YOU are Dan Reeves

Discussion in 'Texans Talk' started by Goldeagle, Dec 18, 2005.

  1. Goldeagle

    Goldeagle Hall of Fame

    Joined:
    Jan 10, 2005
    Messages:
    1,816
    Likes Received:
    42
    Location:
    Spring
    Rate them on the typical John McLaine scale of A great to F (bad)

    Daivd Carr:

    Dominick Davis:
    Jonathan Wells:
    Moran Norris:
    Verand Morency:

    Andre Johnson:
    Jabar Gaffney:
    Corey Bradford:
    Jerome Mathis:
    Derrik Armstrong:

    Chester Pitts:
    Zack Weigert:
    Steve McKenney:
    Fred Weary:
    Todd Wade:
    Todd Washington:
    Drew Hodgen:

    Jerry Deloach:
    gary Walker:
    Seth Payne
    Junior Ione (sp?):
    Travis Johnson:
    Robaire Smith:

    Deshon polk:
    Antwan Peek:
    Morlon Greenwood:
    Kailee Wong:
    Jason Babin:
    Shantee Orr:

    Dunta Robinson:
    Phillip Buchanan:
    Demarcus Faggins:
    Jason Bell:
    Lewis Sanders:

    CC Brown:
    Mark Coleman:
    Glenn Earl:
    Jason Simmons:


    Kris Brown:
    Chad Stanley:

    Dom Capers:
    Charlie Casserly
     
  2. Goldeagle

    Goldeagle Hall of Fame

    Joined:
    Jan 10, 2005
    Messages:
    1,816
    Likes Received:
    42
    Location:
    Spring
    Daivd Carr: C-

    Dominick Davis: B
    Jonathan Wells:B
    Moran Norris: D
    Verand Morency: D+

    Andre Johnson: B
    Jabar Gaffney: B
    Corey Bradford: D-
    Jerome Mathis: B
    Derrik Armstrong: C

    Chester Pitts: B
    Zack Weigert:C-
    Steve McKenney: D
    Fred Weary: F
    Todd Wade: F
    Todd Washington: D
    Drew Hodgen: C

    Jerry Deloach: D
    gary Walker: B
    Seth Payne: C
    Junior Ione (sp?): D
    Travis Johnson: C-
    Robaire Smith: C

    Deshon polk: C
    Antwan Peek: D+
    Morlon Greenwood: D-
    Kailee Wong: D
    Jason Babin: D-
    Shantee Orr: C

    Dunta Robinson: C+
    Phillip Buchanan: F
    Demarcus Faggins: C
    Jason Bell: C
    Lewis Sanders: C

    CC Brown: C-
    Mark Coleman: D
    Glenn Earl: C-
    Jason Simmons: C-


    Kris Brown: B-
    Chad Stanley: B

    Dom Capers: D
    Charlie Casserly: F
     
  3. Runner

    Runner Hubcap Diamond Staff Member

    Joined:
    Jan 6, 2005
    Messages:
    8,325
    Likes Received:
    627
    I'd like to, but I'm still recovering from the "you are the GM" thread from last week.
     
  4. stevo3883

    stevo3883 All Pro

    Joined:
    Sep 18, 2005
    Messages:
    733
    Likes Received:
    9
    Location:
    h-town
    Daivd Carr: C-

    Dominick Davis: B
    Jonathan Wells:C
    Moran Norris: D-
    Verand Morency: D+

    Andre Johnson: A
    Jabar Gaffney: C
    Corey Bradford: D-
    Jerome Mathis: B
    Derrik Armstrong: D

    Chester Pitts: B
    Zack Weigert:C-
    Steve McKenney: D
    Fred Weary: F
    Todd Wade: F
    Todd Washington: D
    Drew Hodgen: C+

    Jerry Deloach: D
    gary Walker: B-
    Seth Payne: C+
    Junior Ione (sp?): F
    Travis Johnson: D-
    Robaire Smith: C+

    Deshon polk: C+
    Antwan Peek: D-
    Morlon Greenwood: D-
    Kailee Wong: D+
    Jason Babin: D-
    Shantee Orr: C+

