Keep Texans Talk Google Ad Free!
Venmo Tip Jar | Paypal Tip Jar
Thanks for your support! 🍺😎👍

Jim Harbaugh

At least our bad QB is cheap! Watching Kaep play this season, and most of last season, goes to show the saying is true... No matter how good or bad the QB looks in their first season, you truly don't know if you have your franchise QB until the 3rd year. 9ers missed their window.

i think the kaepernick decision was (or will be) his ultimate undoing. alex smith had turned into the epitome of game manager with harbaugh's tutelage and was smartly winning games. the offense ran well enough that an athlete was able to step in and continue the trend, but kaep is only that - an athlete. he's not a quarterback. injuries and suspensions to his linebacker core, along with a team of wild personalities also certainly helped to warm his seat.

that being said, my stance doesnt change. harbaugh took a great roster and made it a monster roster. he took basically a rookie to the superbowl, and the previous quarterback to the championship game. he's on the hot seat with a 7-4 team in the toughest division in football. if he gets away, and on the off chance he'd be interested in houston, you absolutely have to persue the opportunity.
 
Kaepernick is yet another example of people falling in love with flash instead of substance at the QB position.

Fantastic athlete. Fantastic arm. No accuracy and no mental acumen for the position.

I'll admit that he's already done more in the NFL than I ever thought he would. But I think that has more to do with what he has around him in SF than it does with his own ability.
 
Adam Schefter
Reports from @JoePequenoCBS5 and @rapsheet about Michigan offer to Jim Harbaugh. Here's what I know:

Multiple NFL and Michigan sources had said for weeks 49ers HC Jim Harbaugh was not expected to wind up at Michigan, but in recent days at least one person familiar with his thinking said he was at least “considering it.”

Another person close to the process said that while it was possible Harbaugh could wind up at Michigan, “it was not likely."

Asked why he was considering it now, but hadn’t been previously, one person said now that the 49ers are out of the playoffs, it was possible for Harbaugh to at least consider it.

Bottom line: Harbaugh has some thinking to do and decisions to make.
 
NFL guys like Rapoport and Schefter look like idiots right now. They reported 2 weeks ago that Michigan met with Harbaugh and was given a firm no. That absolutely did not happen.

While it's true that it is very unlikely that he chooses Michigan in the end, the fact that these guys immediately dismissed it and then put those reports out there without even digging into it makes them look pretty bad.

Rapoport has now backtracked and is saying that the "first run" was turned down and now a "second run" has re-initiated interest. That's plain ole BS. He expressed interest from the beginning but refused to go further than that because of his commitment to the 49ers.

He now holds a significant offer from Michigan and has to choose between NFL and college.
 
At this point McNair is not even considering Harbaugh. OB just got this team to a 7-9 record at worse or 9-7 at best. OB is not going anywhere for a while
 
Humor me. O'Brien continues to struggle with his college offense. After a promising start the team implodes and poof another horrible season. Does McNair have the stones to pull the trigger if a bonafide REAL coach is available?

http://www.cbssports.com/nfl/eye-on...win-super-bowl-jim-harbaugh-wont-return-in-15

Got to hand it to ya Uncle Ricco. Another outstanding contribution of yours. Lol!

In OB's first season of taking over a 2-14 team he had a better record than the almighty Harbaugh who just went 8-8.

Where are you now? You owe Mcnair and OB an apology.
 
Can't believe the 49ers and Harbaugh couldn't get their heads out of their asses. No reason Jim Harbaugh shouldn't have been the coach of the 49ers for the next two decades. Morons all around. What a failure.
 
Can't believe the 49ers and Harbaugh couldn't get their heads out of their asses. No reason Jim Harbaugh shouldn't have been the coach of the 49ers for the next two decades. Morons all around. What a failure.

This is what huge egos and somebody having other viable options will get you.
 
Like Nick Saban, Harbaugh's mentality and personality don't mesh with millionaire adult men, whether they need it or not.

He is better suited to the college game, where the players he treats like kids are actually kids.

