #2 CB in the draft, and the #19 pick in their top 100.
The only questions here is : Is one Earl Thomas or one Mike Iupati worth all the depth and weapons they accumulated in the 2010 draft? And does this class give us enough of a lift to win the division out right ? And we want know the answers until we've run through a sixteen game schedule. I'm not a professional scout. What I see is a team who stood up true to their draft board and drafted pieces that they were lacking. Now whether or not they get us over the hump and sweep two division foes and split with the other, we'll just have to wait and see. But here is no doubt this was a "scouts" draft.
Historically Nolan Nawrocki has been less than flattering of the Texans drafts. Here is this years take:
http://www.profootballweekly.com/2010/04/25/ravens-patriots-stand-out-on-draft-weekend
Houston Texans
GM Rick Smith filled some pressing needs with the first three picks, landing two potential starters in Kareem Jackson and Ben Tate with his first two picks, both of whom fit the Texans' schemes perfectly. The team might have reached slightly in the next two rounds, but Earl Mitchell can have an impact as a nickel rusher and Darryl Sharpton value on special teams. Rounds 4-7 brought great upside, as TE Garrett Graham should benefit learning from fellow Wisconsin grad Owen Daniels. Sherrick McManis could provide versatility as a corner/safety. Shelley Smith fits the Texans' run game very well and has swing backup potential. Trindon Holliday could provide a spark in the return game, and Dorin Dickerson, drafted as a receiver, has upside to be groomed. Smith moved down the board several times, acquiring additional picks and landed nine rookies who could fend for roster spots, including three potential starters in the first three rounds. It may not appear flashy, but it was a productive draft, valuing intelligence and character, as he drafted very safely.
Grade: B-plus
I like to look at the CB situation like this.
Pretend the "top 3" CBs in this year's draft were the top 3 LBs in last years draft.
Aaron Curry (Joe Haden) was a lock to go near the top of the draft, and he did. Most Texans fans wanted Clay Matthews (Kyle Wilson), but he ended up falling to late in the 1st. Instead, the Texans drafted Brian Cushing (Kareem Jackson) who wasn't rated as highly by some, surprising the fans, but ultimately getting the DROY.
Obviously if we compare it to last years situation, both LBs taken after Curry ended up being stars, which seems perfectly possible here. But we took Jackson and I no longer care how good Wilson is, as long as Jackson becomes a star for the Texans.
Saban is a good coach and the team did pretty well but Boise State's Petersen led the team to 14-0 and 4th place with a team roster of only four seniorsI had Wilson rated as the best available corner and Jackson right behind him on draft day .... They werent seperated by much imo.
But the more I think about it the more I can see why the Texans chose Jackson .... Nick Saban coached DB - He's NFL ready from that standpoint.
As for recovery speed - You have to take into account the level of competition. The SEC is a few steps above the Big Ten in terms of overall talent.
The fact that the Texans had their choice of every CB not named Haden and they took Jackson tells me they got their guy - not just leftovers. I'll give them the benifit of the doubt.
I tend to view the Texans draft similar, productive, keyed on intelligence/character, athletes & played it very safely. they traded down in 2nd got nervous then traded back up. I get that kinda reflects how they play on the football field too, they'll stretch teams out between the 20's then they get tighter & tighter the closer they get to the endzone.
Coverage on Texans draft sucked making it more frustrating to get a grip on each selection (network went to commercial seemingly every Texans pick) along with very high, informed expectations from its own fan base, there is probably no way they could have lived up to any of our own mock drafts. Difference between reality & fantasy I guess
Maybe we're still really high on Troy Nolan
Saban is a good coach and the team did pretty well but Boise State's Petersen led the team to 14-0 and 4th place with a team roster of only four seniors
http://www.broncosports.com/ViewArt...=C&DB_OEM_ID=9900&ATCLID=578844&Q_SEASON=2010
2006,2007,2008 and 2009 Boise State led the WAC in total defense and scoring D. Marcel Yates the secondary coach has a good resume after coaching CBs for 3 seasons.http://www.broncosports.com/ViewArt...=C&DB_OEM_ID=9900&ATCLID=536982&Q_SEASON=2010
Most recognize the legendary Alabama but since 2000 Boise records is 111-17 for .867 (best in nation)& 63-2 at home.
