Death to Google Ads! Texans Talk Tip Jar! 🍺😎👍
Thanks for your support!

Is It time to fire David Culley after 1 year?

Status
Not open for further replies.
You are taking my posts way too seriously and I don't really need a recap from you or the order of events. You will not find any of my posts endorsing what Watson did or advocating that he should be involved with the GM search. So, I don't get the point of your posts or what you think I'm forgetting.

Since the TT narrative is they had to hire a minority HC to appease Watson. I was simply posting on what endorsers of Leslie Frazier or Jim Caldwell becoming HC could say about the new HC versus what Culley's endorsers could say about his accomplishments or qualifications. But feel free to continue......

And you are assuming the opinion of one person is the opinion of the entire forum. If it wasn't meant to be taken seriously then that's fine but tone doesn't carry over text so unless I see an emote or its something that is clearly a joke or sarcasm I take it seriously.
 
As I was mowing leaves today I thought of a grand conspiracy, do you remember how prepared the team looked and played in their opener. Then Caserio went to Culley and said you are blowing my tank, coach worse! Well, probably did not happen, but 3% chance it could of!
 
That Mahomes guy that many on here wanted turned out to be pretty good.
.
Envy, LMAO can't get around the fact that RS traded for your guy and he turned out to be a perv. The fact that I didn't like the pick at the time doesn't make me envious. I like watching a trainwreck from time to time.
The stretch Mahomes just went through, you were mighty quiet. I like Mahomes, Andy Reid moved up higher to get his guy. Andy Reid is regarded as an offensive genius. Look at all the qbs who had career years. Hell, Smith best years was under Andy Reid. Your envy for Watson is and always have been front and center. Nobody, you included had no idea he was having those problems. Mahomes wouldn't have fixed the terrible play calling and design by O'Brien. We saw what happened in the superbowl when Mahomes was under constant pressure too. Guess what, Watson played under that same pressure almost every game.
 
Many on here didn't want JJ Watt. So, what anonymous internet posters want doesn't matter and makes that point irrelevant. Posters always remember the players they want who became successful, but never remember the ones who were unsuccessful or the ones that they didn't want who became successful. I call it the Nate Peterman principle.

As mentioned previously. Pairing Mahomes with the BOB ED offense is not the guaranteed success or the panacea for all the problems with this offense. Mahomes has admitted he didn't really start reading defenses until his 3rd year. Would that fly in BOB's complicated scheme where the QB has to make the protection calls? Would BOB be willing to integrate many Air Raid concepts into his offense and terminology like Reid did for Mahomes? Would Mahomes have the luxury of sitting behind a veteran his rookie year? Is the surrounding cast Mahomes have in KC similar to what he would have with the Texans? There are many variables to consider before assuming Mahomes would be Mahomes in BOB's offense.

During practices his rookie season, Mahomes was throwing INTs all over the place. Many KC players were questioning the draft pick who had a reputation as a turnover prone gunslinger. I recall you mentioning Nate Peterman looked better than Watson in their preseason games. Would you have said Peterman looks better than Mahomes too?
We got receipts on his Peterman love fest. Mahomes also got to work with a guy who turned Kevin Kolb into a tradeable qb that brought back a 1st rd pick.
 
Considering they currently have the number 2 overall as well yeah I'd say they still view us as a threat. Seriously if you think we could have gotten Minshew for what Philly did then frankly I question how much attention you actually pay to drafts and trades.
They had the #1 overall draft pick, he wanted out. Wasn't Caserio around when they traded Drew Bledsoe in the division? They weren't viewing Minshew as someone they would regret trading in the division . They traded him for a conditional 6th rd pick. You dont think just a regular 6th would have done the trick? Late round picks for players are throw away picks. I mean they traded Ingram for a 2023 7th rd pick. If the Titans called after Henry went down, what now the Texans want a 3rd because its interdivision?
 