That's not to say he isn't a great coach, because he obviously is. But his personality wears on people and in college no player will ever have to deal with it for more than four years. That's not how it works in the pros.
 
Like Nick Saban, Harbaugh's mentality and personality don't mesh with millionaire adult men, whether they need it or not.

He is better suited to the college game, where the players he treats like kids are actually kids.

That's not to say he isn't a great coach, because he obviously is. But his personality wears on people and in college no player will ever have to deal with it for more than four years. That's not how it works in the pros.

It also helps when your FO doesn't undercut you at every opportunity. Baalke has some serious Jerry Jones syndrome going on. He was not happy that Harbaugh got the credit for winning with his players.

Going by winning percentage, 2 of the top 3 coaches fired in NFL history were fired by the 49ers. One obviously being Harbaugh (#3, .690%) and the other being George Seifert (#1, .766%).

Both coaches are the only coaches in 49ers history (other than Walsh) to get them to the Super Bowl. Both were fired unceremoniously despite overwhelming success. Harbaugh being forced out despite never having a losing season and going to 3 NFC CCGs in 4 years and Seifert being forced to resign despite never winning less than 10 games in a season and winning 2 SB's.
 
It also helps when your FO doesn't undercut you at every opportunity. Baalke has some serious Jerry Jones syndrome going on. He was not happy that Harbaugh got the credit for winning with his players.

Going by winning percentage, 2 of the top 4 coaches fired in NFL history were fired by the 49ers. One obviously being Harbaugh (#4, .690%) and the other being George Seifert (#1, .766%).

Both coaches are the only coaches in 49ers history (other than Walsh) to get them to the Super Bowl.[/QUOTE


Most of them weren't Baalke's draft picks. They were McCloughan's.
 
Like Nick Saban, Harbaugh's mentality and personality don't mesh with millionaire adult men, whether they need it or not.

He is better suited to the college game, where the players he treats like kids are actually kids.

That's not to say he isn't a great coach, because he obviously is. But his personality wears on people and in college no player will ever have to deal with it for more than four years. That's not how it works in the pros.

Sounds like Kubiak will be the next coach of the 49er's. He will give them a yes sir, no sir, aw shucks, gee wiz, and it's on me, for 8 years of mediocre football.
 
Most of them weren't Baalke's draft picks. They were McCloughan's.

Which makes it all the more curious why he ruined a good thing. The team was winning with Harbaugh. 8 years with no playoffs and then boom...3 straight CCGs with Harbaugh at the helm. They had a rough year this year. They also had half their OL and half their front seven injured and had no talent at CB because the GM didn't do his job.

A lot of people are saying it's on Harbaugh because Kaepernick regressed and that's on him. Look at the stats. Kaepernick's numbers were on par with last year when they went to the CCG. Difference was they had no running game and he had no protection because of OL injuries.
 
York and Baalke getting freaking grilled by media.

The level of hostility coming from media to these two is quite unusual, in my experience.
 
Y'all can laugh but I wouldn't be surprised to see Kubiak or a Shanahan discussed. They have a QB who needs coached up and an offense to be jump started to go with a good D.
 
Y'all can laugh but I wouldn't be surprised to see Kubiak or a Shanahan discussed. They have a QB who needs coached up and an offense to be jump started to go with a good D.

I'd imagine Baalke noticed Kubiak's offense was up at halftime 20-3 over SEA and dominated the stats -- outgained the Seahawks 476-270, gained 29 first downs to Seattle's 15, had 88 plays to Seattle's 58 -- in 2013 before the pick 6 and OT loss.

I'd still be surprised if they went that direction, but who knows.
 
York and Baalke getting freaking grilled by media.

The level of hostility coming from media to these two is quite unusual, in my experience.
I've been telling my 49'ers friends all year that there's no reason why Harbaugh should be gone. It says more about their organization. They're doomed to irrelevance again after this.
 
Baalke seems to forget what a ****ing joke his team was before Harbaugh showed up. I don't blame him I would have left too.
 
