with a twist.... Let's say his name was Brooks, Aaron Brooks. He became a starter in 2001, one year before David. He's thrown for 3000 yards every year. his avg would be more than 3000. his passer rating is comparable. He's got an arm, he's shown that he can make plays. Hints of ProBowl Caliber...... shouldn't he get a pass?? His recievers drop balls, he's offensive line is pourous, His running back is always getting hurt.... what do you think?? Can you bring enough evidence to seperate his situation from Carrs??