    Dunta Robinson: B+
    Phillip Buchanan: F-------
    Demarcus Faggins: C-
    Jason Bell: D-
    Lewis Sanders: D-

    CC Brown: C-
    Mark Coleman: D-
    Glenn Earl: D
    Jason Simmons: D-


    Kris Brown: B-
    Chad Stanley: B

    Dom Capers: D
    Charlie Casserly F
     
  5. Nighthawk

    Nighthawk All Pro

    Joined:
    Sep 18, 2004
    Messages:
    719
    Likes Received:
    21
    The rest of these guys are all Cs and Ds, for the most part. Too much trouble to grade 'em. Not really worth it.
     
  6. axman40

    axman40 Hall of Fame

    Joined:
    Apr 29, 2004
    Messages:
    21,687
    Likes Received:
    536
    Location:
    Austin
    I run to the bank and clean out my checking account and savings !

    :cool:
     
  7. edo783

    edo783 Site Contributor

    Joined:
    Apr 29, 2004
    Messages:
    7,712
    Likes Received:
    308
    Location:
    Houston, again.
    Rate them on the typical John McLaine scale of A great to F (bad)

    Daivd Carr: C (might be a LOT better, but who knows)

    Dominick Davis: B
    Jonathan Wells: C+
    Moran Norris: B
    Verand Morency: Only a C at this point, maybe better, but again, not
    enough data.


    Andre Johnson: B Probably better than a B, but can't really tell at this
    point.

    Jabar Gaffney: C
    Corey Bradford: D-
    Jerome Mathis: A- as a Kick returner, D as Punt Returner, C- as a WR
    Can't really tell yet a WR, but has dropped several tosses to
    him. Might be a Lot better, but can't tell at this point.

    Derrik Armstrong: C+ Might be better, but not used enough to be sure.

    Chester Pitts: B+
    Zack Weigert: B when healthy, but that isn't often
    Steve McKenney: B as a LG, but only a C- as a Center
    Fred Weary: D
    Todd Wade: C-
    Todd Washington: D
    Drew Hodgen: C, might be better just not enough data yet.

    Jerry Deloach: C
    gary Walker: B+ when healthy, but again that isn't offten enough.
    Seth Payne: B
    Junior Ione (sp?): C
    Travis Johnson: C, very likely better, to soone to tell
    Robaire Smith: B and seems to be getting better

    Deshon polk: C
    Antwan Peek: C, to many loose parts to his game
    Morlon Greenwood: C+
    Kailee Wong: C+
    Jason Babin: C, might be better than that, but an injury has slowed his
    progression. Showed well today.

    Shantee Orr: C+ and may be better. Seems to be progressing and may be a
    real find.

    Dunta Robinson: A, although he hasn't done as well this year (sophmore
    thing?)

    Phillip Buchanan: D as a DB MIGHT be a C+ as a punt returner, didn't see
    that enough.

    Demarcus Faggins: C
    Jason Bell: C-
    Lewis Sanders: ???? Not enough data points to make the call.

    CC Brown: C+ and might be better.
    Mark Coleman: D at this point in his career. Time to hang them up IMO.
    Glenn Earl: C might be a real find, just to early to tell
    Jason Simmons: C as a DB, B+ as a special teams player.


    Kris Brown: B+
    Chad Stanley: C+

    Dom Capers: C-
    Charlie Casserly: C-
     
  8. Hervoyel

    Hervoyel The Right Track

    Joined:
    Apr 30, 2004
    Messages:
    15,564
    Likes Received:
    2,348
    This is a lie! I'm NOT Dan Reeves!

    That's just some junk that other posters made up to try and discred...

    Oh? Not "literally" Dan Reeves?

    Sorry, nevermind.
     