York and Baalke getting freaking grilled by media.

The level of hostility coming from media to these two is quite unusual, in my experience.

Jed York is the epitome of a silver spoon baby. Dude was born on third base and acts like he hit a triple. He deserved to get destroyed by media after the way he acted in his PC today.

"We don't hang NFC Championship banners, we hang Super Bowl banners"

Not anymore you don't. Fired the last 2 coaches to get you to the SB.
 
I've been telling my 49'ers friends all year that there's no reason why Harbaugh should be gone. It says more about their organization. They're doomed to irrelevance again after this.

I don't know, there is a price limit on every commodity. As good as Harbaugh's record is, I'd have a bit of a hard time not chuckling at a demand for more money than Belichick makes. Now if it came down to responsibility for player decisions, then that's on the Niners unless he has a proven bad track record of wanting folks who have been busts.

I tend to think everyone involved are short sight aholes.
 
Congratulations on the purchase of your new Harbaugh!
Congratulations on the purchase of your new Harbaugh! It has been carefully constructed in the Upper Midwest and California for optimum football performance. You are guaranteed to have many memorable moments with your Harbaugh, but it is important to note that it is not designed for use beyond four years.

Here are some tips and guidelines to operating your Harbaugh:

▪ Your Harbaugh does not function like other head coaches. An innocuous query about the weather, for instance, could trigger a florid quote from Admiral William Halsey. And yet a routine question about a running back’s knee injury may cause your Harbaugh to wince, pause and grimace as if a malodorous scent has wafted into the room. Your Harbaugh’s default in this instance is: “We don’t really talk about that here” or “I can’t get inside his body” or “He’s working through something.” This is a design flaw our technicians in California have not yet worked out.

▪ You may notice that your Harbaugh never shuts off. This is normal.

▪ There are still a few bugs in the answer-response system. For instance, you may sense – due to a long pause – that your Harbaugh has completed an answer. You will begin to ask another question. You could be two sentences into your question when your Harbaugh suddenly continues his answer to the previous question. You will feel stupid. Do not be alarmed. This is normal.

▪ Your Harbaugh will be enormously affectionate one day and cold and distant the next. This is normal.

▪ Your Harbaugh will not alter his attire in a 1,460-day span. This is normal.

▪ Your Harbaugh will guard his practices like North Korea guards its missile program. He will tell you he’s concerned you will inadvertently leak information that will fall into enemy hands. He will say this with a straight face and will tell you that he mines other teams’ media reports for that type of information. There will be no evidence, however, that he does this or that it has been helpful. You will conclude he is being overly paranoid. This is normal.

▪ Your Harbaugh may arrive one day with a chipped tooth, a bent finger or a gash across his forehead. This is normal.

▪ Your Harbaugh has been programmed for combat and within six months will pick a fight with the biggest, baddest bully on the block. Urban Meyer, you have been warned.

▪ Your Harbaugh often will double-down on words for emphasis: “A-plus, plus,” “erroneous, erroneous,” “wonderful, wonderful.” This is not a glitch. Do not bring your Harbaugh in for repair. This is normal.

▪ Warning: Do not seek constructive criticism on your Harbaugh’s players. He will utter nothing but praise. A rule of thumb for operating your Harbaugh: Players who earn the heaviest amounts of praise often deserve it the least. (See Jenkins, A.J, and Baldwin, Jon).

▪ Your Harbaugh has been designed for offense and will require many high-end parts to run said offense. Yet his defense will be better than his offense. This paradox has not been explained.

▪ You may be tempted to pour Gatorade on your Harbaugh. This is not recommended unless temperatures exceed 75 degrees Fahrenheit (23.9 degrees Celsius.)​

You will enjoy your Harbaugh, especially at first. Then you will want to kick your Harbaugh in the shins. In the end, you will realize that your Harbaugh is perhaps the most unique operating system ever created and that you have been lucky to have had a chance to experience it. Some assembly required. Ages 18 and up.
:spit:
 
5 years from now this will likely look like one of the biggest failed moves by an organization I've seen in a very long time. People are going to laugh at the Niners organization for running off the bet coach they've had since Seifert/Walsh. This team was stuck in the mud for like 15 years, and they had a guy that dug it out and was making them a contender for years now, and they ran him off.
 
