Discussion in 'The National Football League' started by Honoring Earl 34, Nov 12, 2007.
Is Brady Quinn better than any QB this years draft ... hmmm ?
Hard to tell, considering that neither he nor JaMarcus Russell has taken a snap this season. I would say that Trent Edwards has performed this best from the 07 class, if only because he's the only one that performed. :P
Yeah, Jared Zabransky.
Derek Anderson is having a monster year .
If Brady is rated above any QB coming out , why not trade him for a higher pick than you gave up for him .
Was Brady the highest rated? I was pretty sure it was JaMarcus Russell, but I could be wrong. Either way, I doubt that the Browns let go of Quinn. In fact, I would expect them to trade Anderson away before I see them let go of Quinn.
There's a thought. Derek Anderson, anyone? Of course I'm only half serious, but it would be hard to pass up on.
I have said that they should trade quinn to the panthers or bears first round pick...
This years draft because he's better than Ryan or Woolfolk .
I bet the Chargers would rather have Brees . That's why I say trade Quinn .
This question is premature. We have to wait three years before any type of determination can be made.
Or so I've heard.
I'm starting to pull for the Browns . The Texans are so iffy that I need to pull for someone who's got some chances .
I'm hoping the Browns go 12-4 and pick 27th . This means Dallas traded the 22nd pick for the 27th pick .
I also hope the Browns trade Quinn to the 6-10 Panthers who pick 8th . That means they traded the 22nd pick for the 8th pick because we know the Panthers need a QB for the future .
He might be better than Woolfolk (?) & Matt Ryan but there is no way he is better than Brian Brohm or Andre Woodson.
I'm thinking that Brady Quinn is a better prospect than both .
I never saw it. And I think it would be hard to find an NFL scout that did.
I think the Browns made a great move by trading up to get Quinn. He had really good value at 22.
But Brohm would have been the #1 pick if he had declared last year & he is still a top 10 player (his team is killing his draft status).
Woodson is easily a top 10 pick. There is really no arguement against him.
Brady Quinn 2006
2006 289 467 3426 61.9 7.34 62 37 7 31 146.65
Brian Brohm 2007
Projected 334 497 4289 67.2 8.63 81 34 11 22 157.64
Projected 278 438 3184 63.6 7.27 57 35 8 29 147.00
Could you title the stats so I can tell what is what?
year - comp - att - yards - % - YPA - long - TD - INT - ? - passer rating
i thought it was five???
So Brohm is on pace to have a way higher completion percentage, way more yds per attempt, & a higher efficiency rating. All that while having absolutely no talent on his entire team besides Harry Douglas.
Woodson is on pace to have a higher completion percentage, virtually the same yds per attempt, & a comparable efficiency rating. All that while playing on a mediocre team in the SEC.
I'm not a big Quinn fan but with him Notre dame was 10-3 . Without him ND is 1-9 . They did'nt lose a lot of guys to the NFL either .
Brohm ... name a good QB out of Louisville ? Oh ... Dave Ragone NFLE MVP .
Woodson ... has an arm . Does he have the experience ?
Woodson's an SEC QB that's a plus .
You trade for Quinn you don't have to pay him top 10 money .
Separate names with a comma.