Once and for all: Carr

[TheCD]

I think the Cardnals realized their problem was much deeper than QB, and they had no right holding on to him, till they fixed their problems.... that's just my take. I'm sure they understand that a lot of success Jake has had, was because he left Arizona.


why?? They had their starter. and had Aaron Brooks not run off the mouth about the guy signing his pay check, he'd still be the guy in N.O.



I seriously doubt any of those teams want trent green back... I just don't believe it.


You think the Skins think they would've won that SuperBowl if they would've kept Brad Johnson??

You really think that huh??


Because you believe the Titans believe McNair was an underachiever??

OK.


whose worried?? I'm not worried.......

I was showing what you wanted...teams that wish they hadn't given up their QB. I guarantee you the Skins wish they had a proven starter the past couple of years. I never said they would have won a Super Bowl...but the fact he did shows that he's a more than competent starter than what they've had

Likewise, the Cardinals wish they hadn't let Plummer go regardless of why they did...

Now, considering the inconsistency of Aaron Brooks, and the (relative) consistency of Jake Delhomme, I'll bet they wish they'd kept Jake around.

You can't tell me that none of those teams want Trent Green back...he's proven himself year in and year out on a team with very little defense to back up the offense. He's shown that with a solid running game he can do more than his share to get the job done. There's no way I'm going to believe any team wouldn't want a sure-fire PRO BOWL QB for a mere $7.14 mil per year http://www.fantasysports.aol.com/fb/playerProfile.cfm/pid.1275

Like I said in my post about McNair...it was off-topic, but I still believe they'll regret it.

My point wasn't to YOU about not worrying, my friend...it was to show those out there who are UNSURE about how David Carr will fair under our new coaching regime that they have proven success with an under-achieving QB thrown into a new system (And yes, I DO agree that Carr has under-achieved, I just believe that, seeing as I have always been told by my coaches throughout high school, coaching is an enormous part of a QB's success and his many shortcomings thus far will be remedied).

 

[Wolf]

reading the posts the debate proves one thing (when listing out these guys)

And Kubiak said something along the lines.. It is the coaches job to get the best out of the player and to get the player into a system that brings out the best in the player..

well you look around these posts and around the league (or history of the league).. coaches IMO have to be smart enough to get figure out the players and the scheme that fits the players.

Alvin Harper..was far from being a superstar but as far being a corey bradford type(make the touch catch,drop the easy one) was adequate with the cowboys ..yet with (what was it) washington and tampa.. stunk
J Lewis.. pro bowl kick returner with Baltimore, yet with us ...flopped

Priest holmes...baltimore ..style didn't fit in ..yet KC shifted gears...

listing of the QB's on previous posts..apples and oranges

Would Plummer have done well as well in Arizona if he stayed..hard to say.different coaches different scheme. I can't prove this but I'd guess no

...
Same with Carr..He has the tools to make everythrow.. Lets see if Kubiak can get him in a scheme that can succeed.(honestly no excuses for Carr from me..baring injury to some key players.. we actually have talent on the offensive side (TE,#2WR, OL..etc etc)

Unless you think the Dom Capers era offense was an adequate scheme (which I think Dom's scheme is more like Carolinas scheme...you pound the ball and open up the pass.well we couldn't pound the ball consistantly so we were dead in the water on passing because we couldn't protect)

 

[Hulk75]

"Give the guy a break"

He's going into the 5th year--and still counting--of his 'break.' What more do you want?

I have realized your here for one thing, so it is pointless to argue with you. You dont come here to discuss like some of us..............You ramble, if you have a question ask it.................BUUTTT there is 30 plays of loss yards and the backups only had blah

................"I got sacked 15 times all of last year (at Fresno State)," he said. "It's a new thing for me."

Anything else worth discussing?