5 years from now this will likely look like one of the biggest failed moves by an organization I've seen in a very long time. People are going to laugh at the Niners organization for running off the bet coach they've had since Seifert/Walsh. This team was stuck in the mud for like 15 years, and they had a guy that dug it out and was making them a contender for years now, and they ran him off.

Funny thing is this is actually the second time something like this has happened to the 49ers.... last one sent them into a tailspin for a decade.
 
49ers notes: More thoughts on the Harbaugh conversation, the snag that kept Gase from getting/taking the job, and more

...There is a clear explanation for the weird and abrupt ending last month to the 49ers’ apparent pursuit of former Denver OC Adam Gase to replace Harbaugh.

When Baalke and Gase spoke for 7+ hours in Colorado a month ago, there were reports that Gase had an agreement in place with the 49ers to be their next head coach.

That didn’t happen–Baalke flew home, talks broke off, and Tomsula was hired very quickly after that.

There have been multiple, persistent reports, mostly from people close to Gase, that Gase was all but offered the 49ers job during that face-to-face with Baalke, except for a few details.

So how did this all blow up?

According to an NFL source, Gase and Baalke did indeed come very close to an agreement for Gase to replace Harbaugh, down to the details of his prospective coaching staff, and Gase understood that his choices for the coordinator spots were approved.

Tomsula’s name was not involved in the discussions with Gase about the defensive coordinator slot, I was told.

Then, the next morning, after Baalke flew back to the Bay Area, things changed: Gase, the source says, was informed that he could only have the job if he made Tomsula his defensive coordinator.

No Tomsula, no offer.

Gase turned that suggestion down flat, and that’s when the 49ers immediately tabbed Tomsula as the head coach to follow Harbaugh.

So when Tomsula tried hard to hire Gase as his offensive coordinator, the answer was no way–and Gase went to Chicago as the offensive coordinator.
smiley.gif
 
“Wearing out welcome” isn’t new for Jim Harbaugh
Tuesday’s new episode of HBO’s Real Sports with Bryant Gumbel includes ... Andrea Kremer profiles new Michigan coach Jim Harbaugh, who has returned to Ann Arbor decades after he once patrolled the sidelines as a boy — and actually once ran into the end zone to celebrate a touchdown.

Kremer looks at Jim Harbaugh’s legendary intensity and competitiveness, which he admits has undermined plenty of relationships.

“You didn’t always play well with others, necessarily,” Kremer says to Harbaugh.

“Yeah, people say that,” Harbaugh responds.

“Well, what do you say?” Kremer asks.

“It must be true, yeah,” Harbaugh replies. “Sometimes I’d wear out my welcome.”

“What does that mean you wear out your welcome?”

“They just don’t want to be around you after a while,” Harbaugh admits.​

It happened not only when Jim Harbaugh was a youth, but also as an adult. And that may have contributed to his departure from the 49ers.

“He does a great job of giving you that spark, that initial boom,” 49ers guard Alex Boone tells Kremer. “But after a while, you just want to kick his ass. . . . He just keeps pushing you, and you’re like, ‘Dude, we got over the mountain. Stop. Let go.’ He kind of wore out his welcome.”

“What does that mean?” Kremer asks.

“I think he just pushed guys too far. He wanted too much, demanded too much, expected too much. You know, ‘We gotta go out and do this. We gotta go out and do this. We gotta go out and do this.’ And you’d be like, ‘This guy might be clinically insane. He’s crazy.’ . . . I think that if you’re stuck in your ways enough, eventually people are just going to say, ‘Listen, we just can’t work with this.'”

Boone also said something that shed’s light on the perspective of the locker room. “The players had nothing to do with him getting fired,” Boone says, which suggests that the players aren’t buying the whole “mutual parting” thing.

