everyone thinks theres starting QB's everywhere...that every team has one....
who do you want?
The point is that we are having to teach our 5 year starter how to take a 3 step drop. After 16 games, he still screws it up. It really can't get much worse than that.
Plummer- Couldnt be good enough to hold his job with a team that has a better O-Line, TE's and running game
& David can't keep h is job here, with no better option.... Our last three offensive coordinators have focused on keeping David Carr from screwing up. Think about it....... in Carolina, when did Capers ever run as docile an offense as what we've seen in Houston?? Kerry Collins was allowed to put the ball up, and put it up often. He threw a lot of INTs, but Capers never scaled back the Offense the way he did in Houston.
Look at what Sherman did in Greenbay..... did they ever play it conservatively?? & their QB was always throwing INTs, and forcing throws.
Look at Denver...... they've never been a ball control offense.
Sage- Who has been given chances in Miami and was probably looked at by 1 or 2 other teams to be a backup QB. Yea he played good in Tenn but you remember he sucked ass in Dallas. Why not talk about that?
He looked pretty good in Dallas as well, I don't know what you're talking about. That was the first time you saw the Texans with an empty backfield, and a 5 wide receiver set. Dallas wasn't putting any pressure on David Carr, and he still couldn't get the job done.
Garcia/Bledose - Yea bring a old guy to this team. Downgrade the O-Line and Running game they had last year and let them run around behind our ****ty line.
You got a problem with old guys?? You'd be lucky to be an old guy yourself one day......... & Jeff Garcia wouldn't be running around back their if his line was all that...... or if his recievers could get open quicker.
Bledsoe?? who in the heck is talking about bringing Bledsoe to Houston??
Rookie- Yea throw in who? You cant get Russell or Brady.. who? You want to screw up another QB by letting him get sack 78 times a season or 250 for 5 years.
No one that I know of........ & no where on this board have I seen anyone talk about starting a rookie in '07.
Lets look at Grossman/Mannings/Brady/Hasselback/Leftwich/Brees/Green/Romo ect..
they have better running games and better O-Line. Agree?
Romo definitely doesn't have a better offensive line.
Eli Manning was able to win a game where he was sacked 9 times.... it was a thrilling come from behind victory.
Leftwich kinda lost his job..... Garrard kinda lost his job..... I'd assume there were protection issues in Jacksonville.
The Saints actually thought OL was going to be a weakness for them this year..... I think Brees is helping his OL, just like Manning & Brady are.
I would take Benson, Addai, Jones Jr., Bush, LT,LJ, Barber ect over all of them.
Hell other than the Raider's Oline I would take anyone else. Agree?
Why go through all that?? Just take their QBs.... with the possible exception of Oakland's.
I'm not saying Carr is the answer but I would rather have him over the people quote unquote rumors spreading around.
Been there, done that....... do you understand if the F.O. was honest about what they saw in David Carr through the 2005 season, we could've made an offer on Drew Brees??