QBs - Texans Draft Value

Discussion in 'College Football & the NFL Draft' started by TheBestForTheTexans, Feb 22, 2007.

  1. TheBestForTheTexans

    TheBestForTheTexans Rookie

    Joined:
    Feb 21, 2007
    Messages:
    6
    Likes Received:
    0
    I'm interested in seeing where other Texans fans value players at each position. This time QB. Please rank them numerically according to value to the Texans and also list the level of the highest draft position you think the Texans should use on the player. (high-1st, mid-1st, late-1st, high-2nd, ……...) Mid and late levels of a round would be by trade since we are relatively high in each round as it stands now. I would also like to see comments below each player as to why or why not they would fit the Texans. Try to stay unbiased with the Carr/Plummer/?? rumors :hairpull: , I'm more interested in the value of each player to the Texans during the draft and how they fit the system.

    EXAMPLE
    name: ------------
    school: ------
    Rank: 4
    Round Value: mid-2nd
    Fit? Not mobile, wouldn't fit Kubiak system with bootlegs.....


    name: Brady Quinn
    school: ND
    Rank:
    Round Value:
    Fit?

    name: JaMarcus Russell
    school: LSU
    Rank:
    Round Value:
    Fit?

    name: Drew Stanton
    school: Michigan State
    Rank:
    Round Value:
    Fit?

    name: Troy Smith
    school: Ohio State
    Rank:
    Round Value:
    Fit?

    name: Jordan Palmer
    school: UTEP
    Rank:
    Round Value:
    Fit?

    name: Kevin Kolb
    school: Houston
    Rank:
    Round Value:
    Fit?

    name: John Beck
    school: BYU
    Rank:
    Round Value:
    Fit?

    name: Tyler Palko
    school: Pittsburgh
    Rank:
    Round Value:
    Fit?

    name: Jeff Rowe
    school: Nevada
    Rank:
    Round Value:
    Fit?

    name: Chris Leak
    school: Florida
    Rank:
    Round Value:
    Fit?

    name: Luke Getsy
    school: Akron
    Rank:
    Round Value:
    Fit?

    name: Jared Zabransky
    school: Boise State
    Rank:
    Round Value:
    Fit?

    name: Trent Edwards
    school: Stanford
    Rank:
    Round Value:
    Fit?

    name: Drew Tate
    school: Iowa
    Rank:
    Round Value:
    Fit?
     
  2. threetoedpete

    threetoedpete Hall of Fame

    Joined:
    May 26, 2004
    Messages:
    6,644
    Likes Received:
    197
    Location:
    Katy, Texas
    name: Brady Quinn
    school: ND
    Rank: 1a
    Round Value: first round
    Fit? yes

    name: JaMarcus Russell
    school: LSU
    Rank: 1b
    Round Value: first
    Fit? no

    name: Drew Stanton
    school: Michigan State
    Rank: 7th
    Round Value: fifth
    Fit? yes

    name: Troy Smith
    school: Ohio State
    Rank: 3rd
    Round Value: second
    Fit? yes

    name: Jordan Palmer
    school: UTEP
    Rank: 8th
    Round Value: seventh
    Fit? no

    name: Kevin Kolb
    school: Houston
    Rank: 4th
    Round Value: third
    Fit? He77 no

    name: John Beck
    school: BYU
    Rank: fifth
    Round Value: fourth
    Fit? yes

    name: Tyler Palko
    school: Pittsburgh
    Rank:12th
    Round Value: 7th
    Fit? yes

    name: Jeff Rowe
    school: Nevada
    Rank: 11th
    Round Value: free agent
    Fit? no

    name: Chris Leak
    school: Florida
    Rank: 8th
    Round Value: 6th
    Fit? yes

    name: Luke Getsy
    school: Akron
    Rank: tenth
    Round Value: free agent
    Fit? no

    name: Jared Zabransky
    school: Boise State
    Rank: 7th
    Round Value: 6th
    Fit? Yes

    name: Trent Edwards
    school: Stanford
    Rank: 4th
    Round Value: 5th
    Fit? yes

    name: Drew Tate
    school: Iowa
    Rank: Free agent
    Round Value: 7th
    Fit? yes
     
  3. yourfavoritetexan42

    yourfavoritetexan42 Veteran

    Joined:
    Jan 18, 2006
    Messages:
    412
    Likes Received:
    14
    I am only doing the qbs i know a whole lot about...:

    name: Brady Quinn
    school: ND
    Rank: 1a
    Round Value: first round
    Fit? yes, most nfl ready

    name: JaMarcus Russell
    school: LSU
    Rank: 1b
    Round Value: first
    Fit? no, will be not even close to culpepper

    name: Drew Stanton
    school: Michigan State
    Rank: 7th
    Round Value: fifth
    Fit? yes, second best qb in my opinion

    name: Troy Smith
    school: Ohio State
    Rank: 3rd
    Round Value: second
    Fit? yes, could be a mcnabb...just needs to improve awareness

    name: Kevin Kolb
    school: Houston
    Rank: 4th
    Round Value: third
    Fit? He77 no, highly overrated

    name: Chris Leak
    school: Florida
    Rank: 8th
    Round Value: 6th
    Fit? yes, most accurate qb in the draft in my opinion, needs to improve arm strength

    name: Jared Zabransky
    school: Boise State
    Rank: 7th
    Round Value: 6th
    Fit? Yes, is a winner

    name: Drew Tate
    school: Iowa
    Rank: Free agent
    Round Value: 7th
    Fit? yes, has a lot of potential
     

Share This Page