Brother John Harbaugh, the Ravens head coach who beat Jim’s 49ers in Super Bowl XLVII, recalls a strong obsession with winning when they were youths.

“He always wanted to win everything, and if he wasn’t winning — and the few times in our history growing up when I was bigger or better — it really ticked him off,” John Harbaugh said. “We have some pictures where you can see the look on his face in the picture. . . . He’s just mad that he’s shorter or he’s smaller or that he lost a basketball game or he lost a card game. He would carry it around with him for a while.”

Jim Harbaugh even competed with genetics. Obsessed with getting to six-feet, two inches, Harbaugh found a magic elixir for growth.

“I heard that if you drink milk that builds strong bones, and convinced myself that I’ll drink as much milk as I possibly can drink,” him Harbaugh said.

So as a third grader, Jim Harbaugh said he got a job at his elementary school distributing milk to the students. The pay was a free milk every day, plus the ability to drink the milk of the kids who weren’t there or who didn’t want their milk.

“I drank a lot of milk, Andrea,” he says. “A lot of milk. Whole milk, though. Not the candy ass two-percent or skim milk.”

It worked. He made it not to six-two, but to six-feet, three inches.

The competition with anyone and with anything continues. The press copy of the HBO profile has video and audio of Harbaugh shouting generally at Michigan players in spring practice to “huddle the f–k up” and telling one specific player, “I’m just telling you the right way to do it. If you want to look at me with that look, go f–king someplace else.”

“Go f–king someplace else” is what the 49ers essentially told Harbaugh in December. Moving forward, the question becomes whether he’ll hear that phrase or something similar to it from the folks running the show in Ann Arbor.
http://profootballtalk.nbcsports.com/2015/04/19/wearing-out-welcome-isnt-new-for-jim-harbaugh/
 
Kyle McLorg KyleMclorgBASG
Source: midway thru 2014, York walked into meeting Harbaugh was holding w/ players, & Harbaugh told Jed that the meeting was for "men only"

Certainly not the beginning of the animosity, but the source said it was a major breaking point in the Harbaugh-York relationship
 
I'd gladly give up howdy doody for Harbough if the Niners want to be this stupid

The more I think about it, with the way several of the 9ers are retiring, I'm wondering if Harbaugh was covering up for something; PEDs, Drugs, Sexboat... something & they're thinking they need to get while the getting is good.

I'd have to do a lot more "investigating" before I'd sign off on bringing baby Harbaugh to my organization.
 
The more I think about it, with the way several of the 9ers are retiring, I'm wondering if Harbaugh was covering up for something; PEDs, Drugs, Sexboat... something & they're thinking they need to get while the getting is good.

I'd have to do a lot more "investigating" before I'd sign off on bringing baby Harbaugh to my organization.


Don't need any HC's that are driven solely by winning.
 
The more I think about it, with the way several of the 9ers are retiring, I'm wondering if Harbaugh was covering up for something; PEDs, Drugs, Sexboat... something & they're thinking they need to get while the getting is good.

I'd have to do a lot more "investigating" before I'd sign off on bringing baby Harbaugh to my organization.

It's the Cowboys so drugs and lots sex would be welcomed to the criminal element
 
jim-harbaugh-crazy-Brian-Spurlock-USA-TODAY-Sports.jpg


What we’ll miss about Jim Harbaugh

When the 49ers’ training camp begins in about a month, practices will be shorter, quieter, less intense than last year. And someone will be missing.

Jim Harbaugh.

His absence hangs over the 49ers’ entire season. He’s the biggest story on the team, and he isn’t even on the team.

Let’s acknowledge he who must not be named. These are the top five things I will miss about Harbaugh.

The way he ran practices

When practice started, the bill of Harbaugh’s hat pointed straight in front him. He’d watch the players warm up, make notes with a sharpie and blow his whistle — official coach stuff.

