Heres how I feel:
Tebow throws an ugly pass. Even his passes that are right on target wobble all over the place.
Tebow deserves the "W" for that game. He was money, and he put the Broncos in the position to win. Their running game was average. That win is on Tebow.
The Broncos defense is ok, but with a basically immobile Big Ben back there and no Mendenhall, I was surprised they gave up as many points as they did. Again, its on Tebow.
Tebow wants to be recognized as very religious. There are plenty of athletes of equal faith who never were recognized as in your face Christians. The commercials, the press conferences, the personal decorations, etc. Its his thing. And its working, because he's famous now.
I don't see how these things conflict. Its possible for him to be over the top about his religion AND be a poor throwing QB AND get all the credit for having a phenomenal game. The Broncos defense is good, but Tebow won that game. I may not like what I believe to be attention-seeking behavior, but as a football player, I enjoyed watching him yesterday