Texans need Running Back

[Eyeguy]

Sir... ummm, yea I think you should actually state better facts about what you are saying because ....to me , you sound completly ridiculous. There is no way at all you can compare McNeil to VY, why would you even say something like that is obsurd. The only people in the running that even come close to VY is Leinart or Cutler and still thats a long ways away from the awesome talent that VY progresses. Therefore I'll take back what you just quoted, no prob.

There are plenty of examples of 2nd or lower round picks surpassing those 1st round QB picks re: Farve,Brady, ect.
McNeil was the Parade Mag. co-player of the year with VY in High School. McNeil is faster and has a better release point. He was the MVP of E/W Shrine Game. If he had played for UT he might have had better record against Okl. than VY.
No one can say for sure who will be the better pro QB only TIME WILL TELL. Do I think McNeil will be picked before Young-no. Is McNeil a better value in the 3rd or 4th rnd.- yes
I mean no disrespect to VY, but I think Mc Neal will make a better pro player and no one will be able to say diffrent for a couple of years.

 

[MorKnolle]

There are plenty of examples of 2nd or lower round picks surpassing those 1st round QB picks re: Farve,Brady, ect.
McNeil was the Parade Mag. co-player of the year with VY in High School. McNeil is faster and has a better release point. He was the MVP of Sr. Bowl. If he had played for UT he might have had better record against Okl. than VY.
No one can say for sure who will be the better pro QB only TIME WILL TELL. Do I think McNeil will be picked before Young-no. Is McNeil a better value in the 3rd or 4th rnd.- yes
I mean no disrespect to VY, but I think Mc Neal will make a better pro player and no one will be able to say diffrent for a couple of years.

FYI McNeal was the MVP of the East/West Shrine Game not the Senior Bowl, that is about all I want to add to this argument.

 

[Huge]

There are plenty of examples of 2nd or lower round picks surpassing those 1st round QB picks re: Farve,Brady, ect.
McNeil was the Parade Mag. co-player of the year with VY in High School. McNeil is faster and has a better release point. He was the MVP of E/W Shrine Game. If he had played for UT he might have had better record against Okl. than VY.
No one can say for sure who will be the better pro QB only TIME WILL TELL. Do I think McNeil will be picked before Young-no. Is McNeil a better value in the 3rd or 4th rnd.- yes
I mean no disrespect to VY, but I think Mc Neal will make a better pro player and no one will be able to say diffrent for a couple of years.

Trying to resist...not working...

For starters: No, McNeal was not the Parade Magazine co-player of the year with Young.

Sinorice Moss was the MVP of the Senior Bowl. Does that make him a better WR than Santonio Holmes?

If Young had played at A&M, he might have had a better record against Baylor.

Agreed McNeal is faster but how does this make him a better QB? He's certainly not a better runner.

Also agreed that McNeal has a better release point. But does that make him a better passer? Not when you look at the stats.

You're able to say you think McNeal will make a better pro QB but nobody else can say anything different for a couple of years? I disagree. I think Young will make a better pro QB. See? That wasn't too hard.