That would last about 20 minutes. Then Harbaugh would turn his cap backwards, run over to a position group and do drills with them. Sometimes he’d throw passes with the quarterbacks. Sometimes he’d run routes with the tight ends. Sometimes he’d kick punts so the special teams could practice blocking them.

He was the most enthusiastic coach I’ve ever seen. He couldn’t just coach a practice — he had to participate in it, be the center of it. He was like the sun, and the players were planets orbiting him.

The way he shut down national writers and radio hosts

Harbaugh likes to shut down people’s questions. He’ll quibble with the wording, or simply refuse to answer. Especially if he doesn’t know the questioner.

Sometimes a famous national writer would come to Santa Clara for a day to ask Harbaugh a few questions during his group interview. The writer seemed to expect thoughtful, in-depth answers from Harbaugh, as if Harbaugh’s would be impressed by the writer’s byline, as if Harbaugh shut down only the local beat writers.

For national writers like this, Harbaugh would reserve his shortest, most awkward answers. And every time, Harbaugh would catch the writer completely by surprise. The writer would quickly follow up with two or three questions and try to force a good answer out of Harbaugh, and Harbaugh would answer in monosyllables. And the writer would sit there fuming.

In that respect, Harbaugh was tremendously egalitarian.

The way he didn’t hold grudges

You can criticize Harbaugh. You can criticize his ability to coach, his offensive system, his game management. You can even criticize his personality. The next day, he’ll greet you with a smile. He doesn’t take business personally.

I’ll give you an example. In 2013, Aldon Smith drove his truck into a tree when he was drunk a few days before the 49ers’ Week 3 game against the Indianapolis Colts. Harbaugh played Smith anway.

Before the game, I predicted the 49ers would lose. They lost by 20. After the game, I wrote “by playing Aldon Smith, Jim Harbaugh undermined the integrity of the franchise.”

The next day, Harbaugh walked through the 49ers’ locker room looking for me. “Hi, Grant,” he said with a smile. It was the first time he ever talked to me or said my name. We always got along after that.

His defensive staff

You always can tell the pedigree of a coach by the quality of his assistants. A bad coach is threatened by top-notch assistants — he’s afraid one of them will take his job. Former Warriors coach Mark Jackson was threatened by his assistants.

Harbaugh never was. Harbaugh had the best assistant coaches, especially on defense where he needed help. Harbaugh freely admitted defense wasn’t his thing — he was an offensive guy. He needed great defensive coaches, and he got them.

In the entire league, Vic Fangio was the best defensive coordinator and Ed Donatell was the best defensive backs coach. Harbaugh hired both of them, and he gets credit for doing that.

It was such a pleasure watching Fangio and Donatell make the 49ers’ defense one of the best in the NFL year after year, no matter which players they had.

His competitiveness

Harbaugh didn’t merely want to win. He wanted to kick butt, wanted to embarrass the other head coach.

Any coach going against Harbaugh was in for it. Jobs were at stake — not just wins and losses.

Former Detroit Lions head coach Jim Schwartz learned that the hard way. Not only did Harbaugh beat him in 2011, Harbaugh ruined him, slapped Schwartz in the back after the game and made him look like a little complaining punk. Two seasons later, the Lions fired him. It’ll be a while before he gets another chance to coach an NFL team.

Then there’s Green Bay Packers’ head coach Mike McCarthy, generally considered one of the best coaches in the NFL.

Every time they faced each other, McCarthy was a step behind. He’d adjust to what Harbaugh did in the previous game, but not to what Harbaugh did in the current game. By the fourth quarter, McCarthy would look ill on the sideline. Harbaugh gave him sour stomach.

I’ll miss the sour-stomach look.​


jim-harbaugh.jpg


What we won't miss about Jim Harbaugh

Yesterday we covered what we’ll miss about Jim Harbaugh. Today we’ll cover what we won’t miss, or at least what I won’t miss.

Harbaugh’s offense

It was stone-age.

Let me amend that — the passing game was stone-age. Harbaugh’s running game was pretty good. That’s where he expressed his creativity. But his passing game boiled down to, “Drop straight back, throw downfield and hope for the best.” Stuff that would have made Bill Walsh snicker.

