Should we compare Reggie to Faulk??

[kastofsna]

How was the Big 12 overrated? and which conference wasn't overrated then?

because both are very top-heavy conferences. they don't have the depth like the ACC, SEC, big 10.

 

[ToroFan]

because both are very top-heavy conferences. they don't have the depth like the ACC, SEC, big 10.

How were those other conferences head and shoulders above the Big 12 in terms of depth? The Big 12 had 8 out of its 12 teams in a bowl game, and finished with a 5-3 mark?

Bowl Records
SEC - 3-3
Big X - 3-4
ACC - 5-3

Although A&M, Baylor, Ok State, and Kansas State were down this year, they aren't worse than the bottom teams of the other conferences you mentioned ACC (Duke, UNC, Wake Forest), Big X (Illinois, Indiana, Michigan State, Purdue), or SEC (Kentucky, Ole Miss, Miss St, Arkansas)

So what's the basis for the depth argument?