Source > http://collegefootball.rivals.com/content.asp?CID=1034994
You are correct that Texans got their corner, I am hope it was the best one.
Watching the draft on TV was painful as a Texans fan. I didn't even know we traded the second time and I don't recall them ever putting up the terms for that trade. Also, Trey Wingo is an *****. He could not get it right during picks. The analysts would be talking during the pick and he'd announce it for the wrong team, etc. Really wish I had NFL Network.
Don't worry coverage over there wasn't too hot if you were a Texan fan either. Everytime the Texans were about to pick they'd go to commercial and when they came back they'd talk about the previous pick, meanwhile our selection would be posted at the bottom and then the group would start talking about the next teams needs.
The first day of the draft they were irritating me because freaking Jason Lacanfora was announcing the darn pick before the comissioner would even announce the pick. They wanted to have the ground breaking news so bad.
Man the lack of coverage this team gets is just astounding. We get more TV time on other teams' highlight videos than we get for our own team. Ridiculous.
This team hasnt won anything , they arent the "Sexy pick to win anything" either .... Until they WIN they wont get coverage.
Add in the fact that the Chronicle probably has the absolute worst sports coverage of any paper in a major sports market and this is what you get.
Epic Fail
Saban is a good coach and the team did pretty well but Boise State's Petersen led the team to 14-0 and 4th place with a team roster of only four seniors.
Lions and Browns haven't won anything either and they get plenty of coverage.
I like to look at the CB situation like this.
Pretend the "top 3" CBs in this year's draft were the top 3 LBs in last years draft.
Aaron Curry (Joe Haden) was a lock to go near the top of the draft, and he did. Most Texans fans wanted Clay Matthews (Kyle Wilson), but he ended up falling to late in the 1st. Instead, the Texans drafted Brian Cushing (Kareem Jackson) who wasn't rated as highly by some, surprising the fans, but ultimately getting the DROY.
Obviously if we compare it to last years situation, both LBs taken after Curry ended up being stars, which seems perfectly possible here. But we took Jackson and I no longer care how good Wilson is, as long as Jackson becomes a star for the Texans.
1.Texans: Kareem Jackson 5'10 196 4.40 great within 20 yards and better not guess wrong or he will never catch up.
Badboy: Kyle Wilson 5'10" 194 4.43 bump & run and cover guy that can close with a burst.
After seeing the National Championship game again, I saw how much he did in run support but the dude was also literally in Jordan Shipley's pocket. Alot of the over throws Gilbert threw was because he had to in order to keep from Kareem deflecting the ball or intercepting it. Shipley's TDs came when Texas moved him into the slot away from Jackson.
2. Texans: Ben Tate 5'11"220 4.4 ok a strong,fast guy & we get an extra 3rd not knowing we'd give it away immediately. Boy, did that look stupid. Still, 3rd best back on my board.
Badboy: Toby Gerhart 6' 231 4.5s He is sitting right there! Dennison said both were rated even and if we could have gotten Tate and kept the 3rd, brilliant. But we didn't. So much for TG versus Jonathan Dwyer.
I see them as having the same skill set also. Are you more upset that we just didn't take Toby or mad that we traded down, got Tate and then wasted the pick we traded down for?
3.Texans: Earl Mitchell 6'3" 296 &fast. Guess we will see if he can get through the middle. This isn't Barwin speeding in from the outside. If it works, great move! If it doesn't, someone should be taken to the woodshed. Pretty risky for a 3rd.
Badboy: We had Mike Johnson, Rennie Curran (OLB) and Tony Moeaki there.