It's always about Nick, Nick, Nick. I want my thread back!

culley-1.jpg
 
Look at who all of the candidates were. That tells you all you need to know. This was a mandate from ownership before Caserio was even hired.

Wrong, I grew up playing with my best friend on a farm. My best friend who I'm still close with today happens to be an African American. Love him to death.

I also played basketball ball on Sunday afternoon with 50 African Americans and I was the only white guy there sometimes. Many of these people are still friends of mine.

This has served me well throughout the years. As with my profession, I mainly serve African American customers. Serving the nursing home and Section 8 housing communities. I've made many friends throughout the yrs in these situations. They've helped my family have a better life and I'm truly grateful to them.

Frankly I'm offended that I have to put down in a post my qualifications for the I only know a couple of African Americans. It's sickening.

I've got to get back to work and will answer your Mahomes post later.

Have a great day.
If you grew up around black people and know black people, then you should know the last thing black people want are token hires. Caserio and Esterby could've sold the Texans fans on anyone but Culley. All the minorities and non minority coaches were known for something good on a particular side of the ball. Culley wasn't known for anything aside from being a good person. Hell, Lovie, Caldwell, Frazier all fit that bill amongst the black dudes. They could've sold the fans on any of those interviewed except the guy they hired no matter his ethnicity. If Watson was pushing for a minority, which I doubt, the last guy he would push for is Culley. When you know black people and have regular conversations with black people, you would know the hiring of Culley is the worse for any kind of advancement.
 
The stretch Mahomes just went through, you were mighty quiet. I like Mahomes, Andy Reid moved up higher to get his guy. Andy Reid is regarded as an offensive genius. Look at all the qbs who had career years. Hell, Smith best years was under Andy Reid. Your envy for Watson is and always have been front and center. Nobody, you included had no idea he was having those problems. Mahomes wouldn't have fixed the terrible play calling and design by O'Brien. We saw what happened in the superbowl when Mahomes was under constant pressure too. Guess what, Watson played under that same pressure almost every game.
I haven't mentioned Mahomes because the subject hasn't been brought up. But speaking of Mahomes the league has somewhat caught up to him. He's having to take the short throws and methodically move his team down the field. He's not putting up the numbers he was before. But he's got his team on a current 6 game win streak because he adjusted his game. This is what I hoped Derrick would learn to do. You're correct he looked like a guy should look when both of his starting OT's were missing. With that said, it that great pass had been caught insteadof dropped in the endzone. That game could've been a totally different story. In short he gave his team a chance to win.

I think the Chiefs are odds on favorites to represent the AFC in the SB.




IMO, this right there is the problem. Cal having to ask prior NFL coaches/people who he should hire. This clown has ZERO idea what he is doing. Reminds me of a quote his ol man said back in the day, "The inmates are running the asylum." Or something like that.

I think asking people who've done it before what they would do in Cal's situation is a very smart thing to do. Going with his gut was sage advice. IMHO
 
If you grew up around black people and know black people, then you should know the last thing black people want are token hires. Caserio and Esterby could've sold the Texans fans on anyone but Culley. All the minorities and non minority coaches were known for something good on a particular side of the ball. Culley wasn't known for anything aside from being a good person. Hell, Lovie, Caldwell, Frazier all fit that bill amongst the black dudes. They could've sold the fans on any of those interviewed except the guy they hired no matter his ethnicity. If Watson was pushing for a minority, which I doubt, the last guy he would push for is Culley. When you know black people and have regular conversations with black people, you would know the hiring of Culley is the worse for any kind of advancement.

I totally agree with you.

But not all people think like we do or are in agreement with us. However this looks to me like this situation.

Cal- because of the Derrick situation, lets hire a minority so people cant call us racist.

Caserio- which minority will be the easiest to fire after we suck for a couple of yrs? Cal- lets hire the 65 yr old positive vibe guy Culley. Caserio- Good choice.

Sad thing is Culley never had a chance to succeed.
 
I totally agree with you.

