Me and another 49ers fan are having a heated argument on the 49ers message board about David Carr. It's quite a long thread that was started by him. Basically he started the thread to insult David Carr and how he'll never amount to anything and is sick and tired of hearing that he may be something special if he went elsewhere. And now he wants the thread closed because everyone in the thread is disagreeing with him. So my question is, do you believe Carr will amount to anything? Ever? Here's a page of the thread. I think you can view one part of it even if you're not members on the forum. Click here. It came down to him believing that Carr just plain sucks because Sage Rosenfels played better behind the same offensive line that Carr did and only got sacked once, and Carr holds onto the ball too long and hasn't shown anything after being in the NFL for five years. I disagree. He had a pretty decent stint in 2004. Then he compared Carr to Losman and somehow concluded that he's better than Carr because he has "less weapons" and got sacked several times more. School this person please.