TwinSisters
Veteran
Caveat lector: Buddy/Clan vs Merit is a time honoured debate amongst all of humanity. Both have won and lost over the years... Muslims built an empire on merit, Washington forged a nation on merit, Mongols ruled the world with clans, Kennedy ran a country with buddys and 'men of the family'. While Romans won and lost on both. So the Kubiak's buddy system doesn't automatically condem it to failure, however just because Ferdinand Marcos, Suharto, Kennedy, Ford, and the Waltons use the buddy system to conduct business, it doesn't mean automatic success.
----
Is it a Buddy system or is it a Merit based system? That's the question. The question is not about 'if it sucks'. There have been no games played.
Front office:
Bronco Buddy: Rookie GM / GM - Rick Smith - Broncos
Bronco Buddy: 8 Years in job /College Scouting - Dale Strahm - Broncos
Casserly Buddy : 2 years / Pro Scouting - Chuck Banker - Texans
Don't know where Banker is now. His name is not on the charts. There are some Casserly guys there though; Kisiel and Saimes.
Coaching Staff:
Aggie/Bronco Source: Rookie HC /Gary Kubiak (Head Coach) - Broncos
Aggie Buddy: 6 years as HC/GM / Mike Sherman (Asst. HeadCoach/Offense) - Packers
Bronco Buddy: Rookie OC /Troy Calhoun (Offensive Coordinator/Quarterbacks) - Broncos
Bronco Buddy: 1 year DC /Richard Smith (Defensive Coordinator) - Dolphins/Lions
Capers Buddy: 10 years / Joe Marciano (Special Teams Coordinator) - Texans
Merit: Rookie DBs /Martin Bayless (Asst. Defensive Backs) - Raiders
Kubiak Buddy: 1 Year /John Benton (Offensive Line) - Rams
Capers Merit: 25+ years /Chick Harris (Running Backs) - Texans
Merit: 4 years /Jon Hoke (Defensive Backs) - Texans
Aggie Buddy: 4 Years /Johnny Holland (Linebackers) - Packers/Seahawks/Lions
Casserly Buddy: 14 years / Bob Karmelowicz (Defensive Line) - Chiefs
Bronco Buddy, but this guy doesn't count for beans... he makes coffee. Mike McDaniel (Offensive Assistant) - Broncos
Bronco Buddy: 9 years /Brian Pariani (Tight Ends) - Syracuse/Broncos/49ers
Merit: Rookie, but this guy serves the coffee that McDaniel makes. Robert Saleh (Defensive Assistant) - Texans
Bronco Buddy: Rookie, but never had to make or serve coffee, because he is the Coach's son. Kyle Shanahan (Wide Receivers) - Buccaneers
In the 4 critical spots
HC - Rookie
GM - Rookie
OC - Rookie
DC - 1 year
Smith and Holland come from the Lions. Yes, that is the Detroit Lions. They were fired by the Detroit Lions ( this of course can be seen as a plus or minus ).
Of the two Merit based hires, they most likely are Bowling Green buds.
What's the one thing over the past 5 years that is brought up with the Chiefs? They would be in the Super Bowl if they had a defense. For the past 6 years they have never been ranked above 16th in points allowed or yards allowed.
So our defensive coaches look like a mix of Detroit, KC, and the old Texans. That's not good.
----
The point in taking the time to type all of this crap out is to say they have PROVEN NOTHING. They have a lot TO PROVE.
----
Is it a Buddy system or is it a Merit based system? That's the question. The question is not about 'if it sucks'. There have been no games played.
Front office:
Bronco Buddy: Rookie GM / GM - Rick Smith - Broncos
Bronco Buddy: 8 Years in job /College Scouting - Dale Strahm - Broncos
Casserly Buddy : 2 years / Pro Scouting - Chuck Banker - Texans
Don't know where Banker is now. His name is not on the charts. There are some Casserly guys there though; Kisiel and Saimes.
Coaching Staff:
Aggie/Bronco Source: Rookie HC /Gary Kubiak (Head Coach) - Broncos
Aggie Buddy: 6 years as HC/GM / Mike Sherman (Asst. HeadCoach/Offense) - Packers
Bronco Buddy: Rookie OC /Troy Calhoun (Offensive Coordinator/Quarterbacks) - Broncos
Bronco Buddy: 1 year DC /Richard Smith (Defensive Coordinator) - Dolphins/Lions
Capers Buddy: 10 years / Joe Marciano (Special Teams Coordinator) - Texans
Merit: Rookie DBs /Martin Bayless (Asst. Defensive Backs) - Raiders
Kubiak Buddy: 1 Year /John Benton (Offensive Line) - Rams
Capers Merit: 25+ years /Chick Harris (Running Backs) - Texans
Merit: 4 years /Jon Hoke (Defensive Backs) - Texans
Aggie Buddy: 4 Years /Johnny Holland (Linebackers) - Packers/Seahawks/Lions
Casserly Buddy: 14 years / Bob Karmelowicz (Defensive Line) - Chiefs
Bronco Buddy, but this guy doesn't count for beans... he makes coffee. Mike McDaniel (Offensive Assistant) - Broncos
Bronco Buddy: 9 years /Brian Pariani (Tight Ends) - Syracuse/Broncos/49ers
Merit: Rookie, but this guy serves the coffee that McDaniel makes. Robert Saleh (Defensive Assistant) - Texans
Bronco Buddy: Rookie, but never had to make or serve coffee, because he is the Coach's son. Kyle Shanahan (Wide Receivers) - Buccaneers
In the 4 critical spots
HC - Rookie
GM - Rookie
OC - Rookie
DC - 1 year
Smith and Holland come from the Lions. Yes, that is the Detroit Lions. They were fired by the Detroit Lions ( this of course can be seen as a plus or minus ).
Of the two Merit based hires, they most likely are Bowling Green buds.
What's the one thing over the past 5 years that is brought up with the Chiefs? They would be in the Super Bowl if they had a defense. For the past 6 years they have never been ranked above 16th in points allowed or yards allowed.
So our defensive coaches look like a mix of Detroit, KC, and the old Texans. That's not good.
----
The point in taking the time to type all of this crap out is to say they have PROVEN NOTHING. They have a lot TO PROVE.