But not all people think like we do or are in agreement with us. However this looks to me like this situation.

Cal- because of the Derrick situation, lets hire a minority so people cant call us racist.

Caserio- which minority will be the easiest to fire after we suck for a couple of yrs? Cal- lets hire the 65 yr old positive vibe guy Culley. Caserio- Good choice.

Sad thing is Culley never had a chance to succeed.
Ok, now we're on the same page and thats why the fans have checked out and will continue to be checked out. I mean Khan sensed the dysfunctional state with his franchise qb and canned the coach. Watson spoke of the same without saying his name. Andre Johnson who never tweets or says anything called out Esterby. It was an easy out for Cal and he let it pass. Had he fired everyone and hired Caserio, this franchise wouldn't have this cloud over it. Back to Culley, the most disappointing thing about him is his indecisive nature. We all know it takes time to adjust in the NFL, but where is his stamp? He's been around Reid for a number of years and you dont have any kind of input in the offense? Supposedly they kept Kelly for Watson. Ok, Watson ain't playing, so why allow him to keep being a counter puncher who doesn't make any adjustments? Giants fired Garrett, Lions to the play calling duties away their oc, what has the Texans done with the 2nd lowest scoring team in the NFL? A team that hasn't scored a td in the 2nd half in 3 games? Absolutely nothing.
 
Man you can’t go off of what Watson said. His darn credibility was shot up when he endorsed Bill O’Brien. Bill O’Brien messed all over this freak team. It was said dude wanted out a long time ago, but Watson wanted him to stay. Why, because I have a feeling O’Brien knew exactly what Watson was doing. ( disclaimer: speculation) .

All these jokers played a larger role in the crazy crap that’s going on with the Texans.

Watson knew he was messing up out there. He’s just in his feelings because he got caught up.
 
Ok, now we're on the same page and thats why the fans have checked out and will continue to be checked out. I mean Khan sensed the dysfunctional state with his franchise qb and canned the coach. Watson spoke of the same without saying his name. Andre Johnson who never tweets or says anything called out Esterby. It was an easy out for Cal and he let it pass. Had he fired everyone and hired Caserio, this franchise wouldn't have this cloud over it. Back to Culley, the most disappointing thing about him is his indecisive nature. We all know it takes time to adjust in the NFL, but where is his stamp? He's been around Reid for a number of years and you dont have any kind of input in the offense? Supposedly they kept Kelly for Watson. Ok, Watson ain't playing, so why allow him to keep being a counter puncher who doesn't make any adjustments? Giants fired Garrett, Lions to the play calling duties away their oc, what has the Texans done with the 2nd lowest scoring team in the NFL? A team that hasn't scored a td in the 2nd half in 3 games? Absolutely nothing.

Kelly was kept to be the scapegoat at season’s end. He will be fired on black Monday, Culley stays on because he’s the perfect guy for what team EasterNick wants right now. A guy to take the heat, and do and say what they tell him.

What EVP of Football Operations is on the sidelines, not in a suit and tie, during games? What GM is on the headset during games? Culley is a puppet and he will continue to be a puppet until this team needs a real HC. And even then team EasterNick will be pushing all the buttons. What legit HC candidate is going to want that and pretty much be powerless?

I fear we may be in for a long winters nap, aka, bad football, for a very long time.
 
Kelly was kept to be the scapegoat at season’s end. He will be fired on black Monday, Culley stays on because he’s the perfect guy for what team EasterNick wants right now. A guy to take the heat, and do and say what they tell him.

What EVP of Football Operations is on the sidelines, not in a suit and tie, during games? What GM is on the headset during games? Culley is a puppet and he will continue to be a puppet until this team needs a real HC. And even then team EasterNick will be pushing all the buttons. What legit HC candidate is going to want that and pretty much be powerless?

