Discussion in 'College Football & the NFL Draft' started by DerekLee1, Jan 2, 2008.
How would this guy look in a Texans uni?
J Stew (click for link)
He would look darn good in a Texans uniform....but not near as good as a Left Tackle would.
he looks small in College games.. that means he is probably too small to be an every down back in the NFL.
hrm..well according to the internets..he is 5'11" and 230-240....so size may not be an issue afterall.
I agree that a stud LT would look much better in steel blue.. but if this guy is BPA I wouldnt be against it...at least, judging by his highlight reel I wouldnt be against it
Saw the J Stew reel.
And I searched and viewed the Mendenhall reel (vs. Wisconsin).
My money is on Mendenhall, if I had to pick between the two.
Dude looks pretty good. Although the majority of plays vs. Wisconsin were from the Shotgun, with two RBs, and although we don't run the shotgun much, I still saw Mendenhall running right up the middle a lot. So it's not like he's just a Bush-type player who gets around the edge. Mendenhall seems to knife his way right through the gut of the defensive line a lot.
Here's the Illinois vs. Wisconsin reel with Mendenhall: Link
more and more backs are playing out of the spread. it's an issue for translating QB's talents to the pros, but not really RB's.
That highlight reel was from 2005, remember, in his SOPHOMORE YEAR. Look at the improvements he made even BEYOND that in his next two seasons.
YR ATT YDS AVG LNG TD
2005 53 188 3.5 33 6
2006 183 981 5.4 63 10
2007 280 1722 6.2 88 11
And oh, he's NEVER HAD A FUMBLE IN HIS ENTIRE CAREER!!!
That's not correct. Stewart did not lose a fumble this season (he did fumble in the Fresno State game). But, he has lost fumbles in previous seasons.
Jonathan Stewart is a different back than any other. most teams like a combination of power back between the tackles in tough short yardage situations & a speed back that can get outside the tackle box 2nd level as home run threat. Jonathan is really a true power back, downhill, straight ahead runner with out alot of shake & bake yet still a home run threat, great speed, vision, everytime he touches the ball. plus he's a consumate team player, smart, humble, improved blocker & plucks the ball as receiver. Jonathan Stewart is like two RB's in one. This is what should increase his value to any NFL team looking for a feature back & return on investment.
I'm having a hard time in deciding who I like better between Mendenhall and Stewart. They seem to be very comparable to each other; they both are power runners with breakaway speed, both 20 years old, both 5'11 225lbs-ish, and both have simliar production (1500+ yards at 6.4 and 6.2 yards per carry.)
I would love either one with our first pick.
I stand corrected. ESPN's stat page is apparently wrong then.
Espn doesn't have a fumble credited to any college player. I don't think the NCAA actually tracks fumbles, except on a team basis. You'd basically have to go through all the play-by-play transcripts to determine the fumbles.
We don't have to worry about it. Rick Smith will do the evaluation & recommendation to Kubiak.
Need wise they'll be weighted in this order, IMO CB, OT, RB. bpa @ those positions.
CB- the only cover corner, thats draft eligble worth around the 18th pick is Antoine Cason, Arizona. he is a little bigger than d-rob & above average in run support with very good cover skills. will depend on the rest of the class of underclassman to declare.
OT- Sam Baker would be a nice fit & longterm solution @ LT. personel workouts more than anything at this point will solidify his position on the Texans draft board. the next bpa @ tackle is Jeff Otah & Gosder Cherilus so the Texans will have options for selecting a LT @ #18 depending how they rate them.
RB- Jonathan Stewart would be the bpa in this scenero if he where still on the board. he should be a top 15 pick but it would be hard to pass on a franchise back if he falls in your lap & fills #3 priority need.
am i the only one who didnt think JS' highlights were anything to get excited about bar the first run? mendenhall (who id never seen before) on the other hand looked quite impressive
Yeah, but this was his 05 season.
I bet his 07 season highlight reel looks amazing.
They're highlight reels - they're suppose to be impressive.
Show me film of the guys blocking, studying tape, following their assignment, running the proper route, etc...
No one ever looks bad on "highlight" tape.
I remember hearing about a QB once whose dad made a "highlight" reel that was just his incompletions.
Basically showing that many of his incompletions were good throws but his receivers dropped the balls.
I don't remember who I heard that about. I think the father sent the tape to college recruiters.
I know what you mean. no problem. paypal & anthonyE both make good points too. But one thing you have to understand is Jonathan is very low key, no showboating, doesn't want to call any attention to himself & shys away from the media. not that he's afraid of the media its just he doesnt want to accept credit without his teammates. In alot of ways Jonathan Stewart (0597 235) personality is similar to Andre Johnson, very much the consumate team player, softspoken & doesn't worry about his own press clippings, in this case video highlights created by others even though he's been different & elite (ranked the #1 RB coming out of High School) since strapping on cleats.
Regarding Mendenhall (0511 210) is impressive. his pro comp reminds me of Willis McGahee while I can't remember a comp to Jonathan Stewart but think he can be a bigger version of Maurice Jones Drew.
RUSHING ........ GP Att Gain Loss Net Avg TD Long Avg/G
Mendenhall,R. ..13 262 1742 61 1681 6.4 17 79 129.3
Stewart,J. ......13 280 1798 76 1722 6.2 11 88 132.5
just by watching the runs, mendenhall impresses me much, much more.
Outside of Long, there are no stud LTs in this draft. I am a USC fan, but Baker is not the answer. He's too injury prone, and can't be relied to hold down the left side.
I'd take Felix Jones over Stewart, or a trade down to somehow get Talib/Conner/Groves in the 1st, and Slaton in the 2nd.
Separate names with a comma.