  9. royce1054

    royce1054 All Pro

    Joined:
    Mar 13, 2005
    Messages:
    900
    Likes Received:
    6
    Location:
    HOUSTON
    There should be a grade lower than F so i can give it to Casserly maybe a Z-
     
  10. YoungTexanFan

    YoungTexanFan Hall of Fame

    Joined:
    Dec 1, 2004
    Messages:
    4,802
    Likes Received:
    134
    Daivd Carr: b-

    Dominick Davis: a
    Jonathan Wells: a-
    Moran Norris: a
    Verand Morency: c-

    Andre Johnson: b+
    Jabar Gaffney: b
    Corey Bradford: f
    Jerome Mathis: b+
    Derrik Armstrong: incomplete

    Chester Pitts: b-
    Zack Weigert: c+
    Steve McKenney: d+
    Fred Weary: D
    Todd Wade: D-
    Todd Washington: C-
    Drew Hodgen: b-

    Jerry Deloach: c
    gary Walker: a-
    Seth Payne: b+
    Junior Ione (sp?): d
    Travis Johnson: c-
    Robaire Smith: b-

    Deshon polk: a
    Antwan Peek: b-
    Morlon Greenwood: F
    Kailee Wong: c
    Jason Babin: b+
    Shantee Orr: a-

    Dunta Robinson: b+
    Phillip Buchanan: b-
    Demarcus Faggins: F
    Jason Bell: d
    Lewis Sanders: incomplete

    CC Brown: a-
    Mark Coleman: F
    Glenn Earl: c
    Jason Simmons:d


    Kris Brown: d
    Chad Stanley: a

    Dom Capers: d+
    Charlie Casserly: d-


    please notice my two players in bold.

    some guys i graded higher based on expectations or draft position.
    some guys i graded lower for the same reasons as above.
     
  11. Daivd Carr: B- (leads the team when given the chance)

    Dominick Davis C: (gets hurt, can't block)
    Jonathan Wells: C (no toughness)
    Moran Norris: B (underutilized)
    Verand Morency: B (underutilized)

    Andre Johnson: B (still has a few kinks in his armor)
    Jabar Gaffney: C (must be able to create)
    Corey Bradford:F (bad hands, horrible smarts)
    Jerome Mathis: C (stay healthy, why is he not the starter)
    Derrik Armstrong: B (lost in the shuffle)

    Chester Pitts:C (ok at LT, takes too long to develop)
    Zack Weigert:C (veteran)
    Steve McKenney:D (gets blown up too much)
    Fred Weary: F (bad pick, no fire)
    Todd Wade: F (weak and soft)
    Todd Washington: C (when he's a center)
    Drew Hodgen: B (didn't stay healthy, bit I liked what I saw)

    Jerry Deloach: C (Journeyman, but veteran)
    gary Walker: A (has been fired up this year)
    Seth Payne C (not making an impact like a NT should)
    Junior Ioane : C (backup)
    Travis Johnson: D (still learning, but seems weak)
    Robaire Smith: B (strong but lacks quickness)

    Deshon polk: C (good job picking up, but not there yet)
    Antwan Peek: D (handed the reigns but didn't deliver)
    Morlon Greenwood: D (overhyped and overpaid)
    Kailee Wong: B (LB unit leader, smart and versitile)
    Jason Babin: B (rushed into position, but a force on pass downs)
    Shantee Orr: B (great backup and borderline starter)

    Dunta Robinson: A (gets burned from time to time, but great skills)
    Phillip Buchanan: F (bust)
    Demarcus Faggins: C (dimeback)
    Jason Bell: D (special teamer)
    Lewis Sanders: D (nothin special)

    CC Brown: C (rookie, but learning)
    Mark Coleman: D (out of position and lost his fire)
    Glenn Earl: C (good against run, but weaker in pass)
    Jason Simmons: C (special teamer)


    Kris Brown: B (good kicker but....)
    Chad Stanley: C (inconsistant)

    Dom Capers: C (has made adjustments to fix problems, relies on friendship too much
    Charlie Casserly F (Boselli, Hollings, Brown, etc.....)
     
  12. stephen1

    stephen1 Veteran

    Joined:
    Mar 12, 2005
    Messages:
    151
    Likes Received:
    0
    Davis-A
     
  13. Napa Auto Parts

    Napa Auto Parts Hall of Fame

    Joined:
    Oct 17, 2005
    Messages:
    1,186
    Likes Received:
    15
    Location:
    Houston
    Daivd Carr: D- in four years hasnt showed he is cut up for the NFL sad but true regardless what anyone says.