I fear we may be in for a long winters nap, aka, bad football, for a very long time.
I've seen this game before. The pressure is going to come from those home-away crowds. One thing about the NFL, once you get that rep as a bad franchise and in the south where its 80 degrees in December, those empty stadiuns speaks volumes. Culley is the ultimate puppet. Did you hear him comment about Zach not being vaccinated? I haven't heard 1 coach speak about a players vaccination status except Culley and the Texans organization. Its like they're trying to portray him as a malcontent.
 
Sad thing is Culley never had a chance to succeed.

The Bucs could have their current roster and Culley as head coach would figure out a way they end up with a losing record.

There are reasons why Culley has never ever been even considered for an NFL HC job, and it's not because of his race.

Kelly was kept to be the scapegoat at season’s end. He will be fired on black Monday, Culley stays on because he’s the perfect guy for what team EasterNick wants right now. A guy to take the heat, and do and say what they tell him.

What EVP of Football Operations is on the sidelines, not in a suit and tie, during games? What GM is on the headset during games? Culley is a puppet and he will continue to be a puppet until this team needs a real HC. And even then team EasterNick will be pushing all the buttons. What legit HC candidate is going to want that and pretty much be powerless?

I fear we may be in for a long winters nap, aka, bad football, for a very long time.

This is the inherent rub with fans. Nobody expected anything from a Culley team. While most of us understood this season would be a losing one, it seems ludicrous to expect fans to sit through multiple "mulligan" seasons with a "placeholder" HC until they conditions are juuuuuust right to start a rebuild.

Is Caserio a Goldilocks GM? Everything has to be just right before he finds a competent HC that actually has a long-term vision that can be built upon?

Hire the HC of the future and start building NOW. HC puts his coordinators and schemes in place and starts to find talent to teach and mold to play those schemes. At least this is the way most successful teams run their businesses.

Right now the Texans have no long-term plans. How are they even evaluating players if they have no idea of the schemes they will run under the "real" HC??? Or is the next HC going to have his coordinators chosen for him and shoved down his throat, too? That's how the Texans have being doing business, so why change? It's bush league.

Are they going to draft guys in 2022 and waste a year or two of their careers while Culley treads water and Easterby infects them with his culture BS?

The entire thing right now is a complete waste of time, and the majority of Texans fans agree with us judging by attendance and general disgust with this franchise.
 
The Bucs could have their current roster and Culley as head coach would figure out a way they end up with a losing record.
Does he have leftwich or kelly? If Leftwich I think he’d have a winning season.
There are reasons why Culley has never ever been even considered for an NFL HC job, and it's not because of his race.

there have been a ton of HCs selected for those same reasons Culley was over looked that have failed. Culley made an impression on Caserio that he remembered over many, many years. He chose Culley so… we’ll see. I have yet to see anything that has convinced me Culley can not be a good HC.


Nobody expected anything from a Culley team.

I hoped the Texans would be competitive against bad teams. We’ve had 5 games against teams that are currently below.500. I remove Seattle from the list since they were bad because Wilson missed time. So we’re 2-2 against sub .500 teams this year.

However, I don’t think the team looked competitive at all against the Panthers or the Jets. I wasn’t expecting a rookie to start 7 games. & we did beat one team above.500 at this time, so it’s a bit of a mixed bag.


Are they going to draft guys in 2022 and waste a year or two of their careers while Culley treads water and Easterby infects them with his culture BS?

I think when you start with the assumption Culley is a placeholder it leads to one poor conclusion after another.

How do you feel about the Chargers now? I don’t think Lynn was a placeholder hire. Someone for whatever reason thought he would be a good HC. Didn’t work out. Yet they accumulated talent during his tenure, canned him, brought in a completely new staff that found a way to put that talent to good use.

Problem is we can see what the Chargers have done & we can only speculate where the Texans are heading. So there’s going to be some anxiety.

personally I don’t think any of these owners know what they are doing, or how to win, except maybe the Rooneys. Everybody else is running on blind luck. Sometimes things work out for them, sometimes they don’t.

