Discussion in 'Texans Talk' started by Texans34Life, Dec 21, 2006.
Interesting article. I can't wait to see how this plays out in the off-season.
I do like the thoughts also, very logical IMHO.
I am just not sure I would agree to Plummer though. I have watched him for years and just feel like it would only be a lateral move.
The list of free agent qb's doesn't impress me at all. I'd still rather draft a qb in the 2nd or 3rd and let him learn behind DC for the next 2 years, rather than trade much needed draft picks away.
Either way, it will be exciting to watch the teams moves in the offseason.
All hell would brake loose if Tennessee would pick Kolb in the 3rd.
The idea of turning to Plummer concerns me. I lived in Denver for 4 years ('02 - '05) and watched Plummer 'lead' the Broncos. While he was serviceable under Kubiak, he is not the answer. He would simply be a band-aid for our team.
I have been a Kubiak fan since he was hired. But if he brings in Plummer he will drop a notch in my opinion. It would show me that he is looking at personnel decisions with blinders on. Jake Plummer is NOT superior to any and all quarterbacks that may be available. Picking up Plummer would show me that Kubiak is making decisions that are "comfortable" and "easy" rather than the best for the team.
I know coaches typically like to bring on guys that they know and are confident with. We've got a few ex-Broncos to prove it (Salaam, Dayne, Putzier, etc.). But when a coach is afraid to go outside of that comfort zone.... That's disturbing.
Just my .
So who is the QB that is available and is clearly superior to Plummer?
Well, from McClain's article, I'd take Garcia in a heartbeat over Jake the mistake. I'd also be happy (believe it or not) with Sage or Carr behind a beefed up O-Line while we have a younger prospect learning for a season or two.
If we pick up Plummer, do we have a chance to win a few more games next year? I think the answer is yes simply because Plummer is a competitor and was solid under Kubiak. But like I said, it would concern me that Kubiak is making another "comfortable" personnel decision.
No way Jeff Garcia comes here. Bob McNair wouldn't part with his "Christian family man" for a guy that's dating a Playmate.
For football reasons, I think that Garcia's on a hot streak right now. I don't expect it to last. He also happens to be playing behind one of the best OL's in the league.
If he plays behind an inferior line, he'll be running for his life again.
Garcia isn't going anywhere, or so that is what he said. He likes Philly, he likes the system, and he knows McNabb is the guy there but is willing to stay. That was said last week when they plyed the Giants. Now there is alot of time ahead and there will be offers that would be too hard to turn down, but he wants to win and he thinks Philly can give him the chance to do it.
It will be a tough sell to get an established QB here in Houston with the line they have. Not too many QB's want to get hit that often and I don't blame them. The QB position is going to be very hard to access this off season, as I would rather have Sage or Carr again,( did I say that) than an older re-tread that would have to learn everything over and last but a year or two.
The Texans need a guy they can put in there that will be around for more than a season...and if Kolb is around, get him.
I don't like the guys that are available, free agent or draft possibilities at that. I like sticking with Carr much less however...
Yeah, winning a few extra games would make me comfortable too. Maybe that should be the consideration more than worrying about prior connections. Not saying Plummer is the best solution, but in terms of FA's he has to be one of the top 2, neither of which is a long term solution.
Dude is lying--no QB, especially one at the tail end of his career is going to skip a starting QB spot to be the backup to a probowler.
As for Garcia's playmate girlfriend--yeah, right. Travis Johnson and Jerome Mathis wouldn't have ever been drafted by the Texans if character was as important as people like to make out around here. Like dating a pretty girl is a moral deficiency now.
I really doubt that Plummer would be coming in, which we would totally regret. We need to get legit o-linemen,draft Kolb in later round 2nd or 3rd, keep Carr and let him fight Sage for starting spot next year but not be a mentor to Kolb. Kubiak would put his time in with Kolb and mold him to the type of qb he wants him to be in a year or two. My biggest concern is that I hope Kolb have the opportunity to have AJ as a reciever, we can't let this guy get away, drops or no drops this guy is our #1 playmaker on the outside and if he goes, it's no telling what kind of recievers we will have. A new qb might entice AJ to stay, I sure hope soo.
A band-aid might be an upgrade for us.
It will be interesting to watch the upcoming free agency period because of the comfort zone theory. I brought up this same point while it was happening last off-season. I still think it caused some division in the locker room - us vs. them, old vs. new.
Nothing wrong with dating a pretty girl. A pretty girl that posed in Playboy and karate-kicks his ex-girlfriends (allegedly) might be a different story.
Wouldn't bother me at all. I'd welcome the excitement. I'm just thinking that McNair may not want that to be the face of his franchise after he's had to cut the cord with the current pillar of the community.
I think Rosenfels would be the right guy to groom a young QB. Kolb could learn behind Sage for a year or 2, then take over. Rosenfels led Miami to 6 straight wins to end the 2005 season. He has some ability!
Sadly you're right. To be honest, I was on the Carr bandwagon coming into this season. You know - new coaches, more weapons, better protection. It was his chance to get a 'fresh start'. But last weekend put me on the "Carr Sucks" bandwagon. I still want to support him and I hope he (and ultimately the team) does well.
Honestly, like I said earlier, Plummer may give us a kickstart.
I guess the reality that we might be pinning our team's hopes on Jake is a sobering, depressing thought for next season. They thought he would be the answer (after Griese) in Denver. He obviously was not. And he had lots of talent around him...
Where does this stuff come from? Sage played in a total of 4 games in 2005 (2 wins, 2 losses--no two straight weeks) and started just 1 (a shut out loss to Cleveland).
The article I want to read would have the following:
Why did the Texans pick up Carr's option for 3 year?
Who would take Carr's contract in a trade?
What are the salary cap implications of releasing Carr and at different times?
It's nice to be able to mention random QB names, and speculating about their fit with the offense, but I want to know how this is going to effect the team as far as being able to get other pieces and parts as well.
I personally don't see Plummer coming here unless Carr is dealt somewhere for draft picks and we pick up a QB in the draft. If we keep Carr, it doesn't make sense to pay Plummer to come in and win the starting job (which I think he would) and put a highly paid Carr on the bench. And I wouldn't mind watching Plummer work a year while we groom a quality draft pick. I like Kolb a lot. Especially if he fell to the second round. He runs a very fast paced offense at UH, seems to make good decisions and runs pretty well. Quinn and Troy Smith will probably be gone first round and I don't see us picking a QB first. I'm still itching to see a really dominant running game for the Texans and if Peterson if available, I'd hate to see us pass on him.
Separate names with a comma.