I am not convinced that Mathis should be returning punts. I love him as an electrifying kick returner, as we all do, but I am worried about him getting his head taken off shaggin' punts. I don't think he looks too comfortable back there, and he has a little trouble adjusting to the ball especially in open air stadiums. While alot of this can get better with experience, I think he could use a little more time to develope this skill. I am not to big on DD pulling punt return duty either. He needs to keep gas in the tank for the ensuing offensive drive. I would like to see Vernand Morency get the job, he has good hands and knows how to get North and South. And since PBuc is out, what about DROB he has sure hands, he's fast, and is extremely atheletic. It would take alot of reps in practice, not sure if he has ever done it? And I am not saying it would be worth the risk of injury, but it would be intresting. If not DROB, how about GAFF or Armstrong? For the remainder of the season, I would vote for Morency.