Regardless what team we follow we’re basically hoping they fall into a good situation
 
there have been a ton of HCs selected for those same reasons Culley was over looked that have failed. Culley made an impression on Caserio that he remembered over many, many years. He chose Culley so… we’ll see.

If that helps you sleep at night.

I have yet to see anything that has convinced me Culley can not be a good HC.

Seriously? You’re not even trying to see if that’s the case.
 
Correct, I'm letting it play out & judging him on what he does, not on what I think he won't do.
We're talking about the guy who declined a penalty to punt instead of playing 3rd down over, right? Yeah, I'm judging him on what he's does too. And it hasn't been good. I guess when the Texans are so bad that fans sleep through their games, people won't see stuff.
 
We're talking about the guy who declined a penalty to punt instead of playing 3rd down over, right? Yeah, I'm judging him on what he's does too. And it hasn't been good. I guess when the Texans are so bad that fans sleep through their games, people won't see stuff.

Definitely a mark against him.
 
There's plenty more where that came from, but to quote your own own words, "Dude, I'm not going over this again."
There's enough, imo, to say he does indeed have areas he needs to improve on. Par for the course for new HCs imo.
 
The Bucs could have their current roster and Culley as head coach would figure out a way they end up with a losing record.

There are reasons why Culley has never ever been even considered for an NFL HC job, and it's not because of his race.



This is the inherent rub with fans. Nobody expected anything from a Culley team. While most of us understood this season would be a losing one, it seems ludicrous to expect fans to sit through multiple "mulligan" seasons with a "placeholder" HC until they conditions are juuuuuust right to start a rebuild.

Is Caserio a Goldilocks GM? Everything has to be just right before he finds a competent HC that actually has a long-term vision that can be built upon?

Hire the HC of the future and start building NOW. HC puts his coordinators and schemes in place and starts to find talent to teach and mold to play those schemes. At least this is the way most successful teams run their businesses.

Right now the Texans have no long-term plans. How are they even evaluating players if they have no idea of the schemes they will run under the "real" HC??? Or is the next HC going to have his coordinators chosen for him and shoved down his throat, too? That's how the Texans have being doing business, so why change? It's bush league.

Are they going to draft guys in 2022 and waste a year or two of their careers while Culley treads water and Easterby infects them with his culture BS?

The entire thing right now is a complete waste of time, and the majority of Texans fans agree with us judging by attendance and general disgust with this franchise.

Agreed on this post.

Just telling you rebuilds done right take time.

Hate you feel this way, but I totally get it.
 
My main issue with Culley is that he has an offensive background and I have no idea what his offense is supposed to look like.

Same issue with OB.

I think Lovie is doing a solid job as DC and that’s not because they are a dominant unit. It’s because I can tell what his defense is supposed to look like and he is making the most of the limited talent he is given.

Regardless of talent level you should know what the identity of the unit is supposed to be and recognize that with more talented players the performance will improve.
 
My main issue with Culley is that he has an offensive background and I have no idea what his offense is supposed to look like.

Same issue with OB.

I think Lovie is doing a solid job as DC and that’s not because they are a dominant unit. It’s because I can tell what his defense is supposed to look like and he is making the most of the limited talent he is given.

Regardless of talent level you should know what the identity of the unit is supposed to be and recognize that with more talented players the performance will improve.

If Culley is letting his coordinators do their jobs, which I have no issue with, then it’s still the OB offense, which is why there’s still no identity.

Kelly should have been shown the door like everyone else, but Culley had no say in that, like I believe he has no say in just about everything.

Kelly will see that door come black Monday, because that’s who the scapegoat is, and we’ll have Culley around at least another year while we see if the rebuild starts to take shape.
 
...Is Caserio a Goldilocks GM? Everything has to be just right before he finds a competent HC that actually has a long-term vision that can be built upon?

