my second thoughts about the game:
First I want to say that we have some fair weather fans..... fair weather Carr fans at that, and you should be ashamed of yourselves. All of you guys who started your "criticism" about Carr, since yesterday, with "I've defended him, but after today I can't" should feel the worst.
I just re-watched the first half, and he didn't have his worse game of the year, far from it. It might have been his best game of the year.
Now before I get too much into it, I want to say if you share Vinny's opinion of Carr & his play, then you're right, he's still that same guy, and he had a poor game based on what Vinny, and guys like Vinny want to see.
But if you thought he has been playing well this season, and showing great improvement, and having a heck of a year, yesterday was a very good day for David Carr.
One of the things I noticed about David, Starting with the preseason games, after he got sacked, his footwork got all screwed up. Before the sack, he would stride back, every step the same, he'd have a rhythm, a gallop..... the spacing of his feet would be the same, his steps would follow a cadence. but after a sack.... that would go away. sometimes he'd cross his feet, sometimes he wouldn't. sometimes they'd open shoulder width, sometimes wider, sometimes shorter. It was like he was anxious, and his mind was telling him to do one thing, and his body wanted to do something else.
That stopped at around the Washington game..... & in the first half, against the Titans, it was still gone. KVB sacked him three times before the half(only one counted) & he was hit several times.... but his feet looked good.
I think it was the Indy game that I saw improvement in his willingness to look downfield as he was getting hit. Again, in Miami, he was doing very well looking downfield, as he was getting hit. Against Tennessee, he was looking downfield as he was getting hit. Remember that INT.... he got hit at the knees right after he let the ball go(he never should have let that ball go) & there was no flag even though that hit was worse than the KVB low blow.
Remember the play that David ran for like 8 yards, and he pump faked the ball to freeze the defender, then dove head first?? Well before all that, he did his perfect little 5 step drop, looking down field. I think it was Wiegarts guy who after he was ran around Carr came back to Carr from his left.... Carr takes a step to the right, never taking his sights from downfield. he then steps to the right a couple of more steps, then decides to take off down field.
Then there was that ball he drilled into the dirt, for no apparent reason. Well that apparent reason was a big Defensive end in his face. He hit his elbow on the guys helmet as he threw the ball, hence the sharp drop straight to the ground.
He didn't stretch the field by throwing the ball deep. But he didn't really do that in any of the other games......... shure, he threw the Jumpball to AJ in the Jax game, & he threw that beautiful bomb to Aj in the Washington game, and he got AJ on the one against Philly. & those were good throws... but one or two a game doesn't stretch the field. So if you were happy with Carr's down field throws before this game, you should have no problems with his refusal( I call it refusal, I don't have proof that you'd believe, but I call it refusal) to throw the ball down field in this game. He usually waits till the 4th Qtr, when he has no other choice....
He did fumble the ball twice, but if you think he had a good game against INdy, Washington, & Miami, then you should have no problem with Sunday's game. He fumbled the ball at least twice in those games, only none of them were returned for touchdowns.
He basically had the same game yesterday that he's been having all year. I just don't understand why soooo many Carr lovers all of a sudden flipped.