I really considered the OLB but thought TE bigger need as I don't have medical info on how our vets are doing. My Pick:Moeaki6'3" 245 great receiver, needs to work on blocking. An OD clone if you will.
I had Earl Mitchell as the 35th best player in terms of need and ability to grab him on my draft board. On my draft board he was the 8th best DT for us but only the 4th best available at that time. There's alot of comparison going on on this message board to Amobi but that's only because of size. Motorwise, this kid is ahead of Okoye. I did feel like we could've got this guy in the 4th or later tough and would've loved to taken an OL. I had C Matt Tenant penciled here but as you can see I was way off base because he went to someone in like the 5th round or something.
4.A Sharpton5'11"236 ILB to convert to Will. I really like this guy but not a need position nor BPA.
Badboy: #118 Owusu-Ansah 6'207 4.41 CB/FS/KR This was my FS and back up corner. BTW, Ed Campo of Dallas is saying he is the FS.http://www.star-telegram.com/2010/04/24/2140336/dallas-cowboys-draft-pick-from.html
Ansah also averaged 30 yards as a senior on kick returns.
You and I have the same thoughts here. I was like "pick Owusu and be done with DB for good in this draft." They pretty much said that every draft they give Marciano the chance to draft a guy for his ST. I just don't know if I do that with my 3rd rounder though. I guess they figured they could do that when they got the extra pick for trading down? Then they trade away the extra later?
4b. Garrett Graham similar to OD but in my draft we have better TE with Moeaki. I have no 4th as I did not trade.
5. Texans:McManus, I covered above.
Badboy: Rashad Jones 6'1"214 4.51 I was stunned he was here and he had a 3-4 th round range. Can play SS to back Pollard or FS. Fast, hard hitter.
Right here we are thinking the same. At this point Reshad was my best player on my board. Another post on here will show you that I wanted to get him in the 2nd. So that goes to show how much I know where a player can go. Either way, we are talking about a player that could help is in two positions. I did see some info on McManus and they say he can play FS as well and that the dude is a real leader on the football field. The fact they went with a DB kept me from questioning too much.
6a Texans: Shelley Smith a throw away pick that will not beat out any of current OGs.
Badboy: David Gettis WR 6'3" 217 pro day 40 4.39 and does not have to convert from TE. 52 receptions 3 TDs. Big guy in Red Zone who could make one of current WRs obsolete. Had him on one of my earliest mocks. *Note Jonathan Dwyer was still available and I almost went with him as I wanted one more back in TC.
6b Trindon Holliday: I almost fell out of my chair, RMartin65 pick this guy from way back when and we put him on our final mock.
Badboy:To be honest due to his small size I really looked hard for another player but this kid should be great. I hope he keeps his Blue Cross/Blue SHield premium paid up.
7.DD ok but you know who I mean. I am ok with this pick but with Gettis who is better, we could go with my guy.
Badboy: Jeff Owen DT 6'1" 304 4.94 40. 65 and Beerlover researched the heck out of this guy and he is super strong and Pepto's (stops) the runs. We had him as high as 4th and would have been a steal. I'll put him against Mitchell especially comparing where each was selected.
I was expecting to come out today bragging on how the Texans had shut up all the critics with an outstanding draft. That did not happen.
Rating- C that I meritoriously moved up to C+ for Smith accepting RMartin65's telephone call and going with his itty bitty missile, Holliday.
1 20 Kareem Jackson CB Alabama
2 58 Ben Tate RB Auburn
3 81 Earl Mitchell DT Arizona
4 102 Darryl Sharpton ILB Miami (Fla.)
4 118 Garrett Graham TE Wisconsin
5 144 Sherrick McManis CB Northwestern
6 187 Shelley Smith OG Colorado State
6 197 Trindon Holliday RS LSU
7 227 Dorin Dickerson TE Pit
BOLD = Stater
RED = ROTATIONAL
SLATE GRAY = PR/INSURANCE IN CASE OF INJURY
Add in the fact that the Chronicle probably has the absolute worst sports coverage of any paper in a major sports market and this is what you get.