Hire the HC of the future and start building NOW. HC puts his coordinators and schemes in place and starts to find talent to teach and mold to play those schemes. At least this is the way most successful teams run their businesses.

Right now the Texans have no long-term plans. How are they even evaluating players if they have no idea of the schemes they will run under the "real" HC??? Or is the next HC going to have his coordinators chosen for him and shoved down his throat, too? That's how the Texans have being doing business, so why change? It's bush league.

Are they going to draft guys in 2022 and waste a year or two of their careers while Culley treads water and Easterby infects them with his culture BS?

The entire thing right now is a complete waste of time, and the majority of Texans fans agree with us judging by attendance and general disgust with this franchise.
It's possible that Caserio has a good idea who he would like as HC, but that person is not currently available.

It's also possible for Caserio to have a plan as to the type of scheme he'd like to build around, one that would fit the future HC. This could be for offense, or defense, or both.

Why is this unreasonable to believe. Put yourself in a fantasy world where you are an NFL GM. Wouldn't you want to build your coaching staff and team around your ideas and plans? This is what I think Caserio is doing. Why do you think Caserio has no long term plan or vision? To think this is totally unreasonable.
 
My main issue with Culley is that he has an offensive background and I have no idea what his offense is supposed to look like...
I think it is very clear that he wants to emphasize a strong running game interspersed with a short to intermediate passing game. At least, from his comments, I can envision what it is what he wants to do.

The problem is, he lacks the players who can run his offense. Caserio has only had one, abbreviated, draft to start the rebuild. This past draft he drafted a QB and a WR. And a TE. I think we will see OL'men taken in this next draft; and probably a RB. As Steelb says, it takes time.
 
There are to many variables concerning the NFL, NFL players and coaches to make any kind of reliable statements about any team's future. Right now the Texans are a mess, and they'll still be a mess in 2022. They (hopefully) should be less of a mess next year, but progress is seen in games won so we have a long time to wait and see. I don't think it's fair right now to judge either Caserio or Culley, but after after spring trading season and the draft, we should have a much better idea.

I'm actually more interested in this weekends game than I have been for a while. If the Texans continue to struggle against another very poor team like themselves, or one of the two teams routs the other should be an interesting thing to see. Hopefully it's the Texans that do the routing.
 
There’s first time coaches who make mistakes, then there’s guys in over their heads. There is a difference.
Urban Myer & Brandon Staley. I get it. I just feel Culley is closer to Staley than Urban. You disagree. It’s ok.
 
My main issue with Culley is that he has an offensive background and I have no idea what his offense is supposed to look like.
The decision was made before Culley got here to appease Watson, so they rolled with Kelly. Hopefully next season they’ll can that line of thinking & we’ll see what Culley wants from his offense
 
The decision was made before Culley got here to appease Watson, so they rolled with Kelly. Hopefully next season they’ll can that line of thinking & we’ll see what Culley wants from his offense

Hope so. But even still… what Kelly is doing clearly isn’t working. We saw Joe Brady get fired who was much more highly regarded than Kelly.

Why can’t Kelly at least be stripped of playcalling duties? They have a veteran play caller in Pep Hamilton, let him have a shot and maybe he’ll run whatever it is Culley is envisioning. The lack of in-season adjustment is disappointing. Lots of personnel turnover, particularly shuffling around OL. But there is clearly a need for adjustment in the coaching ranks so lets see it.
 
Hope so. But even still… what Kelly is doing clearly isn’t working. We saw Joe Brady get fired who was much more highly regarded than Kelly.

Why can’t Kelly at least be stripped of playcalling duties? They have a veteran play caller in Pep Hamilton, let him have a shot and maybe he’ll run whatever it is Culley is envisioning. The lack of in-season adjustment is disappointing. Lots of personnel turnover, particularly shuffling around OL. But there is clearly a need for adjustment in the coaching ranks so lets see it.
Agree on all parts.

If it were me, I’d have fired him four games in… poetic, eh?

