Objectively assessing our QBs

[santo]

I'd beat up a clown and a magician in front of a kids birthday party every Sunday for a year plus next year's top 3 picks for Andrew Luck. You're insane to say he sucks.

He sucks because he's with the Colts.
Now if he were with the Texans....

 

[sandman]

I'd beat up a clown and a magician in front of a kids birthday party every Sunday for a year plus next year's top 3 picks for Andrew Luck. You're insane to say he sucks.

He absolutely does not suck. He has been (no pun intended) Lucky enough to have his first three years in the NFL in a division that pretty much sucked except for the Texans his rookie season. 16-2 over the last three years against the AFC South. 17-13 against the rest of the NFL. He is really really good. But tough to call him great after only three years and that big of a disparity between AFC South wins and the rest of the NFL.

 

[thunderkyss]

He sucks because he's with the Colts.
Now if he were with the Texans....

Exactly

However, last year was the first year that he averaged better than 90 passer rating, more than 60% completions, & greater than 7 ypa.


Just saying.