Wish to make a one time donation? Make it here.

Disappointing that the roof will never open...

BattleBull

Practice Squad
as long as Bill O’Brien is coach. Sunday night would have been another perfect to open it up yet they chose to keep it closed due to “crowd noise.” Yet Seattle and KC, the two loudest stadiums have no roof. It defies logic.

(since were playing well I have to complain about something)
 

austins23

Hall of Fame
Maybe for night games but I’ll vote “nay” for any day game, don’t care what the temp is outside.
It’s hot AF in the north side of stadium.

Heck, I was in KC for that game, 52 degrees at kick off, beautiful day out, sunshine no clouds, but 52 degrees. It was HOT AF in that stadium and that stadium is wide open.

NRG isn’t wide open and the last game I remember the roof being open, it was low 70s out, beautiful day. Just flat out miserable on the north side of stadium. My ol lady had to watch from the concourse it was so bad.
 

Uncle Rico

Ur apology should be as loud as Ur disrespect was
LMAO at "crowd noise" .. seems to me even with a winning product the crowds aren't what they used to be. Prices keep going up. The Tailgate isnt as wild. For me the best seat in the house is in front of my 75" LED with a death grip on my remote control. Wait I did like the Chairmans Club seats with the free food and drinks and the pregame stuff they would do in the bubble, that was pretty sweet. Been .. 5 years now since my last live game. Dont miss them.
 

TexansBull

Hall of Fame
as long as Bill O’Brien is coach. Sunday night would have been another perfect to open it up yet they chose to keep it closed due to “crowd noise.” Yet Seattle and KC, the two loudest stadiums have no roof. It defies logic.

(since were playing well I have to complain about something)
Wasn’t it like this with Kubiak too?

I disagree with open roofs. I don’t go for the ambiance of a starry night. I go to watch a game.

That’s why I stay home. Beer is cheaper and I can lay down butt ass naked and not get kicked out like that one time at Reliant.
 

CloakNNNdagger

Hall of Fame
The sun roof is pointless, but it was a good marketing toy for a little while.
A $48 million sunroof. If the point was to try to have the loudest stadium in the League, the roof should have been domed and constructed of metal, not fabric, and each level of the overhangs closer towards the field as they would basically act as noise catchers, deflecting the noise from below back toward the center of the field. Just like the ill-advised grass field and the poor sun orientation of the stadium, the brilliant NRG architects when conceiving the roof essentially created an expensive nondurable sound-absorbing umbrella. At least they didn't opt for a better sound containing/reflective clear plexiglass player/fan-frying material like their city predecessors. :toropalm:
 

thunderkyss

It's good to be me... again.
Staff member
Contributor's Club
The sun roof is pointless, but it was a good marketing toy for a little while.
I could have sworn the idea behind the retractable roof was about having an indoor venue on gameday with real grass, like an open stadium. It was supposed to be the best of both worlds.

I know it didn't work out that way, but that was the idea. Indoor game experience. Open during week to let the grass grow.
 

Mangler

Veteran
Well, that idea (closed roof=louder crowd) isn’t even working as the Houston crowd is rarely ever that much into the game. I don’t know if it’s because we haven’t won anything, or they don’t really care to even try to be one of the loudest crowds. I’ve been to quite a few outdoor stadiums that put us to shame. Mainly Centurylink in Seattle.
 

Speedy

Yeller Dweller
It's the same with the Astros, though they do open it up early in the season. At least twice in this year's playoffs the roof cost the Astros outs on popups that hit the roof. But hey, gotta have that noise because that obviously makes a difference (0-4 at home in the WS).

But I heard the players (Astros) prefer it closed.

As for the Texans, yeah, the stadium concept was flawed from the beginning. I believe the Texans did want it more open, but the rodeo didn't, so they came up with that design. Should have just made it a dome at that point.

I remember the Pittsburgh game where we thought we'd make the Steelers wear black, open the roof in September to have the sun blaring down on them, to gain some advantage. Big fail, of course, but that game was the most miserable I've ever been at any sporting event. You'd burn your arm just putting it on the arm rest. I moved to the south end zone where the sun never shines the following season. That's when they came up with their 80-50 BS that they never seemed to follow from the get go.

Odd that Houston has 2 retractable roof stadiums and in big nationally televised games, our overhead shots of the stadium suck because the damn roofs are closed.

I sorta get it with the Texans for noon games, because even when it's not that hot, the north end zone is looking straight into the sun for most of the game. It is a little difficult to see. But night games, even 3:00 games, the sun isn't an issue at all. No reason to have it closed.

But like someone has said up thread, I don't go to games to look at the sky, I'm there to watch a football game. In baseball though, the roof can actually have an effect on the game.

And the crowd noise thing? I've heard it ear shattering loud with the roof open at NRG before.

BTW, last open roof game at NRG - November 30, 2014.
 

Hookem Horns

Administrator
Staff member
I was all for the open roof until my section (500 level above the Bullpen endzone) became a furnace on Noon starts in the early months. In the early years they would often open the roof. There would literally be empty seats all around us until after halftime when the sun would move away.

Houston is the hottest, most humid place that I’ve ever lived and having an open roof stadium is not practical for typical NFL start times.

BTW, it can be brutal here in Tampa Bay on Sundays but it’s not like Houston. You have the 3 digit heat, humidity and air pollution on top of that.
 

texanhead08

All Pro
I was all for the open roof until my section (500 level above the Bullpen endzone) became a furnace on Noon starts in the early months. In the early years they would often open the roof. There would literally be empty seats all around us until after halftime when the sun would move away.