And the passing game was only the third-worst thing about Harbaugh’s offense.

The second-worst thing was how conservative it was. Harbaugh would send out his field-goal kicking unit over and over and let the opponent hang around when they should have lost already.

But the worst was Harbaugh’s play-calling system. Just calling the play took him and his coaches forever. It seemed they burned timeouts to avoid delay penalties almost every game. Call it slapstick football.

Harbaugh’s offensive coordinator

Greg Roman deserves his own section. Harbaugh hired him, so Harbaugh’s responsible for him.

Roman called the offensive plays. His first 15 — the plays he scripted — often were clever and effective. But when he went off-script, he got lost.

He frequently forgot to repeat plays that were successful earlier in the game. Week 9 last season against the Rams, for example – the Niners’ offense averaged almost 9 yards per carry on counter runs, but Roman only called three of them. The Niners lost 13-10.

Roman did other weird things when he went off-script. One series he would use three wide receivers, then the next series he’d use four, and then the next series he’d use two tight ends. He seemed to want to impress the crowd with his vast array of plays and personnel groupings instead of just calling the stuff his players did best. This made my brain hurt.

But what really made my brain hurt was the way Roman answered questions. Like after Week 1 last season. The Niners had cut running back LaMichael James, so a reporter asked Roman if James wasn’t a good fit in the offense.

“I think LaMichael’s a really good football player,” Roman said.

Really? Then how come you never found an effective way to use him, Greg?

Harbaugh should have fired Roman years ago. But Harbaugh was loyal, so they went down together.

Harbaugh’s behavior during games

Harbaugh argued with the officials almost every play.

He’d scream, he’d spit, he’d stomp, he’d throw down his hat or his play sheet or his headset or all three, like a kid throwing a tantrum — all while the play clock was ticking down to zero.

Harbaugh obviously didn’t care what people thought of his behavior, which was his business. But he was the one who radioed Greg Roman’s play selections to the quarterback. How could Harbaugh do that and go berserk at the same time?

A coach is supposed to move on to the next play, not fume over the previous one. Maybe the Niners would have gotten their plays in quicker if Harbaugh could have emotionally detached himself from the game.

Harbaugh’s secretiveness

You would have thought Harbaugh was planning the invasion of Normandy.

Almost everything was a secret, almost every line of questioning off limits. You couldn’t ask him about scheme or injuries, you couldn’t ask him to compare or contrast things and you couldn’t interview his assistant coaches.

In four years, I never met his quarterbacks coach, Geep Chryst. Not one time. I requested to interview him and got turned down. Sometimes I wondered if he really existed.

One of the first things new head coach Jim Tomsula did this offseason was introduce his entire coaching staff to the media. Finally, I met Chryst. He was charming and interesting, and he spoke for about 30 minutes without giving away any state secrets.

What was Harbaugh so worried about?

Harbaugh’s catchphrases

Local beat writers had an unspoken rule about Harbaugh interviews: If you asked a question which elicited one of Harbaugh’s cliché catchphrases, you failed.

His catchphrases included, but were not limited to the following: Mighty men, humble hearts, iron sharpens iron, low-hanging fruit, blue-collar team, that’s scheme, God willing and the creek don’t rise, trusted agent, the olive jar, peeling back the onion, working through something, plowing ground, he’s a football player, Freddy P. Soft, arrows up, A-plus-plus.

As I would drive to Santa Clara every morning, I would test my questions to see if Harbaugh could answer them with “mighty men,” “humble hearts” or any of his meaningless responses. I called this the Harbaugh Game.

I don’t have to play that game anymore, and we don’t have to hear Harbaugh’s slogans ever again.

Who’s got it better than us now?​
 


Jed York, Jim Tomsula, the Ghost of Harbaugh, and all the rationalizations and unrealistic expectations that now burden the 49ers

Thank you, Jed York, for reminding us about everything at stake in this upcoming 49ers season and everything that was foul about the previous one.

