Texans_Chick
Utopian Dreamer
OK, we know he is smart, the generalized scouting report is that you wish he were a better athlete:
See for example: DeMeco Ryans Scouting Report
OK, I haven't seen him play but the way this is written up is that he is just a smart guy who can get into the right places but you worry some that he isn't enough of an athlete for the NFL. A shorthand.
Well then, I was goofing around and reread something I read a while back. Before the draft so I wasn't paying particulate attention to Ryans.
It was the Pat Kirwin article that we talked about a while back about how he grades players in order to get a sense of the sort of athlete they are. Obviously, it has its limitations, but it just a generalized sense of things. And lookie at this:
Just something interesting I wanted to share.
See for example: DeMeco Ryans Scouting Report
Weaknesses:
Does not have great speed...Possesses only average size...Is not a great natural athlete...Could stand to bulk up and add some weight...Must hit the weight room and get stronger...Has some trouble shedding bigger blockers...Does fine at the college level but could struggle when asked to drop into coverage as a pro.
Notes:
Tremendous college player who was the heart and soul of his squad and the type of guy every good team needs...Is not the biggest or fastest prospect out there but he is more than able to make up for his lack of ideal physical gifts with top intangibles...Should be able to come in and make an impact early on in his career.
OK, I haven't seen him play but the way this is written up is that he is just a smart guy who can get into the right places but you worry some that he isn't enough of an athlete for the NFL. A shorthand.
Well then, I was goofing around and reread something I read a while back. Before the draft so I wasn't paying particulate attention to Ryans.
It was the Pat Kirwin article that we talked about a while back about how he grades players in order to get a sense of the sort of athlete they are. Obviously, it has its limitations, but it just a generalized sense of things. And lookie at this:
If you are the kind of NFL fan who really wants to dig down into all the numbers being broadcast to us about the draft class -- the measurables if you will -- then you may find my take on some of these numbers interesting. Teams are still gathering 'measurable' numbers at Pro Day workouts, so this study is incomplete. But I thought it would be a good time to explain how I look at some of the test scores, and more importantly, how I combine certain test scores to get a better feel for an athlete.
.....
The 40-yard dash seems to steal the show as the marquee measurable and it is the most advertised score to interpret. It has its place in the final grade for an NFL prospect, but I prefer to look at a combination of three measurables to get a sense of a prospect's ability to win in the 'combat' of football. I take the vertical-jump score and add it to the standing broad-jump score, which is added to the number of repetitions on the bench-press test. These three scores are combined to give me a benchmark score, which gives me a good feel for a player's ability to win the mini battle he will engage in while trying to finish a play.
I have been adding these three scores for a long time now and I am always looking for athletes who can score a 70 or better. Some positions naturally score higher than others and they need to by the nature of what is required for these positions on the field. Defensive ends and linebackers will generally score higher than wide receivers or cornerbacks. And since these positions are played in space where collisions are not as frequent, it is not as important to score a 70, but nonetheless, I am intrigued by perimeter players who score well on this combination score.
This year, we have a number of players who crossed the 70 mark and we have the rare few that have crossed the 80 mark. Believe me, not many NFL draft-eligible players ever get an 80-plus score. Here's a look at the top guys in this year's draft that have the combination of strength, power, explosiveness and agility to excel. Mario Williams, the top defensive end in the draft class, is off the charts when it comes to this combo score and has one of the highest scores I have ever seen.
NAME POS. VERTICAL BROAD BENCH TOTAL
Mario Williams DE 40.5 10.0 35 85.5
Brodrick Bunkley DT 32.5 9.05 44 85.5
Vernon Davis TE 42.0 10.08 33 85.08
Jon Alston OLB 40.0 11.0 30 81.0
Ray Edwards DE 39.0 9.06 30 78.06
Haloti Ngata DT 31.5 9.02 37 77.52
Ernie Sims LB 41.0 10.05 25 76.05
Dusty Dvoracek DT 34.0 9.06 31 74.06
A.J. Hawk OLB 40.0 9.07 24 73.07
Kamerion Wimbley DE 38.5 10.09 24 72.59
Manny Lawson DE 39.5 10.04 23 72.54
Demeco Ryans OLB 39.0 10.09 23 72.09
Rodrique Wright DT 32.0 9.02 31 72.02
Michael Huff FS/CB 40.5 10.05 21 71.55
Antonio Cromartie CB 42 11.0 18 71.00
DeAngelo Williams RB 35.5 10.01 25 70.51
Just something interesting I wanted to share.