    Dominick Davis: C+ good back just cant stay healthy year round
    Jonathan Wells: C Produces when given a chance
    Moran Norris: C
    Verand Morency: D havent seen enought to judge

    Andre Johnson: B- Possibly and A with a good QB
    Jabar Gaffney: C
    Corey Bradford: F-
    Jerome Mathis: D as a reciever B+ in special teams
    Derrik Armstrong:

    Chester Pitts: B
    Zack Weigert: D
    Steve McKenney: C
    Fred Weary: D
    Todd Wade: D
    Todd Washington: D
    Drew Hodgen: D

    Jerry Deloach: D-
    gary Walker: C+
    Seth Payne C
    Junior Ione (sp?):
    Travis Johnson: C
    Robaire Smith: C-

    Deshon polk: D
    Antwan Peek: D
    Morlon Greenwood: C
    Kailee Wong: C-
    Jason Babin: D-
    Shantee Orr: C+

    Dunta Robinson: B+
    Phillip Buchanan: F+
    Demarcus Faggins:
    Jason Bell: D
    Lewis Sanders: D

    CC Brown: C
    Mark Coleman:F
    Glenn Earl: C
    Jason Simmons: D


    Kris Brown: C+
    Chad Stanley: B+

    Dom Capers: F
    Charlie Casserly F-

    Bob Mcnair F For not getting rid of the coaching staff after our national showing in seatle.
     
  14. non natural texan

    non natural texan Rookie

    Joined:
    Nov 3, 2004
    Messages:
    75
    Likes Received:
    1
    Daivd Carr: C, he would be better if protected properly

    Dominick Davis: B-, he is what he is
    Jonathan Wells: B
    Moran Norris: B
    Verand Morency: B

    Andre Johnson: B-
    Jabar Gaffney: C
    Corey Bradford: C-
    Jerome Mathis: D, reciever... Returner: A
    Derrik Armstrong: C-

    Chester Pitts: B
    Zack Weigert: F
    Steve McKenney: F+
    Fred Weary: D
    Todd Wade: F
    Todd Washington: D
    Drew Hodgen: C

    Jerry Deloach:
    gary Walker: C
    Seth Payne: C+
    Junior Ione (sp?): C
    Travis Johnson: B, he'll get better
    Robaire Smith: c+

    Deshon polk: B, great job coming off the bench
    Antwan Peek: C
    Morlon Greenwood: C
    Kailee Wong: C
    Jason Babin: C-
    Shantee Orr: B, same as Polk

    Dunta Robinson: B+
    Phillip Buchanan: F
    Demarcus Faggins: C+, he would likely only be a starter here
    Jason Bell: B
    Lewis Sanders: B

    CC Brown: B
    Mark Coleman: D-
    Glenn Earl: B
    Jason Simmons: B


    Kris Brown: B-
    Chad Stanley: D+

    Dom Capers: C-
    Charlie Casserly: D+


    A lot of the young guys get B's based on what they've shown thus far in their career... they will get better, unlike players such as Walker and Coleman who have shown all they have.
     
  15. HJam72

    HJam72 Hall of Fame

    Joined:
    Aug 28, 2004
    Messages:
    11,617
    Likes Received:
    653
    Location:
    Over here.
    Here's how I do it:

    Goldeagle: D (gave Moran Norris a D)

    stevo3883: F (gave Norris a D, Orr a C+, and Brown a B-)

    edo783: A- (shouldn't have given Buch a passing grade and maybe a little too hard on Orr)

    YoungTexanFan: A (too hard on Brown and too easy on Peek)

    SESupergenious(Linux is better) :) : B- (too hard on Davis, Wells, and Pitts. too easy on Capers)


    Napa Auto Parts: 0- (too hard on everybody) (besides, you're an *****) :)

    non natural Texan: C+ (too easy on Bradford and Capers, too hard on Weigert)
     
  16. ccdude730

    ccdude730 Hall of Fame

    Joined:
    May 1, 2004
    Messages:
    1,616
    Likes Received:
    37
    Location:
    Corpus Christi
    YoungTexanFan needs to reevaluate his secondary grades :tiptoe:
     
  17. HJam72

    HJam72 Hall of Fame

    Joined:
    Aug 28, 2004
    Messages:
    11,617
    Likes Received:
    653
    Location:
    Over here.
    Very true. I give myself an F. :bomb:
     
  18. Grid

    Grid Hall of Fame

    Joined:
    Apr 29, 2004
    Messages:
    4,299
    Likes Received:
    244
    Tough crowd.. but ill give it a shot.