Epic Fail
Honestly, now that you say that, I think that has more to do with it than anything. I don't live in these sates or cities but I know of The Dallas Morning News, Denver Post, New York Times, Chicago Tribune etc... because I hear their names on sports channels all the time saying that they are the ones who reported it.
We can't even get coverage on a freakin practice from the Chronicle.
Don't count Garrett Graham out of beating Joel Dreesen. I consider the #2 TE position a starter since we may run some two TE sets. Graham is an every down type of TE that can both block and catch.
John McClain's idea of posting new up to date Texans information is retweeting Adam Schefter. and attaching a picture of Anna Megan to keep the masses interested ;P
even better, meaning this draft could yield 5 starters?
I must add however that I have mixed feelings about the Graham selection with Owen Daniels remaining unsigned. So that is my problem with the pick not the player himself. I also value Joel Dreessen more, his growth from the time Owen went down to end of season was nothing short of outstanding, displayed intelligence along with ability to play the position in the NFL, consumate team player, excelled even more when not asked to handle the long snapping duties.
Add in the fact that the Chronicle probably has the absolute worst sports coverage of any paper in a major sports market and this is what you get.
Epic Fail
Watching the draft on TV was painful as a Texans fan. I didn't even know we traded the second time and I don't recall them ever putting up the terms for that trade. Also, Trey Wingo is an *****. He could not get it right during picks. The analysts would be talking during the pick and he'd announce it for the wrong team, etc. Really wish I had NFL Network.
1 20 Kareem Jackson CB Alabama
2 58 Ben Tate RB Auburn
3 81 Earl Mitchell DT Arizona
4 102 Darryl Sharpton ILB Miami (Fla.)
4 118 Garrett Graham TE Wisconsin
5 144 Sherrick McManis CB Northwestern
6 187 Shelley Smith OG Colorado State
6 197 Trindon Holliday RS LSU
7 227 Dorin Dickerson TE Pit
BOLD = Stater
RED = ROTATIONAL
SLATE GRAY = PR/INSURANCE IN CASE OF INJURY
I don't think we worry about Graham coming here to replace Daniels. Especially when Kubiak said he talked to Daniels about Graham and Daniels had good things to say about him.
They went to commercial every time we came on the clock. EVERY SINGLE TIME! Weird.
Well our coverage sucked all the way around then. No biggie, I'm used to it by now.
The only time we ever got coverage during the draft was when we took Mario and we had the nation bringing the hammer down on us then.
not so sure about that as Owens if resigned does have trade value.
Saban is a good coach and the team did pretty well but Boise State's Petersen led the team to 14-0 and 4th place with a team roster of only four seniors
http://www.broncosports.com/ViewArt...=C&DB_OEM_ID=9900&ATCLID=578844&Q_SEASON=2010
2006,2007,2008 and 2009 Boise State led the WAC in total defense and scoring D. Marcel Yates the secondary coach has a good resume after coaching CBs for 3 seasons.http://www.broncosports.com/ViewArt...=C&DB_OEM_ID=9900&ATCLID=536982&Q_SEASON=2010
Most recognize the legendary Alabama but since 2000 Boise records is 111-17 for .867 (best in nation)& 63-2 at home.
Source > http://collegefootball.rivals.com/content.asp?CID=1034994
You are correct that Texans got their corner, I am hope it was the best one.
Well our coverage sucked all the way around then. No biggie, I'm used to it by now.
The only time we ever got coverage during the draft was when we took Mario and we had the nation bringing the hammer down on us then.
For the record Im not saying Jackson is the better corner - just that its easy to see how the Texans justified the pick over Wilson who we both had as at least the #2 CB.
yeah and how did that turn out ?!
Here's what's going to happen . Wilson is going to be thrown into the fire ... why ... cause their not going to throw to the other side . When Wilson plays like a rookie getting thrown at , folks will go man I'm glad we drafted Jackson .