infantrycak said:
Try reading a little closer and you will see he is talking about picking up multiple extra 1st day picks. The potential for that is huge.
A reasonable trade value scenario (let's look at the trade being made in 2004 so we can have real examples)--our #1 overall for #5 the same year plus #5 in the 2nd and a 1st rounder the next year, let's say #10 and a the #10 3rd as well.
So trade Reggie Bush for:
1st--Sean Taylor, Kellen Winslow, Roy Williams or DeAngelo Hall
2nd--Ben Troupe, Tatum Bell, Bob Sanders or Michael Boulware
1st--DeMarcus Ware or Shawnee Merriman
3rd--Justin Tuck, Kirk Morrison, Domonique Foxworth or Nick Kaczur
I have a hard time imagining Bush will help the Texans more than Sean Taylor, Ben Troupe, DeMarcus Ware and Justin Tuck combined.
Expanding on the Chargers/Giants example, if we had been the Chargers we could have chosen from:
2004 1st - Sean Taylor, Kellen Winslow, Roy Williams (the WR), DeAngelo Hall, Dunta Robinson (who we actually picked at #10), Jonathan Vilma, D.J. Williams.
2004 2nd - Teddy Lehman, Ben Troupe, Travis LaBoy, Bob Sanders, Dontarrious Thomas, Michael Boulware.
2005 1st - Shawne Merriman, Jammal Brown, Derrick Johnson, Marcus Spears (Ware went earlier)
2005 3rd - Justin Tuck, Kirk Morrison, Domonique Foxworth or Nick Kaczur
I have no doubts Reggie Bush will be a good NFL talent, but I don't think he fits well enough into our team the way it is currently been built to make up for the talent of 4-5 extra draft picks like this that we could pick up. Bush will likely create higher demand with more teams than Eli Manning did so we will be able to get more in a trade for him than what the Chargers got for Eli. Especially with Leinart being a high-demand QB in the draft this year as well, we could possibly trade down twice and pick up two extra 2nd rounders, two extra 3rd rounders for this year, and maybe a 1st or a couple 2nd rounders for next year. The way our team has been built Bush will not be able to come in and be an every down RB that will rack up 1700 rushing yards and 700 receiving yards like I had seen someone post on one of these threads (I'm not sure he can do that for any team except maybe the Broncos), that just isn't going to happen with our team. We should be able to trade the #1 pick away and acquire an additional 3-4 immediate starting quality players and a few extras as well, so I don't see how we can pass up on that. If for whatever reason teams back out on offering any kind of decent trade for him then by all means draft him and find some way to use him, but the 49ers, Jets, and maybe the Cardinals and Packers will all have very high picks in the draft and will likely be willing to trade a lot for Bush.