The Tennessee Titans lost out on the great AFC South quarterback run of 2023, leaving them Thursday evening as the lone team in the division without a young signal caller for the team, franchise and fans to rally around in the years ahead.
They lost out, and they lost. Got outmaneuvered. Had to change plans.
It happens all the time on draft night. It doesn’t mean the Titans will necessarily end up worse for it — we have no idea how any of this will work out, which makes Thursday’s “L” less severe than last year’s on the same night, when GM Jon Robinson traded A.J. Brown to the Eagles and started the clock on becoming former GM Jon Robinson. That was an obvious and devastating mistake.
This was a miss in the moment, pointing the way to a 2023 season in which the Titans will have the band back together and see if they can rally back toward a division title, and see if they’ll belong on the field with the AFC’s best. New GM Ran Carthon started the clock on his tenure by drafting Northwestern offensive lineman Peter Skoronski with the No. 11 pick.
[…]
In the meantime, they’ll have to contend with a division full of hope at the most important position. And with the division rival who got their guy.
Ohio State’s C.J. Stroud, the Titans’ reported quarterback of choice in the frenzied lead-up to Thursday’s events, went No. 2 to the Houston Texans — that must have been especially frustrating in the draft room for Titans controlling owner and Houston native Amy Adams Strunk. Florida’s Anthony Richardson went No. 4 to the Indianapolis Colts. Trevor Lawrence just led the Jacksonville Jaguars to the 2022 AFC South title, at the expense of the Titans, with an improbable late-season takeover.
Lawrence is very good already. Stroud, like No. 1 pick Bryce Young, appears to have a high floor. Richardson, who needs tons of work to be an effective starter, appears to have the highest ceiling of the quarterbacks in this draft — of quarterbacks in recent memory.
It’s also easy to see a scenario in which Stroud is good but not great. At No. 2, you need great. It’s easy to see a scenario in which Richardson can’t put everything together and ends up a major mistake at No. 4. I have no idea. Nor do you. Young is the only quarterback in this draft who I’m bullish on becoming great. Right around as bullish as I was about Ryan Leaf in 1998.
But the Titans appeared to want Stroud, and someone was willing to make that known as of Thursday morning. ESPN’s Diana Russini, NFL Network’s Ian Rapoport and Pro Football Talk’s Mike Florio were among the NFL reporters who connected the two in midday reports. Yes, the misinformation around draft day is thick, but this was a flood of reports. Backed up by action.
Russini said last week on “Get Up” that she would be with the Colts on draft night, giving extra coverage of their activities for ESPN, but something changed that plan. Her Thursday submissions from Nashville, hinting at a big move up, told the story.
The Titans were going to be one of the big players in this draft. They were going to lay out the path to their own future. Then the Texans made it their own path.
Houston, which according to reports had discussed getting a quarterback by using pick No. 12 to move up, instead used pick No. 2 to take Stroud. The Titans’ opportunity to move up and get pick No. 3 from new Arizona Cardinals GM Monti Ossenfort — who most recently worked in the Titans’ front office — was foiled.
The Texans then gave Ossenfort a haul to take the No. 3 pick that the Titans no longer had use for, and they drafted Alabama outside linebacker Will Anderson. Houston left the night with hopeful stars on both sides of the ball. Maybe Houston was going Stroud at No. 2 all along. Maybe not. Maybe the Titans inadvertently convinced the Texans to change course.
Either way, Stroud’s future becomes a critical story for two AFC South franchises, not just one.
Yahoo Sports reporter Charles Robinson tweeted of the Texans’ moves: “Why is this legendary? Because the #Texans eliminated their competition for the #Cardinals pick by selecting the QB at 2 that the #Titans wanted to trade up for. That left the Texans as the lone trade partner for 3. Ninja move.”
Russini tweeted after the Texans took Stroud: “The Houston Texans just made a wild move. The Titans were fighting to get to 3 but once Houston picked C.J. Stroud at 2, the Titans pulled their offer with Arizona.”
Russini later deleted that tweet. Carthon and Vrabel, of course, had no interest in talking about quarterbacks they might have wanted and planned to take. They were on to Skoronski. Like it or not, the band will be getting back together in 2023. The rest of this weekend is about making it sound like something better than a tribute band.