Keep Texans Talk Google Ad Free!
Venmo Tip Jar | Paypal Tip Jar
Thanks for your support! 🍺😎👍
Jarrod Baxter, Garrick Jones Released:Joppru PUP
- Thread starter TEXANS84
- Start date
ledzeppelin229
Hall of Fame
PUP list looks to be only a formality, I expect him to be on IR before long. They must think pretty highly of him when healthy for them to stick it out like this.
ledzeppelin269 said:
I am torn on this one. While a large part of health is luck, a good part of being a player is being able to play. Joppru has been unable to play for three years now. 2nd round choice or not even the most compassionate person has a point where it is best to move on.
Not cutting Joppru now is all about the cap. He still carries over $800K in signing bonus over the next 2 years.ArlingtonTexan said:
It doesn't cost anything to keep Joppru for another year and see if he can get through a mini camp. As long as the Texans don't count on a contribution from Joppru as I think they did coming into this offseason.
Lucky said:
What's the cap 85M....math not my strong suit but that is less than 1%. 800,000 sounds a lot but, it is not really. I just watched the Cowboys cut Jacob Rogers who is mid 2nd rounder from 2004, who could not stay healthy.
I have been developing a theory that Texans management hates to admitting to mistakes and hides this under the guise of patience. Still some holes in the thought and waiting to see how they handle certain players over the next 10 days or so.
That's a completely different situation in that Parcells felt that Rogers could at least try to play with the injury. Rogers opted for surgery & Parcells sent a message to the rest of the team that he'll decide whether you're healthy enough to play.ArlingtonTexan said:
No one on the Texans believe that Joppru could play this season with torn ligaments. My point is that there's no good reason to cut Joppru now, except to "own up". The mistake the Texans made was in not coming up with a TE this offseason, not by drafting Bennie in the 1st place. Who could have known he would be injured 3 years in a row? Hollings you can point to as a mistake because he came in as injured goods and never got his game back. Joppru was just freaky bad luck. If it hurts nothing to keep him on injured reserve for another year, why not bring him back?
Lucky said:
IMO, they have been beyond fair with Joppru. If I were another player I am wondering about getting cut for poor performance and another guy who can't stay healthy (unlucky or not) keeps getting paychecks. Unfair to the healthy player after a point. It seems a little cold, but thank the guy for his hard work, injury settle and allow him to move foward.
Hollings is a player i am waiting to see how they handle before I start making the generalization from above. Weary falls in to that category also. Don't feel like listing, but the 2nd and 3rd rounds have not been too kind to the Texans.
Vinny
shiny happy fan
I think most of his money owed is in bonus and that is being paid regardless since it is guaranteed. There is no sense in cutting him now since most of his money owed is still going into his bank account. The real mistake would be to cut him now and him catch on with another team and give them his healthy years at a subvented price while we were stuck with paying a guy the large bonus. I think it makes no sense to release him. Just bring him back next year and try it again. It's not like it is costing us that much more money...or even a roster spot (since he will be on IR).
Vinny said:
My other problem is this...Let's assume he was going to have a solid career pre-injury. We now have a guy that will not have played in any real football since January 2003 in September 2006. Not many players have taken three and half years off and been successful. The number lowers when you talk about players who have been injuried for most of that time. Joppru has went from a guy you expected to be entering his prime in 2006 to a guy that you are hoping stay healthy enough to play in pre-season games (much less real). Personally, I would not criticize the Texans for giving up on Joppru too soon. If he turns into a really good NFL TE at any point, whatever team benefits is now lucky, not smart.
His signing bonus went into his bank account in 2003.
The accounting proration (approx 400k/yr) is on the cap this year and next, in addition to his base of 380k this year and 460k next year if he's still around.
It would count as much on the cap to keep him as to cut him this season, unless they split the dead money over two years which they would be allowed based on the timing of the cut.
There's really no reason to cut him, but they are rolling coins to pay for Carr's extension. Based on his history there's no reason to believe he will ever make it out of training camp but enigmatic as he is, he'll probably get one last chance next year.
The accounting proration (approx 400k/yr) is on the cap this year and next, in addition to his base of 380k this year and 460k next year if he's still around.
It would count as much on the cap to keep him as to cut him this season, unless they split the dead money over two years which they would be allowed based on the timing of the cut.
There's really no reason to cut him, but they are rolling coins to pay for Carr's extension. Based on his history there's no reason to believe he will ever make it out of training camp but enigmatic as he is, he'll probably get one last chance next year.