    Rate them on the typical John McLaine scale of A great to F (bad)

    David Carr: C+ (Not bad enough to dump..not good enough to be happy about. need more time.)

    Dominick Davis: A- (Has everything except durability)
    Jonathan Wells: B (good backup)
    Moran Norris: A (one of the best FBs in the league)
    Verand Morency: C (has promise.. still a rookie though)

    Andre Johnson: B+ (You can tell he has talent, just arent using him right)
    Jabar Gaffney: B (great hands, great route runner. everyone cant be a star)
    Corey Bradford: D (too one dimensional)
    Jerome Mathis: B (Great KR... but can he be our #2?)
    Derrik Armstrong: B (He hasnt been played enough. I cant give an A, and wont give him lower than a B because he has looked passingly good when he played)

    Chester Pitts: A (hes a keeper)
    Zack Weigert: D (for playing the easiest spot on the line.. hes weak)
    Steve McKenney: B+ (We are misusing him. He is a great LG)
    Fred Weary: F (bubye)
    Todd Wade: D+ (costs too much. keep him as backup till you can cut him)
    Todd Washington: F (if he cant take the C job from McKinney..he can go)
    Drew Hodgen: B- (hope he isnt injury prone.. i liked what i saw)

    Jerry Deloach: C (career backup... but teams need depth)
    gary Walker: C (His time has passed.. time to replace him)
    Seth Payne: B- (hes a GOOD DT.. but a playmaker up front MAKES the 3-4)
    Junior Ioane: C+ (Another career backup)
    Travis Johnson: B- (Shows some promise.. needs work)
    Robaire Smith: B+ (Glad we got him. He is a quality starter)

    Deshon polk: B (Polk and Wong may be our starting ILB next season)
    Antwan Peek: B (Want to see what he can do with a different DC)
    Morlon Greenwood: C+ (I like his coverage.. dont like much else)
    Kailee Wong: B+ (quality starter.. i trust him to play hard and well)
    Jason Babin: B (I see potential)
    Shantee Orr: B+ (I think he could shine in a better system)

    Dunta Robinson: A+ (hes a star)
    Phillip Buchanan: D (hes a bum.. but he can be depth)
    Demarcus Faggins: C+ (great NICKLE corner.. not so great starter)
    Jason Bell: D+ (hes depth right now.. but I wouldnt miss him if he left)
    Lewis Sanders: C (more depth.. we really need a solid #2)

    CC Brown: B (I think hes gonna be a starter for this team for a while)
    Mark Coleman: D- (after this season.. im ready for him to go)
    Glenn Earl: B (CC Brown and Earl look good at the saftey spots)
    Jason Simmons: B- (what a hitter.. great great depth)


    Kris Brown: A+ (great NFL kicker)
    Chad Stanley: B (hes been off this year)

    Dom Capers: B (I think he could do better with better help)
    Charlie Casserly: D+ (He made some good picks.. but some BAAAD trades)
     
  19. HJam72

    HJam72 Hall of Fame

    Joined:
    Aug 28, 2004
    Messages:
    11,617
    Likes Received:
    653
    Location:
    Over here.
    Nevermind.
     
  20. Texas_Thrill

    Texas_Thrill Hall of Fame

    Joined:
    Apr 19, 2005
    Messages:
    1,473
    Likes Received:
    22
    Location:
    H-Town stomping once again!
    I wonder what the hell I got myself into. Thank a old friend for the check and leave town on the first thing smoking b/c at my age I need to get to enjoy life as much as I can. :yahoo:
     

Share This Page