Tha_Tinman
Waterboy
Let's just have a look at the offensive line of the current SuperBowl Champions ...shall we?
LT Marvel Smith 2nd Round 7th pick 38th Overall 2000
LG Alan Faneca 1st Round 26th 26th 1998 Pro Bowl
C Jeff Hartings 1st Round 23rd 23rd 1996 Pro Bowl
RG Kendall Simmons 1st Round 30th 2002
RT Max Starks 3rd Round 12th 75th Overall 2002
I don't remember hearing anything bad about these guys ...you can get quality linemen in later picks. I see no need to blow a top 10 pick on a lineman. It is also notable that all but one of these guys were drafted by the Steelers.
Now, the Texans have been around since 2002 ...Soooooo Who WAS taken in the first ...Lets see.
2002 1st Round 4th Pick Mike Williams - was just released by the Bills
1st Round 10th Pick Levi Jones - actually not bad, and team was 11-5 w/disappointing playoff loss this year
1st Round 29th Pick Marc Colombo - Was CUT by the Bears, picked up by the Cowboys and is now a backup
2003 1st Round 8th Pick Jordan Gross - Ok. I'll give ya THIS guy.
1st Round 20th Pick George Foster - Missed entire rookie season after being injured on THE FIRST DAY OF TRAINING CAMP!
1st Round 26th Pick Kwame Harris - His team has been 1 of the worst since he's been there, not saying it's his fault, I'm just saying!
2004 1st Round 2nd Pick Robert Gallery - In 2yrs played 32 games and is actually pretty good. But his team was 4-12 last year. So big deal.
16th Pick Shawn Andrews - missed rookie season due to injury. Bounced back but this year his team ...6-10 ...again Big deal
2005 1st Round 13th Pick Jammal Brown - started 13 games as a rooke for the SAINTS ...so what?!?
1st Round 19th Pick Alex Barron - His coach got fired after his rookie season ...not saying it's HIS fault, etc etc
1st Round 26th Pick Chris Spencer - Not many Centers taken in the 1st, he must have been good! But who knows, he was a BACKUP all year. What a waste
1st Round 32 Pick Logan Mankins - A REALLY good pick up for the Pats ...but he's a LATE 1st rounder ...STRENGTHENS my argument
My conclusion ....Don't WASTE this pick on some OVERWEIGHT lineman, when we can build a SOLID and SUCCESSFUL line in later rounds.
LT Marvel Smith 2nd Round 7th pick 38th Overall 2000
LG Alan Faneca 1st Round 26th 26th 1998 Pro Bowl
C Jeff Hartings 1st Round 23rd 23rd 1996 Pro Bowl
RG Kendall Simmons 1st Round 30th 2002
RT Max Starks 3rd Round 12th 75th Overall 2002
I don't remember hearing anything bad about these guys ...you can get quality linemen in later picks. I see no need to blow a top 10 pick on a lineman. It is also notable that all but one of these guys were drafted by the Steelers.
Now, the Texans have been around since 2002 ...Soooooo Who WAS taken in the first ...Lets see.
2002 1st Round 4th Pick Mike Williams - was just released by the Bills
1st Round 10th Pick Levi Jones - actually not bad, and team was 11-5 w/disappointing playoff loss this year
1st Round 29th Pick Marc Colombo - Was CUT by the Bears, picked up by the Cowboys and is now a backup
2003 1st Round 8th Pick Jordan Gross - Ok. I'll give ya THIS guy.
1st Round 20th Pick George Foster - Missed entire rookie season after being injured on THE FIRST DAY OF TRAINING CAMP!
1st Round 26th Pick Kwame Harris - His team has been 1 of the worst since he's been there, not saying it's his fault, I'm just saying!
2004 1st Round 2nd Pick Robert Gallery - In 2yrs played 32 games and is actually pretty good. But his team was 4-12 last year. So big deal.
16th Pick Shawn Andrews - missed rookie season due to injury. Bounced back but this year his team ...6-10 ...again Big deal
2005 1st Round 13th Pick Jammal Brown - started 13 games as a rooke for the SAINTS ...so what?!?
1st Round 19th Pick Alex Barron - His coach got fired after his rookie season ...not saying it's HIS fault, etc etc
1st Round 26th Pick Chris Spencer - Not many Centers taken in the 1st, he must have been good! But who knows, he was a BACKUP all year. What a waste
1st Round 32 Pick Logan Mankins - A REALLY good pick up for the Pats ...but he's a LATE 1st rounder ...STRENGTHENS my argument
My conclusion ....Don't WASTE this pick on some OVERWEIGHT lineman, when we can build a SOLID and SUCCESSFUL line in later rounds.