common_fan
Practice Squad
Who should have been the first overall pick that year?
Death to Google Ads! Texans Talk Tip Jar! 🍺😎👍
Thanks for your support!
Who should have been the first overall pick that year?
I would still go with carr
Are you asking who should have the pick based on what we know now or who should have been the pick at that point in time? Now it's obviously Peppers. Then...I would still say Carr should have been the pick. He was the top rated QB in the class and no one obviously thought that the 2002 draft would be as bad as it has turned out to be.
Jabbar Gaffney and Chester Pitts before Clinton Portis. I was not aware of that.
1. Houston David Carr QB Fresno State
2. Carolina Julius Peppers DE North Carolina
3. Detroit Joey Harrington QB Oregon
4. Buffalo Mike Williams OT Texas
5. San Diego Quentin Jammer CB Texas
6. Kansas City (from Dallas) Ryan Sims DT North Carolina
7. Minnesota Bryant McKinnie OT Miami (Fla)
8. Dallas (from Kansas City) Roy Williams SS Oklahoma
9. Jacksonville John Henderson DT Tennessee
10. Cincinnati Levi Jones OT Arizona State
11. Indianapolis Dwight Freeney DE Syracuse
12. Arizona Wendell Bryant DT Wisconsin
13. New Orleans Donte Stallworth WR Tennessee
14. NY Giants (from Tennessee) Jeremy Shockey TE Miami (Fla)
15. Tennessee (from NY Giants) Albert Haynesworth DT Tennessee
16. Cleveland William Green RB Boston College
17. Oakland (from Atlanta) Phillip Buchanon CB Miami (Fla)
18. Atlanta (from Washington through Oakland) T.J. Duckett RB Michigan State
19. Denver Ashley Lelie WR Hawaii
20. Green Bay (from Seattle) Javon Walker WR Florida State
21. New England (from Tampa Bay through Oakland and Washington) Daniel Graham TE Colorado
22. NY Jets Bryan Thomas DE Alabama-Birmingham
23. Oakland Napolean Harris OLB Northwestern
24. Baltimore Edward Reed S Miami (FLA)
25. New Orleans (from Miami) Charles Grant DE Georgia
26. Philadelphia Lito Sheppard CB Florida
27. San Francisco Mike Rumph CB Miami (Fla)
28. Seattle (from Green Bay) Jerramy Stevens TE Washington
29. Chicago Marc Colombo OT Boston College
30. Pittsburgh Kendall Simmons OG Auburn
31. St. Louis Robert Thomas MLB UCLA
32. Washington (from New England) Patrick Ramsey QB Tulane
Traded down for more picks.
Peppers #1 overall? Who takes DE's as an overall #1 pick!?
Who would you have picked out of this fine group of athletes?
http://football.about.com/od/nfldrafthistory/l/bl_draft2002.htm
Traded down for more picks.
Peppers #1 overall? Who takes DE's as an overall #1 pick!?
Who would you have picked out of this fine group of athletes?
http://football.about.com/od/nfldrafthistory/l/bl_draft2002.htm
David Carr
Carr for sure.
Woulda...coulda...shoulda....doesn't count!
He was the best pick for us on the board in 02. He has all the tools to be everything they drafted him for. Maybe we should have let him sit for a while and not made him the "bean-bag" of the NFL...
What a total shame!
Shame on the entire FO and
Shame on Mr. McNair for letting it happen.
Peppers.
Carr should have gone somehwere around 15-20, and Harrington should have been a 3rd or 4th rounder...
Carr for sure.
Woulda...coulda...shoulda....doesn't count!
He was the best pick for us on the board in 02. He has all the tools to be everything they drafted him for. Maybe we should have let him sit for a while and not made him the "bean-bag" of the NFL...
What a total shame!
Shame on the entire FO and
Shame on Mr. McNair for letting it happen.
I second that!!
OK.........NO.............NO Dr. Phil avatars...........Yes I am the avatar police. Dr. Phil is the gateway avatar to Opra. We as responsible Texan fans and we cannot.........neh...........will not let that happen.
Boselli was a "busted pick", they gave him entirely too much money and time. But it seems to me that the FO has a way of bringing in "patch-work" players that need some rehab of some sort. BUT HEY, when and IF they ever play they are gonna be PRO BOWL material!! GEEEEEEE
Who stomped on your toes? I think he's kinda funny myself. Am I missing something? Have you had a bad experience with a shrink and the sight of one sends you running? IT"S A JOKE! Settle down.
I second that!!
Who should have been the first overall pick that year?
Traded down for more picks.
Peppers #1 overall? Who takes DE's as an overall #1 pick!?
Who would you have picked out of this fine group of athletes?
http://football.about.com/od/nfldrafthistory/l/bl_draft2002.htm
This list includes DEs and DTs, but you will see the point in that, the last 25 years, a D-lineman has been selected about 36% of the time... (Granted many/ most on this list were busts, but a couple went on to have good careers)
Year Round Pick Player Position Team
1982 1 1 Ken Sims DE New England
1985 1 1 Bruce Smith DE Buffalo
1986 1 1 Tony Casillas DT Atlanta
1988 1 1 Aundrey Bruce DT Atlanta
1991 1 1 Russell Maryland NT Dallas
1992 1 1 Steve Emtman DT Indianapolis
1994 1 1 Dan Wilkerson DT Cincinnati
2000 1 1 Courtney Brown DE Cleveland
2006 1 1 Mario Williams DE Houston
Out of all those, only Bruce was worth the pick. Hopefully mario will be the second.
Julius Peppers.
We could have sucked that year and picked up Carson Palmer in the 2003 draft.
I understand Hulk's undying love for David...
But I mean....what are your reasons ?
That's true whether he deserved it or was nothing but the product of a hype machine. That's immaterial in the long run because NFL teams almost always fall for the hype machine.
You know, guys can talk all day long about how David Carr was the top rated QB and about how he supposedly has all of the physical tools you look for and that may even be true. What it doesn't change however is that under no circumstances should he have been the first pick of the 2002 draft.
It was a terrible mistake at the time and it looks more idiotic every year that passes by.
The reason David Carr had no business being the first overall pick that year is simple. The first overall pick was held by an expansion team and I don't care who you got in the expansion draft or signed in free agency no expansion team should even be allowed to select a QB first overall in it's first year of existence. There should be a rule against it. Hell, there should be a law against it.
Expansion teams that lead off with QB's invariably destroy those QB's long before anyone ever gets a chance to see whether or not those QB's can actually play.
The Texans obviously should have obviously taken Julius Peppers with the first overall pick. In any other year when an expansion team wasn't picking first Carr would have been the top choice. That's true whether he deserved it or was nothing but the product of a hype machine. That's immaterial in the long run because NFL teams almost always fall for the hype machine.