Ok, let's look at that.
2007 and 2008 we didn't have a great defense, and our offense was just taking off. Not to mention, in 2008 we started 0-4, fell to 3-7, but ended up with 8-8.
In 2009, Schaub had a great year, but had no run game. Worst running game we have had since Kubiak got here. Not only that, but our defense was Mediocre at best.
2010, the Offense was not the problem, it was the defense. In fact, that's why I didn't want Kubiak to get fired after that season, because he was in charge of the offense, and there wasn't a problem with the offense. Defense is what single handily screwed us over in those games.
Finally, in 2011, Schaub was having a good year, and got us to 7-3 before going down. With Schaub in there, we could have easily won out those game, as opposed to having the mistake prone Tj in the last 6 games. Schaub would have been there in the Playoffs if he didn't go down, and would have won too.
Now we are here. Most likely we will go to the playoffs. If we didn't have Schaub, we would probably be neck and neck with Indy right now.