Discussion in 'The National Football League' started by yaboycm, Nov 20, 2005.
Who would you want to have as the quarterback of the Texans, Mike Vick or David Carr?
Vick would have been ours if he stayed for his Junior year.
Knowing what we know now regarding his injuries the past two year or if both were 100%??
With injuries. Carr
Let's see a poll with Peyton Manning & David Carr. We have an equal chance of obtaining Manning as we do Vick. Is LaDainian Tomlinson or Domanick Davis your next poll?
Lets see, a Qb that can't throw.....or a QB that can't....throw.....
Carr hands down. Not being biased either. I just think I would want a QB who knows he is a QB, not a QB who doesn't know he's not a RB...
Vick is going to get himself hammered 1 day and really hurt and then the Falcons will be in our shoes ...
Imagin how soon It would have happened playng behind our line.
David Carr is a Better QB than M.Vick and has showed it time and time again
Just getting a feel for who knows what is going on. And to see what people's answer will be to my next poll.
With the Texans O-Line, Mike Vick would have won more games.
The answer to that question is simple ..... Vick .
He's an enigma at the QB position . I dont think ANY player has come into the NFL and changed the nature of his position more than Vick ..... There may never be another player like him but EVERY team in the NFL will be looking for the next Vick .
Vick made it clear that he WAS NOT going to play for an expansion team . Call him a prophet cause he knew what David Carr was going to go thru and stated as much .
I think Carr is more a product of the system and players around him than his talent level . He has never been put into a situation to succeed . Given the opportunity and a few players around him I think he will become a solid NFL QB .... but not in the class of M. Vick .
Sorry to bump an old thread here, but I couldn't help but get a chuckle over this thread, especially in light of the recent news regarding vick.
Say whatever you will about Carr's QB skills, at LEAST you know when he's flying out of the IAH, you aren't going to have to worry about him stashing Mary J in his water bottle.
He might have too if he wants to get picked up by the only team that might interested in him the raiders
He's gonna need something a lot stronger than the Leaf if he's going to Oakland..
Everyone wants what they can't have.
I pick vick just becuase he is more mobile and he won't get sacked as much behind our offensive line. If we had a good offensive line, than I would say Carr.
Thanks John I was really worried he might be.
Separate names with a comma.