Houston is the hottest, most humid place that I’ve ever lived and having an open roof stadium is not practical for typical NFL start times.

BTW, it can be brutal here in Tampa Bay on Sundays but it’s not like Houston. You have the 3 digit heat, humidity and air pollution on top of that.

That Steelers game in 2005 was brutal I am glad they don't open it anymore.
 

Hervoyel

BUENO!
It was simply a bad idea and came about in an atmosphere of denial about who "we" are. Houston is not a place that's fit for open air stadiums most of the year. The next owner of any sport who says something about a retractable roof needs to have this explained to him with a number of four letter words thrown in for emphasis. Not just "No" but "Hell No"
 

Double Barrel

Moderator
Staff member
Contributor's Club
That Steelers game in 2005 was brutal I am glad they don't open it anymore.
I was there, as well. I remember the Steelers had brought their own benches, which had air conditioning built into them. The Texas were sitting on metal benches. And then the entire north end of the stadium was a frying pan.

I was also there for the season when the roof was damaged by a storm and stayed open all season. There was a Monday night game and the temperature dropped, so a northern wind was blowing in and freezing us out in the upper sections of the south end (Gridiron, TX represent!).

All in all, it was a dumb idea. Houston is a coastal city not far removed from being a swamp, and the consistent humidity alone should have mandated a closed stadium be built for noise and lots of sweet, sweet air conditioning. They knew that in the 1960's when they built the Astrodome, but somehow forgot that basic fact when the built NRG.

Now it's just a useless sunroof and a monument to the hubris of some engineers and marketing execs.
 

Uncle Rico

Ur apology should be as loud as Ur disrespect was
A $48 million sunroof. If the point was to try to have the loudest stadium in the League, the roof should have been domed and constructed of metal, not fabric, and each level of the overhangs closer towards the field as they would basically act as noise catchers, deflecting the noise from below back toward the center of the field. Just like the ill-advised grass field and the poor sun orientation of the stadium, the brilliant NRG architects when conceiving the roof essentially created an expensive nondurable sound-absorbing umbrella. At least they didn't opt for a better sound containing/reflective clear plexiglass player/fan-frying material like their city predecessors. :toropalm:
thank goodness they spared no expense on a great playing surface!!:kitten:
 

Mr.Scarface

Waterboy
We will build another stadium in 5-10 years. The sooner we win a Super Bowl the sooner we will get a new stadium.
Um No. They would renovate NRG. There is no need for a new stadium anytime soon. Texans get plenty of revenue from the stadium. I could see them building a dedicated Practice facility.
 

TexansBull

Hall of Fame
Um No. They would renovate NRG. There is no need for a new stadium anytime soon. Texans get plenty of revenue from the stadium. I could see them building a dedicated Practice facility.

Interesting article on the average life of an NFL stadium.

I wonder if Cal wants to play in the house his dad built, or the house he will build? Eventually everyone wants a house of their own.
 

Rich Schmidt

Myopicone
The roof got broken during Ike and has never been opened after they closed it since.
Wrong, was fixed in March of 2009 after Ike, and this little snippet exists

...the last time the NRG Stadium roof was open was Nov. 30, 2014, when Ryan Fitzpatrick threw six touchdown passes in a win over Tennessee.The Texans' all-time record with the roof open is 24-21
 

BattleBull

Practice Squad
Why don't they just open it for the night games then? Sunday night was beautiful, would have liked to seen it open. Even one or two days a year would be cool
That I agree with, the afternoon games the heat can be pretty ridiculous but night games really shouldn't be an issue. If they can open the thing in Arizona, they can open it here.
 

gwallaia

Moderator
Staff member
The idea of the retractable was a bad idea. The 8' square grass trays were a bad idea.

There is zero airflow in the stadium when the roof is open and the north end of the field can become unbearably hot even with mild temperatures.
The sun never hit the grass trays on the south side of the stadium and rotating the grass trays was too much of a problem.
Cloak is right in regards to the fabric roof absorbing sound. The Dome was loud because the roof is hard and sound waves bounce back into the stadium.

One curious byproduct of the open roof was the arching shadow it would create across the field. Punters used this to their advantage and would intentionally aim the punts where the ball would come out the shadows and into the sharp shadow line of the sun making it difficult for the returner to see the ball.
 

TexansBull

Hall of Fame
A $48 million sunroof. If the point was to try to have the loudest stadium in the League, the roof should have been domed and constructed of metal, not fabric, and each level of the overhangs closer towards the field as they would basically act as noise catchers, deflecting the noise from below back toward the center of the field. Just like the ill-advised grass field and the poor sun orientation of the stadium, the brilliant NRG architects when conceiving the roof essentially created an expensive nondurable sound-absorbing umbrella. At least they didn't opt for a better sound containing/reflective clear plexiglass player/fan-frying material like their city predecessors. :toropalm:
How did the architects get it so wrong?
 

Speedy

Yeller Dweller
What time? I want to say it's always open when I drive by.
Morning, afternoon, doesn't matter. And like I said, I do see it 2-3 times a week, whether driving north on 288 or passing right by it on 610, for the last 4 years at least. It's never open.

Used to be open during the week back when they had grass inside, but no more.
 

Texazan

Our HOF 34
The Cardinals open State Farm stadium here when the weather is nice day or night. During the day it’s a huge issue for the first hour, the glare is unbearable. After an hour it’s fine but that first hour, geesh.

I seem to recall the Texans opened it for a PITT game and it boiled some fans alive, LOL, maybe that ended it.....
 


Top