I don't agree with most of the comparisons made in this thread.
However, I find it funny that even though Carr is probably the brightest spot on this offense right now, some people are still nitpicking a play here or a play there. I know Carr has played for four seasons now, but he is a new quarterback in Kubiak's offense.
Daunte Culpepper does not need an introduction in any football setting, but he is having a rough year as a quarterback playing a new offense.
I think when some people form an opinion based upon one set of circumstances (Carr's play under the Capers regime), it then becomes hard for them not to focus on the bad. I'm not going to point any fingers, but some of you people need to open your eyes a little bit. Even Peyton Manning has a 5 int game every once in a while. None of these NFL QBs are all that every week.
You can scream "David Carr sucks" or "spice it up with Sage" at the top of your lungs all you want. It simply isn't going to happen. Even though Carr's QB rating took a hit this week, I thought he looked even better:
He is reading defenses.
He is making adjustments based on his reads. eg. moving receivers and TE's based on his reads
He is going through progressions.
He is hanging in the pocket to give his receivers time to get open.
He is making accurate throws downfield when he knows he's about to get drilled.
He keeps getting up after being sacked and hit more than any other quarterback these last 4 plus years.
So, complain while your glass is half empty. My glass is 3/4 full.