Answering questions in the absolute is a bit unwise. Especially with no situation information.
But that's all some folks understand to I'll say "yes". I probably would have.
Why go against my "rule", you ask?
Well, the 2005 draft was light on quality QBs so if I wanted one, Rodgers was one of the top prospects even as a junior. I mean my other choices, in 2005, were Alex Smith, Kyle Orton, Jason Campbell, Dan Orlovsky, and others whose names I don't even recognize. So, yes, I most likely would have chosen Rodgers over those other guys.
It's not fair to make the choice - or ask the question - based on what I know ten years down the road.