Of course, Jim Tomsula might not thank his boss for ramping up the pressure days before the first training camp practice and many weeks before the first game of 2015.

But oh well, Jimmy T, welcome to life in the 49ers cauldron, where nothing is ever Jed’s fault and when he talks he only makes things worse.

OK, this latest instance probably wasn’t intentional; I presume the 49ers CEO’s recent ridiculous comments to MMQB.com comparing Tomsula’s hiring to the Warriors’ hiring of Steve Kerr were meant merely to compliment York’s hand-picked coach.


We can guess that York just thought that was the proper way to frame the 2015 season and to brush away the Jim Harbaugh era.

The York view: Kerr controversially replaced Mark Jackson and immediately won a championship, so Tomsula controversially replacing Harbaugh is basically the same thing!

Actually, York’s comparison breaks down in so many real ways that it only highlights how far out of touch 49ers management has become.

Here’s what York said in the otherwise very smart Tomsula profile:

“Culture is huge,” York told MMQB’s Emily Kaplan. “That’s the difference between a championship-caliber team and a championship team.

“You look at the Golden State Warriors. They were the dumbest team in the NBA for letting Mark Jackson go, who won the most games in the franchise’s history. How could you be so dumb?

“They bring in Steve Kerr, who has been around the game for a long period of time but has never coached before. Kerr changes the culture, comes in with a different perspective, and look what happens.”

You don’t have to parse York’s comments too much to figure out that…

1. He’s implying that the team was good enough to win a championship under Harbaugh but that the “culture” under Harbaugh kept the 49ers from getting over the last hurdle.

The 49ers were bad, then they hired Harbaugh and he took the 49ers to three consecutive NFC championship games; but it’s still Harbaugh’s fault, according to York.

Yeah, York surely would know this because the other coaches hired under his watch have been: Mike Nolan (as Jed was just coming into power), Mike Singletary and now Tomsula.

If anything tells you that an owner knows how to pick a champion leader, it’s putting the franchise in the hands of Nolan and Singletary.

2. York is ignoring some history–Kerr won five championships as a player under legends Phil Jackson and Gregg Popovich, was a general manager and a long-time announcer and was one of the hottest names on the coaching market when the Warriors hired him.

Tomsula has none of that background and was not one of the hottest names on the coaching market last winter.

Actually, if you’re going to compare the Kerr hiring to anything in 49ers history, you’d compare it to the hiring of Harbaugh—with multiple other teams in play—in January 2011.

But York and general manager Trent Baalke would prefer not to do that.

3. Kerr inherited a Warriors team that had just been eliminated in the playoffs and had a young core—Stephen Curry, Draymond Green and Klay Thompson—and Kerr added to that by putting together one of the best coaching staffs in the NBA.

Tomsula is taking over an 8-8 team that since then has lost Patrick Willis, Justin Smith, Chris Borland, Frank Gore, Anthony Davis and several great assistant coaches.

Also, there is no reasonable person who would currently call Tomsula’s current staff one of the best in the NFL.

4. By drawing a parallel to the Warriors’ firing of Mark Jackson, York finally is tacitly conceding that yes, he and Baalke actually fired Harbaugh.

Who is the first principal to say that Harbaugh was essentially fired? That would’ve been Harbaugh, to me, in mid-February, after York insisted for months that the separation was “mutual.”

If the CEO will mislead everyone on something as simple as this, when can you ever trust him?

5. The worst part: York isn’t so much praising Tomsula, really, York is congratulating himself for his own daring and genius.

If Tomsula turns out to be a great coach, it will happen on the field, and York and Baalke will get full credit.

But York couldn’t wait for the games; he had to reach for the splashiest example out there, and now anything short of an epic 49ers season will seem like a failure—according to the owner’s own words.

Obviously, Tomsula doesn’t need that kind of pressure, the players don’t need it, and the fans don’t need it.

Jed York, though, decided it was the way to go, and if you don’t like it, what are you going to do about it? Go get a job in Michigan?​
 
Back
Top