DRAMA said:
Seriously? WOW! The whole Bush weight thing? Silly. Blaming Bush for Pete Carroll's idiocy? Silly! Thinking that if Reggie Bush was from my fingernail to my knuckle taller and was holding a 5lb dumbell then he'd a 'perfect' size is SILLY!
If you want Vince - be proud of it. Saying you wouldn't take Marshall Faulk in the top 6?
Ridiculous!
First off, I'm not a Vince Young only fan. I'd rather we take D'Brick, or trade down & pick up more picks. Young does intrigue me, but so does Carr behind an improved offensive line.
I believe that Carr will do just fine & that Young will not have any more of an immediate impact on this team than Bush will. Both Carr & DD are more than adequate & should be able to step up their games a notch, or two, with an improved OL.
The only knock on DD is that he doesn't have break away speed & he's missed a couple of games with injuries. However, DD has proven he can go up the middle & rip off a 20 yard gain. Given an improved OL, he might rip 20 yard gains with more regularity.
In my opinion, Young is at least 2 years away from being a starter in the NFL. Do you want to put some odds on the fans being willing to wait another 2 years?
I believe that D'Brick would be an immediate contributor, whether it's at LT, or RT while he learns.
Mario Williams would have an immediate impact on our defense, as would Huff & Hawk.
However, the one player that I believe is the most intriguing & would have the biggest impact of them all, is Vernon Davis switching to WR. I just can't get that thought out of my mind. It would still require us to upgrade the OL, but I'd be more than willing to take a LT in the 2nd round in this scenario. With an improved OL, Carr would have a field day throwing to AJ, VD, DD, Mathis & Putz. Add to that, Carr's scrambling abilities, & you have the makings of a very potent offense.
Putting Bush, or Young, in that equation, doesn't significantly improve the team, in my opinion.