Here's Schein's point of view:
link
My first thought after reading this...
Even if his premise is right, I don't see how financially it can make sense to have a three way competition with Plummer, Carr and Rosenfels.
I am guessing that if the Texans pull the plug on Carr, there are things that he is doing that they don't think are fixable. They wouldn't say the details of what those things publicly because that would diminish his value, and take out his knees in case we would have to keep him.
In truth...... I think dumping Carr is the wrong thing.
You know I'm high on Vince Young, and it is my belief that he will do great things NFL.
We passed on that.
They better fix David Carr, & if they can't, they better try harder. dumping him after one year doesn't seem like they are trying very hard. Benching him against Tennessee(when he had multiple fumbles against Indy & Washington, then none against Miami, & Dallas)........ that didn't make a lot of sense to me.
Then you've got the most sacked QB in NFL history of any 5 year period, and you don't teach him to play out of the shotgun. How long does it take to teach someone to take the snap out of the gun.
& if you're not going to use the shotgun, at least put 4 & 5 wide recievers. if they blitz, someone is definitely open, & that someone can get some big yards in a hurry.
Now, just so no one gets the wrong idea....... I do not think David should start for the Texans in September. He needs to be the #2 QB from training camp, and earn the starting position during the season. If I had my way, he would be a true back up, meaning the only way he can play on Sunday, is if Sage gets hurt. & when he comes into the game, he's got to make it a tough decision to put a healthy Rosenfels back out there(Kinda like what happened to Huard & Green, or Batch & Rothlisberger in '06. Or Gerard & Leftwhich in '05).
& forget Plummer. He's a basket case. If he can't do anything without Kubiak, then he's nothing special...... nothing worth paying for anyway. Better than Carr...... but Carr's our mistake, Jake isn't.