Blake
MMQB
You knew this thread was coming back.
I want to get everyones assesment after the pre-season on the 2 QB's for our beloved Texans. My take:
Carr: I understand he is playing 1's against 1's, and that is more dificult. But my problem with him has focused on his decision making. His WR stare down. His unwillingness to throw downfield. How many times did I see the kid roll out with nobody in 10-15 yards of him, only to see him throw 5 yards to someone who is covered. He doest scan the field as well as I would like either.
Sage: Like I said, Sage isnt playing against the 1's, but he also isnt using our #1's. But so far he has looked very good. He does a good job of looking off defenders, something even Porter/Pickett do. He views the field well, and finds the receivers down the field.
To say the least, I have been dissapointed with Carr, and Happy with Sage. I know Kubiak stands behind Carr, and I hope he proves me wrong on this by making Carr a great QB, but I think Carr will be the demise of this team.
Let me hear what you think? And while you do that, here are some stats to chew on.
David Carr
Att: 44
Comp: 28
Yards: 250
TD's: 0
Int: 1
Sacked: 3
Sage Rosenfels
Att: 51
Comp: 32
Yards: 329
TD's: 4
Int: 0
Sacked: 0
I want to get everyones assesment after the pre-season on the 2 QB's for our beloved Texans. My take:
Carr: I understand he is playing 1's against 1's, and that is more dificult. But my problem with him has focused on his decision making. His WR stare down. His unwillingness to throw downfield. How many times did I see the kid roll out with nobody in 10-15 yards of him, only to see him throw 5 yards to someone who is covered. He doest scan the field as well as I would like either.
Sage: Like I said, Sage isnt playing against the 1's, but he also isnt using our #1's. But so far he has looked very good. He does a good job of looking off defenders, something even Porter/Pickett do. He views the field well, and finds the receivers down the field.
To say the least, I have been dissapointed with Carr, and Happy with Sage. I know Kubiak stands behind Carr, and I hope he proves me wrong on this by making Carr a great QB, but I think Carr will be the demise of this team.
Let me hear what you think? And while you do that, here are some stats to chew on.
David Carr
Att: 44
Comp: 28
Yards: 250
TD's: 0
Int: 1
Sacked: 3
Sage Rosenfels
Att: 51
Comp: 32
Yards: 329
TD's: 4
Int: 0
Sacked: 0