Gosselin's Top 5 by position

[Errant Hothy]

http://www.dallasnews.com/sharedcontent/dws/spt/football/nfl/draft/gosselin_rankings.html

QBs:
1. Matt Leinart Southern California
2. Jay Cutler Vanderbilt
3. Vince Young Texas
4. Brodie Croyle Alabama
5. Kellen Clemens Oregon

OTs:
1. D'Brickashaw Ferguson Virginia
2. Winston Justice Southern California
3. Marcus McNeill Auburn
4. Eric Winston Miami
5. Rashad Butler Miami

RBs:
1. Reggie Bush Southern California
2. D'Angelo Williams Memphis
3. Laurence Maroney Minnesota
4. LenDale White Southern California
5. Joseph Addai LSU


The rest of the list(s) is interesting also. SOme different names at some of the positions.

 

[DominickDavisFan76]

all of them seem pretty good except the QB position,

they dont even have Omar Jacobs from Bowling Green in the top 5

I know that Omar Jacobs is probably the 3rd best QB going in the draft, but if i could rate how they will do in the NFL I would put it like this

1. Omar Jacobs-Bowling Green
2. Jay Cutler-Vanderbilt
3.Matt Leinart-USC
4.Vince Young-Texas
5. Marcus Vick-VT

Just kidding about Vick I doubt he will do good inless he straightens out

as my 5. I would probably go with some guy out of Furman.

 

[TexansLucky13]

all of them seem pretty good except the QB position,

they dont even have Omar Jacobs from Bowling Green in the top 5

I know that Omar Jacobs is probably the 3rd best QB going in the draft, but if i could rate how they will do in the NFL I would put it like this

1. Omar Jacobs-Bowling Green
2. Jay Cutler-Vanderbilt
3.Matt Leinart-USC
4.Vince Young-Texas
5. Marcus Vick-VT

Just kidding about Vick I doubt he will do good inless he straightens out

as my 5. I would probably go with some guy out of Furman.

Haha. Vick will get lucky to make the 7th Round.

But I agree that Cutler will make it above Young, no doubt. The Wonderlic had a little bit to do with that, haha.

 

[bckey]

Frank Coyle's top 5 by position:

QBs:
1. Matt Leinart Southern California
2. Vince Young Texas
3. Jay Cutler Vanderbilt
4. Brodie Croyle Alabama
5. Reggie McNeal Texas A&M

OTs:
1. D'Brickashaw Ferguson Virginia
2. Eric Winston Miami
3. Winston Justice Southern California
4. Daryn Colledge Boise St.
5. Marcus McNeill Auburn

RBs:
1. Reggie Bush Southern California
2. D'Angelo Williams Memphis
3. LenDale White Southern California
4. Laurence Maroney Minnesota
5. Brian Calhoun Wisconsin

 

[Errant Hothy]

Gosselin does not ranking players by evauluating them on his own, the man has a plethora of contacts in teh NFL (most notable in the scouting departemnts) and he uses those contacts to formulate his position ranks and his mock drafts.

 

[TexansLucky13]

Gosselin does not ranking players by evauluating them on his own, the man has a plethora of contacts in teh NFL (most notable in the scouting departemnts) and he uses those contacts to formulate his position ranks and his mock drafts.

That also serves to explain why Cutler is placed ahead of Young. The only NFL team with one of the top 15 picks that would be interested in VY is probably either the Cards or the Raiders. Most teams still frown upon Running QBs, excluding the Falcons. No offense to you Mike Vick, but the Falcons should invest in a pocket passer. Too risky.

 

[Bubbajwp]

I cant believe that they put VY's name above Reggie Bush.

 

[dalemurphy]

Gosselin doesn't have Tye Hill in the top 5 CBs nor does he have Darnell Bing listed as a top 5 safety... Can someone explain how this could be?