I’m hoping they are not in some way impressed with Kelly & feel like they are “developing” him. But the longer he sticks around the more I feel that’s the case. Meaning we’ll probably see Tim Kelly here next season as our OC.

I hope they’re not grooming him to be our next HC.
 
The decision was made before Culley got here to appease Watson, so they rolled with Kelly. Hopefully next season they’ll can that line of thinking & we’ll see what Culley wants from his offense

Just another example of how Derrick's still screwing over this franchise.

I truly hope Cal is seeing the results of his bad decision making.
 
It's possible that Caserio has a good idea who he would like as HC, but that person is not currently available.

It's also possible for Caserio to have a plan as to the type of scheme he'd like to build around, one that would fit the future HC. This could be for offense, or defense, or both.

Why is this unreasonable to believe. Put yourself in a fantasy world where you are an NFL GM. Wouldn't you want to build your coaching staff and team around your ideas and plans? This is what I think Caserio is doing. Why do you think Caserio has no long term plan or vision? To think this is totally unreasonable.
Is this the role of the GM? I can understand a GM wanting to run a WCO or EP scheme and then hiring a HC who runs a WCO or EP scheme. However, after the hire, isn't it the HC that determines his staff and how he wants to implement his plan and schemes? Shouldn't the GM be more concerned about drafting and signing personnel to match the HC plans and ideas?

I don't recall any HC who has had any success allowing a GM to have that type of power over him. It's not the GM's coaching staff. The GM and HC are partners with distinct roles and responsibilities. People not staying in their lanes is what has gotten the Texans in this mess.
 
Is this the role of the GM? I can understand a GM wanting to run a WCO or EP scheme and then hiring a HC who runs a WCO or EP scheme. However, after the hire, isn't it the HC that determines his staff and how he wants to implement his plan and schemes? Shouldn't the GM be more concerned about drafting and signing personnel to match the HC plans and ideas?

I don't recall any HC who has had any success allowing a GM to have that type of power over him. It's not the GM's coaching staff. The GM and HC are partners with distinct roles and responsibilities. People not staying in their lanes is what has gotten the Texans in this mess.
So you're saying Culley has the sole responsibility for making the decision to keep or replace Tim Kelly?
 
Is this the role of the GM? I can understand a GM wanting to run a WCO or EP scheme and then hiring a HC who runs a WCO or EP scheme. However, after the hire, isn't it the HC that determines his staff and how he wants to implement his plan and schemes? Shouldn't the GM be more concerned about drafting and signing personnel to match the HC plans and ideas?

I don't recall any HC who has had any success allowing a GM to have that type of power over him. It's not the GM's coaching staff. The GM and HC are partners with distinct roles and responsibilities. People not staying in their lanes is what has gotten the Texans in this mess.

Hopefully the GM hires a HC that shares his offensive/defensive philosophies. If not, then there's your problem.
 
Hopefully the GM hires a HC that shares his offensive/defensive philosophies. If not, then there's your problem.
Agree. Then that GM has to find the personnel to match those offensive/defensive philosophies. However, when it comes to the coaching staff, the HC might have to discuss budget or the salaries of his hires, but it's the HC responsibility for who he hires and fires from his coaching staff.
 
So you're saying Culley has the sole responsibility for making the decision to keep or replace Tim Kelly?
Caserio can make the recommendation. However, Culley should have final say to keep or replace Tim Kelly. Most HCs have that in writing before accepting a job. Do they have control over their coaching staff? Do they have control of the game day roster?

Do you think Jerry Jones would tell Jimmy Johnson who to keep or replace on his coaching staff? How about Rick Smith telling O'Brien to fire Devlin? Why should it be different for Culley? In fact, Titans fired Mike Munchak because he was too loyal to his staff and refused to make changes.

Fired Mike Munchak balked at changes with Tennessee Titans (espn.com)

Mike Munchak: Firing assistants wasn't right move (nfl.com)
 
Last edited:
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top